Show SENATOR SMOOT IS IS VINDI VINDICATED RETAINS SEAT BY MARCIN Colleagues Support Utah Man by Vote of 42 to 28 Ending y Long Controversy Over Right to Continue as of oJ Member Congress t MANY SPEECHES MADE DURING CLOSING HOURS HOURS' iI Senators Sutherland and Spooner Were WorD Unable to Talk in inI I Support of Provo Prove Man Owing to Long Longi i Address of Burrows v j VOTH o ii OX SMOOT CASH CASE IN IX TIll Til 15 SI i Ut f Cla Clay a k To 1 expel tI iI It iry Ih-iry i t 3 I Clarke t t II I HulI F ra l I lI I l 11 11 Mt 1 ci Ion Nc 1 ii t O II I ctt ts I Ha lItI Simmon- Simmon Stone Hult h I u u o t LaFollette Smith I tel iii Iti hit Is Total itI 28 8 I e. BC I La gue I ii I Leicy Le- Le Not XIII lo 10 t e o. h fl rk I i A Alleo lIet I Iee A AnKeny iy es l' l icy ley Ie lark Clark of ot Crine Cuilis Dick Hid 1111 I t er Flint I Ler II IrV C Itil Fulton ott Callin cr Jumble I II Icy Icy- Mi It hel 31 haitI t 1 II iii II hr burn ii I Hopkin- Hopkin I t l' l Ij ii III CIOtI Nixon I e. e rik Spooner Sutherland Warner Warren War ren reit I its ji Clark Cut ih of f 1 II II In Daniel To- To ml I 12 L i Republican Special Service I Washington Feb 20 O Ith With the gal sai- I JerIc packed mostly with women am and extending nut flUt Into corridors cor the Zite vote on Oil I Ito tho UP ol ul o l' l of f hi his seat eat at was Vas taken promptly at al I t Th The c. c final OnRI or oi record oC vote vole e was VaS 1 12 for Cot moot Smoot anti and S a against t al him Ii teen senator were 11 paired on ott the cIU bringing bri tigi tig the th e actual act ott I voto vu t o and a I id paired jaired up ul to 10 51 SI IP tp 37 7 7 III in favor a al' al l' l of lC the lie retention of it lie lUah senator 6 The Thc en entire etIlio lire strength of or the senate ellale with the Ch exception tC f f. f two senator Smoot t It III elC ni Senator sto c o J WA lOr I tn I h n tho tte to filial volo VOtO was r r rit it J tI I l o OMIS n. n liati Di-liati 11 Tho h ho t J debate tc va VIl opened by i and HI closed by bo In Iii a voice olec that leached almost lo to a l W charged char that Senator Smoot vas was a b. b bv t n a i nf V UJ J EL f fourth JL UL wife IC JUM and I lh that i ih h he lie j had ci married ici I n ii woman who l was also aIlS a u. polygamist l. l Senator e to th the wife wiCe of Senator Smoot was wu considered to tobe be he In lit exceedingly I poor taste Tho rho re remainder remainder re- re of or his speech was along alons the Iho theline tholine line of or his previous speech on un the subject He lie was wa- followed follo by lJ Senator E Id Idge c Senator said that the Pt greatest wrong that hint be done clone an any man was waN Ow ruin mitt of his i when his hh lire life had bad been stainless and anti this was vas what whal was WaN wa being done clone III In thin the from Utah He lie cate caie of oC the lie directed particular attention to lo the thin that thai Senator Scan Sena generally prevalent opinion l. l The tor Smoot was wa a a polygamist t million of oC petition signers he Lie said saili cd lh lie sentiments of a LUISIn- LUISIn EO fOl-ancel fOl l public Ho lIt road read to tu the tho senate ninny many mall ludicrous 5 clippings from newspapers news news- of oC which was waK published r papers H ono one ti l. l soon after th the tho Burrows Burrows' speech against rf Senator Smoot some than lime ago fI of Poi tj e II C One Olle stated that hint Burrows hind shown In Iii bl his speech that thai Se Senator i had 11 five wives and amI seven forty E three c of whom were born 4 during lie present year I Senator tor spoke aSti it k Senator He lIt I said his hiM opposition nol hot hostile l to III or nl nut of IC lack latic c of f I 10 Ie C- C J to tl ti the Utah laii senator I In ii part parl he it id lOIn Iii sending its H apostle lu-ie lu hl e th e l inn managers lingers ah a always a r Kl i In iii nr the political I iii Interests Ici ts o otheir of oC their leaders leade furnished lIni hc 1 us with another an an- other