Show BOURBON IN INI I USUAL TALK Democratic Leader Clark Opposes Opposes Op Op- Op- Op poses Payne Bill Just as He l Has Done All Tariff Bills Since He Was a Stripling SAME OLD ARGUMENTS MOUTHED IN CONGRESS Same Old Arguments Are Arc Used and the Chances Are That They Will Have Same Old E Effect Absolutely None TALKS FOR FIVE HOURS 0 c. c 4 4 4 4 Washington a hlll ton March 21 For For 4 I f 9 lIve H today oila cula Chump Chuk 4 minority le lender mill and ranking Dem- Dem 4 erratic member of or the tiit v WU wat s and f 4 means committee h held 11 1 forth th on ou 4 4 the lie tariff hill bill praising 4 4 gome features condemn 1112 oth- oth 4 4 ers cm cr and nl nil flit times limes s cering by hy h the thc 44 4 4 Democratic of or tariff for Cor 44 4 4 rc enne only I The rue he House Houseas Wits as 44 4 4 Clark announced he hefa he- he 44 4 4 fa eel or-eel n fl revenue r cn lie tn t tnt on cr c every c 44 4 4 taxable article with Ith tile the exception 44 4 4 of or volt nit this exception being In iti 44 4 4 sentimental Under the exI ex- ex 4 4 I j r 5 lie ho tax tac ta 44 4 4 s o on tea fea ca lOC toffee coffee C lumber and 44 4 4 leather 4 f. L I AL J I I 4 Y r TT Y Ye e 1 t s M 4 s 0 O Clark said he was undecided as to the tho merit of or the Inheritance tax over the income tax but he would not announce announce announce an an- his position Ills his brought from Washburn of or Ma Massachusetts Massa Massa- a- a chusett a flat fiat statement In opposition to an Inheritance tax with the announcement t that he lie would It If given I en the tho opportunity move to to strike this provision from froth the bill lIe IIo char charged e It was an unwarranted encroachment en en- by tho the government on the source of or revenue peculiarly available to 0 states and that a federal tax upon It would burden It beyond reasonable point Dorc Clark began his speech Speaker nn nil Illustration of oC tho attached to to theT toe the T a m- m m r. r fl Hule Wh which h ben beTl f heralded as making radical changes ch l' l gl In the rules rule Fitzgerald Rule Tested One of tl the tho o amendments provides Wednesday shall be bo devoted to calls of calendar unless set aside by a two- two thirds third vote otc of tho the House Gardner of or Massachusetts Invoked InvoIced 1 this this' rule rulo to today todi to- to di day diHe He wanted to see If it would stand 1 knowing there were no committees committees committees commit commit- tees to call cull except those on rules mileage mileage mile mile- age us-e and ways and means and no bills billson on the House caJen calendar ar except the tariff tar tar- itt iff bill The speaker ruled the Gardner Gardner Gardner Gard Gard- ner motion out of ot order and sustained the Payne Pane motion to go JO Into committee commit commit- tee of the whole to cOnsider the tariff tar tar- itt iff bill His Ills explanation nation to Gardner was ns that the conditions were extraordinary extraordinary extra extra- ordinary and the session a special one Clark told Payne his great nine hour speech on tho the tariff puts him himIn In company with Henry Cia Clay Robert Hobert RobertJ J J. J Walker alker er Senator Morrill i William McKInley l William 1 L. L Wilson and Neson Nelson Nel Ne- elson el- el son Dingley Revision ne of or the tariff downward said Cark was v due to President Roosevelt I never nc had ah any delusions about that man He lIe Is gone he said sorrowfully Some of you ou hope he will never noel come back My regret r r t Is 11 i that he left leCt at all If Ie ho he had stayed here you would have liae been In such a n arow arow row within ninety days ays that you would woul not have known whether you OU were Republicans or Democrats He Ho read the committees committee's comparisons compari compari- sons of tho Dingley act and the Payne bill which showed the tho average rato of or Dingley bill was waa per cent cerat while under the Payne bill it Is per cent showing ono one per pel cent less Jess than the Dingle law Clark said he could not understand wh why such tuch tenderness was shown the sugar trust which he ho characterized ata aa at aaa asa a criminal He declared tl under a cut of or live five cents on the hundred pounds poun s sa a man must eat sugar ugar at top speed for Cor months to save a nickel If It he 1111 missed e a day he be would not get I I the nickle Clark Insisted ostensibly on the Cree lIst Was aa given gl protection of or from Crom to p per r cent If It opportunity opportunity opportunity op op- op- op Is given to the bill he declared the countervailing duty would g tit He lie said wid If It the Stan Standard OH oil were not the sole beneficiary lary under he the bill he would not object to revenue In favor of or crude oil producers Remove Remo this duty uty he added Sand and andi i some mo manufacturer may compete with Standard Oil by Importing crude petroleum pe pe- pe- pe This competition might re- re In less cost of or manufactured article arti arti- cle cic to consumer Crude oil pro producers will not suffer Standard Oil on now fixes s the price paid palt for cru crude c oil at a low lowI 11 figure gu r e. e I |