| Show EMINENT DOMAIN MEASURE VETOED Governor Disapproves of Smelter Smelter ter tot Rights Bill Bil at the Eleventh Hou Hour HE GIVES THREE REASONS Unconstitutional Special Legislation Legislation Leg Leg- and Against Public Pub Pub- lic lc Policy He Says Says- S DI Disapproved ed ll Is ht tin tilt Lu verdict of Governor Cutler In Iii II passing the sen sentence fence tence on un time tho bill 0 giving 1 the Ito ll right ht of eminent domain lo to sun smelters ls l's el n eu-n tt-lm tt which W was S consigned n d to the lie waste wate wastebasket basket baskel Time The reasons fur for the time action nH may nitty be le summed II up cli In iii theta these words WOIS vo id i'd S Contrary to public policy Special Specia Jda I gisla legislation iou 1 Unconstitutional I I tm I In tin I. I h Time The measure masul j is one 1110 nl that lint has hns been td lr h by ls' the time Ja largo f mining min In bug ing a and all miti s smelting I lug corporation t of Ulah I as Is a U I final solution of or lh the lie Si smelter Ir damage problem and auth the lie bill hm received tIme tho a attention iou of rif th the lie senate and hou o C of or representatives lot for several set sev eral ral days uLys before both branches of oC the tIme legislature e could finally agree CC on oum 01 a n common on eom measure e. Tho Time bill ui was re regarded re- re 1 gam as ns one of oC th the lie most important of ot tho ho mummy many that lint wore WIe lOft left for fOI the governors governor's JO consideration whon the Ic- Ic e adjourned l and there ho have lr c beon s I conferences over o cr it I in Jim tl hit tho governors governor's f office during the he last three hit days Jn in n reaching his Itis decision Governor Go Cutler has haM co considered mo tIme the views s Ic of prominent attorneys representing tho tue elements both hoU for rOl an and amid time the as os well el as giving git It hl his close chose attention Tho tm time limit 11 for foa td signing time the bills hils of oC LIme Seventh c 1 legislature e expired at ol midnight and OH as fN the thc result lesul I 1 65 hIlls bills have havo become laws Jaws a and auth 11 1 12 memorials lais have ha I passed with wih lh the approval al of if tho hi- hi governor O and amid H the lie WOI work Is fully II com com- o Iwa tt Gh he it s es 5 HIa Kea ons ns I Following ollo Is h lit h. h letter SouL sont h by time the governor go 0 to th tIme the secretary y of lf th h state glIng gl JI II Ing his hiM reasons for fol vetoing of or the time eminent emi nent domain bill 01 It I appears to ti tome 1 me mc to 0 L be contrary to public pub puh- lie lic Ic y holk-y lo to have thi the private enterprises declared een all public u uses cs and there theres s Is I n ii 1 great scat difference between th the lie right of or eminent emi Dent nent domain for dumping places and time tho right of extending that power over overa O CI a n ai o of four tithes miles Iles to the lie great Injury or that lint Int region from poisonous fumes a amit I this dust t. t The Time net act nets net's Is objectionable In that it I ls h special le legislation of th thc tho spirit and letter lettI of or thC lie constitution of or lt lit slate state which says In all In nih al cases CiUl ii a general al t a law Il can h bo Ia applicable no special law shall bo be enacted This act Iet 1 Is sime Ie CH CIHI chil for Cor the time ra reason on that it I grants the right of ot eminent domain to smelters In iii Inthe the counties where the timo population is 18 iso j o or less lew hut but withholds the rJ right ht In lii coun coun- ties tics tes with t a n larger po population ul Uon In Iii makl u nit mill ni smelters n a public u Use o but discriminating against all host In imi hIng lint hav having ni those lhost 1 a R county h in ing Ing- more than luau population lJ by declaring de dc ile- ile carll claring that htmL th they hey shall not exercIse time the rj right ht of oC eminent domain while other smelters In Jim II the thc state m do so It I becomes be be- comes collies at once one a I dal law late an and amid therefore therefore there there- fore In m my opinion c u t lii 1111 Litigation I t I iou lOl It bt I has haH been hn said all that thai If tIme he law IW Is 19 un- un ec the time courts would t so o decide de tic- chic cide Je and no tie one Ol would b be lx Injured While this lOa may be Ul ur urged C iii mm 1 favor or vor of or the mca meas measure tire ure yet ct there would woul arise arlle a I vast tast amount of or vexatious III litigation pending the tho Until decision lon Under Uner our statutes the time stud stud- smelters tnt tnt- t tom tom-S might take possession of oC property propel pending pending- ln Limo tho tlC ll litigation aton ii h by giving hinr a bond and If ir f at nt tho ito end cud of a I number of years the time act ocl was declared tIme the properly might h be lie returned lo to lothe lothe the tIme owner HO 0 o seriously rlou I damaged as to lo lobe tobe toh h be worthless The hl only l redress the owner would have u-ouM u be to enter upon another protracted course of litigation 1 to lo determine time the of uC damages Th The har hardship this WoUld work I Is clearly J eh 1 lel r Tuo Vetoed During time the forenoon CoV Governor lua Cutler l twelve bills his and Iwo o were t-ei-e ere ve- ve neiL In lit 11 house houe lull bill hi m to lu lh time manner of Hf lie salaries of county s he lie declared 11 that lint It would permit the lie county assessor and amid county tm II r to receive exorbitant tail salaries Part of oC Hi Iti Il would ouid In lie given Iven by hy time state stale and anI part by h by time the county This his bill hi he ht disapproved The Time veto teto was on senate bill lill hi J 3 which extended lie scope of the liver ec 1 livery stable keepers keeper's lien but hut It Il 10 does nol not state nn any auty period for which a n l lieu Hen n may be he ma made r With lh the lie amount open Governor Go Cutler Cuter Unit timid hutan an any amount of le Ir Urn hit II might ht be lie charged for forIn in tilLer after It I leaves heat rl Ico time the lJ possession e llon of or the LIme owner despite tIme the tw fact act that lint It I might lint have changed hands a number of times Tho rho following bills lIlis Ills approved tl and tiled with lie tho I secretary of state S S. S H. H SIC ir tl time the duties dutes of the lit state stale hoar board of or land c loin rs and Us itS IH members or from becoming In lands beil being tiled Died U ulon upon 1011 S. S H. H Ii making It Il time the tw dUl duty of the lie secretary sec ace ce- ce tai y of or to lo am and tile le with wih county recorders erH certified tran transcripts o of all al public lands selected by hr time the tt state Ie machines S. S n 13 8 82 to lo the hue use o of oll young voting S S. S II n. relating lo to Jow powers S r of the time sui- sui suoI I pi Ill OntO emu court IT IL I 1 IL B. ILo CM o J. J relating to appeals from time the justice courts S. S B IJ B. 18 i to tu the lie courses ses H of In Instruction II- II at time the University of or Utah I II II I. I It B. IA I O establishing a u state stale board ot or sheep commissioners lonca H S. S II n. 10 JO relating to lo the IcIs re of to voters te us H 5 8 U 13 IJ J ii I relating to water seater rights I II I. I I I n JI J Jh LJ adult delinquency S S. S J JJ H. M O time the practice practIce- of or hal bat hem lu S. S IJ B 16 a ii I new flair dairy and food bill 1111 hi providing pro miro- viding a against adulteration of foods foody JI li- li etc dc S S. S Ii H. IS 1 transcript of oC approved ed laud land lall lt lists to lo bo hO hI Hied with wh thu vacuity county recorders record record- ers era rl In Iii various counties S S. B If d defining duties s of or time the staL land board ll |