sample of brazen effrontery li In further the public soul of tho the country relative to tu the obnoxious ious ions Institution fu fo for which they Lucy are He ro ru- Spi tin it In Senator Foraker wild aid in Iii part paiL XII No cu e whatever has been nw made l' l that will ihl HI justify us tie In lit either vacant the thin at ai-at 01 ir ii expelling the thic s cn- cn r front from Ut Utah dl He Tie j is wj u good man mUll that I almost doubt him He I ie has haf 10 io vices lie He lees does not drink 01 or anul or 01 chow chew or i s r 1 null h ho Is It not ji it t J miJi F ruts III lJ ll Hn of o- o l' l r rt 11 t tho p I Q U i a of which j fic b HIP pi omo r. r 1 said Kahl that he ho was wa In lit favor of depriving Senator S Smoot of oC hl his weal sent but I C hat hal nil only nitty I 1 tl wa way vay to do It was h by I su-n. su u L' L I Senator el v lands lie lit n nj t Senator character anti and would be he If con con- would permit a vote vole In lii hl his his- favor but hut thai thal he Ill would vote vole against him He lie said the Iho Mormon on church had become a factor fa tol in iii Nevada He Senator Burrows closed thC tho Ing In He lIe sai l that since his hiLs original speech of or We weeks ks ago I thin the debate h ho lie lint had after attN listening to the Iho opposing ln arguments nothing to add addor or 01 detract from what he lie then said I He tie analyzed the testimony of oC certain ncr ncr- tain Mormon apostles and other oU high members of ur tho the church before the Iho senate senite I investigating lUnS' lUnS committee mitt e cc and a ad pointed out that there had boon been pol poly poly- marriages since the mani I festo resto 1 11 I Not Xul ot In lii Support Sti He lie t said that It if thought hl lie tho President supported th the tho attitude is the the- Mormon chi chuich the they wore mistaken and read maLl extracts from Crom the Presidents President's les ent's last message e to con congress Ic on oil the lie subject cl of uC If the marriage marriage mar mal c and divorce in lit which he lie recommended mended a constitutional amendment against polygamy Promptly at atI I I 4 the vico president Continued oh ch Pago Jago m Eight ht it 4 4 t 4 I 7 r d V I f E ii s' s I r s. s 4 1 7 l' l S 'S Si I i i mm SM SMOOT OWl 11 lo Jh Johnson k b SENATOR SMOOT IS IS VINDICATE VINDICATED Continued From Flom Paso Page One Ona announced that under the unanimous consent the agreement had be bee on reached that the voto vote must be I Jm- Jm in mediately mc taken Senator Hopkins then offered a n an amendment to perfect the commute committee resolution which provided for Cor exclusion sloe slon The Hopkins amendment Inserted Inter Insert ed the iho words two thI two ds o of the tho senate senate senate sen sen- ate concurring thereby changing ln th tho Burrows resolution from one ono of or ex ex- ex elusion to ono one of or expulsion two two third third being necessary for expulsion Th The Hopkins amen amendment ment was adopted b by bythe the following vote voto Yeas Y a AIIce Al AI Al- Al Ice lee Ankeny Bacon Dacon De Black Blackburn burn Bi ee Bulkeley Burkett Burnham Dunham Carmack Clapp p. p Clark o or Montana 1 Clark of ot Wyoming Crane Daniel Depew Dick ham er Dolliver Flynt Foraker Forake Frye Fulton Gallinger er Gamble Heyburn Hopkins Kean Knox Lodge Lod e McCreary McCumber McCumber Mc Me Cumber Millard l lull l Mulkey c Nelson Newlands Nixon Overman Penrose Perkins Piles Plies Proctor Spooner Ston Stone Sutherland Tillman Warne Varner and Wan Warren aon en Total 49 19 Nays as Berry BOrr Burrows Clark 01 of or Arkansas Cla Clay Culbertson Curtis Dubois Dupont Frazier Hale Hansbrough Hans Hans- brough h. h o. o Ls La Follette Latimer I Long ron ong Money lonc Pettus I Rayner Simmons am an and William Alden Smith Total 22 Among tho the senators who were unable unable un un- able to lo secure time today tony for speeches were Senators and Sutherland lan 1 Many desired to speak but hul w were re prevented pvc pre vented from doing dohl so by b the amount of time which Burrows tool took up starting his closing speech as h he did lid a little after 2 Senator Smoot tonight declined t to tomake make any comment on the thc lie vole nic nl hond hut hat It wa was wag what he lie had expected Utah Ulah Uta h Delegation elc a Pleased Senator Sutherland said I J am glad Iad the he caso case is J over and the theote vote ote t is Is what I expected It would b bt be I Iun gratified since ince the thu beginning am hat that the C case lse Is ended and out of or the tho vay Representative Howell Unwell I am cx- cx gratified at the line theote vote tote today h It Is what I 1 expected With Vilh Hh his this l long ng drawn out contest over o tl c k can n now nV V give Its undivided forts efforts for 01 the state tate Senator Newland's Newlands vote ote was wasa a sur- sur irise It is said Mid that Burrows and Dubois cd with the Nevada sentor sen- sen atol tot tor last night The speech made male by hy Hansbrough h as a n reply to Senator Beveridge e ea a and d da a written memorandum was vas s sent nt to toI him I lin i front from the thc gallery presumably by Dr r. r W M 1 P of Salt Lake Two o votes otes welo taken on amendments amendments amend amend- ments lents before the final linal roll was held hell ringing the issue down lown downIn to tn whether or not ot of two thirds of or the senate c concur concur- neur- neur ring ing Smoot should be bo expelled The were cleared after tho the vote yote wag as taken Lodge having ha moved an session and the crowd crowll warned swarmed out while Senator Smoot tool ok pole the g seat scat al which will twill be his without with with- out ut further di dispute lluto for Cor the two remaining re- re mining years of o his term Substitute Is U Defeated The fhe Burrows resolution having haYing thus ecu perfected by vote ote so as to make male It a resolution of expulsion ion requiring g ga a two-thirds two vote voto for or its adoption Senator Carmack then offered a substitute sub- sub for Cor the tho entire tiling thing in t the form of f a resolution providing pro directly and for expulsion The Car- Car mck substitute was lost by a n. vote of ot 27 to 13 43 the theote vote voto being as as follows Carmack Carmack Carmack Car- Car Yeas Bacon Yeas Bacon Berry Burrows mack Clapp Clarke of Arkansas CIa Clay Culbertson Dubois FrazIer Hale Hansbrough Ket- Ket e La Follette Latimer McCready Mc Mc- Crear Creary Cready McLaurin Money Newlands Overman Pettus Simmons Smith Stone and anti Tillman Total 27 Nays Nays Aldrich Aldrich Alice Allec Ankeny Beveridge Bev- Bev Beveridge Beveridge Blackburn burn Buckley Buck Duel ley Icy Burkett Burnham Clark of or Montana Montana Mon Mon- Ion Ion- tana Clark Clarl of Wyoming Crane Curtis Curtis Cur Cur- Us Daniel Depew Di Dick k Dillingham Dolliver Dupont Flint Foraker Frye Fulton l Gallinger Gamble Heyburn Hopkins Ican I ean Knox Lodge Long McCumber Millard Mulkey Nelson elson Nixon Penrose Perkins Piles Spooner Spoon Spoon- er cr Warner Varner and antl Warren anen Total 43 13 I Resolution He 1 Downed o The Tho question of or tho the adoption of or the Burrows resolution n as perfected was then put and the r resolution which l II it adopted d would have necessitated expulsion expulsion ex ex- was defeated by a n record vote of 28 to 42 The voto vote was as follows follows follows fol fol- lows Y Yea Yeas Republicans Republicans a Burrows Clapp Dupont Hale Utile Hansbrough Hemenway Kittredge gc- gc La Lan Follette and William Alden Smith of or Michigan Total 9 9 Democrats Bacon Berry Bc Carmack Clarke of or Arkansas Clay Culbertson Dubois Frazier Latina Latimer McCreary McCleary McLaurin 1 Money one Newlan Newlands Newlands New- New lan lands s. s Overman O Pettus Rayner naner SUn Sim Simmons mom mans Stone Stono and 1111 man Total lt 19 Aggregate ate yeas cas 28 28 S. S NAys Nays Democrats Democrats Blackburn Clarl Clark of Montana Io Daniel of ur Total To To- tal tat 3 Republicans Aldrich lIce Alice Ankeny Beveridge DuckIe Buck Duck Ie Icy Burnham Clark o of Wyoming 11 Crane Curtis Dick Dillingham ham Dolliver Flint Foral er Frye l Fulton ulton Gallinger er Gamble Hey Hey- Heyburn Heyburn burn buin Hopkins us Kean Knox Lodge Lon Long McCumber Millard rd Mulkey of ot Oregon Nelson Nixon Ixon Pom oe Perkins lerl Pile Piles Sutherland Warner at net and Warren Total 39 Aggregate nays 4 42 Eighteen EI Were cre Paired faired There were eighteen senators senator's paired pair pair- JI paired lr- lr ed cd as follows follows- Whyte hyte Wh te of or Maryland for rOl expulsion with Teller relict o of Colorado who was against expulsion Morgan 1 of oC Alabama for rOl expulsion lon with Allison against expulsion Balle Bailey Kalley of oC T Texas for expulsion lon with of or West Vest Virginia Vir Vir- ginia against expulsion Patterson of Colorado for expulsion with willi Carter Caller of Montana against expulsion loll Martin Marlin of Virginia for fOl expulsion with Cullom of or Illinois against expulsion lon Foster of I Louisiana for expulsion with ith Dr Dryden en enot of ot New ew Jei Jer ey y against a expulsion McEnery Mc- Mc Ic- Ic Enery Ellery of Louisiana for 01 expulsion with will Platt Plait of or New Kew York Yak against a expulsion Talla Talia Fc Ferro ro of or Florl Florida a for expulsion with Scott of oC West We t Virginia against expulsion Mallory Mallor of or Florida 1 for fOl ev- ev with Proctor of ot Vermont against ag expulsion MANY Y 1 WO WOMEN lEX T. ln EST Alo Ihn Croud ul Galleries es Before Taking of or 1 Vote ote ote V Fob 20 In In the tho presence pros pros- enco ence of or 2000 people moro more than onehundred one ono hundred being members of ot the hou house e of ot representatives the senate senat toda today voted that Reed Heed Smoot may retain his hilt seat eat as senator from Utah This dis disposes poses c finally of or a controversy contro that for tor forthe forthe the last four years als has been be n fought I In lobby lobb and committee rooms room It In and out opt of or season and In Ii which millions trillions ot or women have enlisted In what is now proven to be hc the losing los side Through the two days das of ot speechmaking speech- speech speechmaking speechmaking making that preceded the thc vote Semi Sena Senator ena- ena tor Smoot tint riot allent and stolid n ns as ho he hohas has sat Mt through the tho man many litany long lonK big Ing sessions of or the thu senatorial committee com coin mille that investigated hl c jl tc his right to JO o f 4 t the tho upper house hous state in represent his of congress When hen Beveridge g was comparing his hiR case to lo the martyrdom insisting Insisting Insist Insist- of or Dreyfu Dreyfus when was moral man manthan manthan manthan more m a mor ing In that he Iw was in tho rho bo body of or than man members rs many which he hc sits and when Burrows and I denouncing him hint and Newlands Newlan s were his church as enemies c of the tho nation his attitude was unchanged Now and then his teeth teth would set under his long lon drooping moustache or tho ha blood would rise to hl his temples but hut the crowd clowd that overflowed o l the lie gallet galleries ics and the representatives that stood in ina Ina ina a triple rank manic in the back of or the chamber ch would scarce have discovered that ho was the thc man about whom tho the battle was raging rasing so s cn energetically n hadnot had hal hadnot not his figure figuro so 80 o long been familiar In the senate Senator tor Smoot Not ot lc Present cn t. t When hen the speeches were finished at 4 o'clock and Vice President Fairbanks Fair banks announced shortly that It was the tho time agreed l upon for a vote ot Senator Senator Senator Sen Sen- ator Smoot rose and anti walked slowly out of or the tho chamber into the cloak room where hero he ho paced nervously back and forth while the tho roll call was AVOS being taken Ho He did not know what the result re result result re- re |