Show j TILLMAN IN TILT WITH PATTERSON ON NEGRO NE RO QUESTION t Denunciations Ring Through Senate Chamber Which Is Crowded to Doors With Interested Auditors c y y Who Applaud Frequently COLORADO MAN HAS PITCHFORK OF HIS 1113 OWN r fl I V t r aj l' l c South Carolinan Charged Wit With Ii h Championing a Policy That i 1 4 1 X t 4 Wb WOuld ld Make North Solid Republican and South En Entirely En- En n- n J. J I. I 1 ly Democratic in in III Senate I r r i t J V Washington D. D C. C Jan l 12 The The The I r. r senate enate mat chamber rang with denunciation t tion Uon today roday Senator of f oft I led th the Pr t t. t J c J v South Carolina a awn President 1 I of the United States for hI his discharge bt t tT T of Ir negro troops from the thC army and j held h lt for COl or creating a n ae I e j 0 condition of race hatred that would In th the tIie near r result In a throat thoat t cutting t Senator Pa Patterson of nt Colorado who wo retires from public life March 4 4 ast as- as t loun t l the senate by lW a denunciation J He lie charged South Ct J. J him 1 with Ith advocating o HI lawlessness nod and championing a policy t that hat If persisted persist eu ed In would soon oon make the tho n S from the north solidly Republican I lican t IHl I the Uw SOLI I Males solidly Democratic The Tue South repeatedly S hurled defiance at nt the head of If the Ow S 'S Colorado man but hut the effect If nn any 5 was wa-s va to nuke make Mr h Patterson on more mOIl emphatic em cm- i cm-i In his hIM declarations lIe He narrowly oar nar f 1 wi l' l escaped l however having his c 0 words tI l-tI tl reported from the tile pr lel 1 Ic I- I r f de desk Under I the he cu customs customs- of f the h Donate would O oten benI uJ h his 11 l nf f n t Ue tt Uj LI- LI Imm oL 11 Jt Ct r V Jf I l pm hn tbS t 1 f t w 1 11 R t 11 to r 1 f 1 o lm hant Mr t Mon Money II Insisted i tel that the governor gov go 11 01 had been heen n 1 misrepresented I. I um and altho 1 although h lh Colorado senator de de- Glared clarell that he had not nol meant n to re reS rl re- S I upon the Governor Go the tin tI l 19 contended fol for th the accuracy ac ac- curacy of his position po by calling fo for fOI fOIth the th reading of the notes of or the stenographer It was vas a dramatic moment nt A Almost linos every Cry light sit In the tn chamber was wa pled pied The fur couches luch in the rear ream heldman held huh man many members of the house Em Em- of the senate were ranged lang tI along lh he walls wall Time The gallery all IY could conic I hold no more morl The rhe enl of or the I gallery all I was vas IN reserved t. ed for fm senators the thc I aisles nl were Irl tilled filled and handsome gowned women were wel crowded l in the thc narrow space between b t l en the last la t tier tir of seats cats and tho the wall Members embe o othe of the families of th the foreign m members were WE're In the th diplomatic gal gallery lery ry Len LeadIng Lead Lead- Ing log from the tiit minors doors of all nil the galleries Into the cot i K ere ll el hundreds 01 of people peOlI white while and hind black who ha had I been standing for hours hour In the hope that thai they might find flud a place Inside For two hours and a half th tIme the bitter criticism of or Senator Tillman had hind bee bC II listened d 10 to with II the deepest t Interest t The hc tension lon wo was hl high h. h A A. A moment ol or of relaxation followed follo the conclusion lon of nf I the he SoU South iii speech n was lightened d by the caustic tlc criticism o of time the pugnacious senator from flom Colo Coin rado rato Sr Senator Senator- t GIl Grave When IUn Mr tr l Moneys Money's demand wn was ns put l bv by v the vice president t senators C looked I exceedingly I grave C Mr 11 Patterson's Pattersons on fulp ae lIu Hushed deeply Turning to In Mr MiS Mi Jie he explained ll that If JC he hp had hadi i reflection I upon the gO aJ f. f It r tl lt hal 7 iU rII he I II jl of r. r J JN N u. u t. t 1 44 J l S JA t l 1 th h 4 to HH nh U nt 1 not I him hint c ln ed ett Il Mr h Money tone t fet 11 the I I 1 withdraw m my m request reading of the stenographers stenographer's R notes This ended the Incident but not th the discussion lon Tho galleries never en enjoyed enjoyed tn en- joyed themselves an any more Although the subject un under r discussion was wag the I Foraker rc resolution providing 1110 for or an Investigation t of the Presidents President's personal personal per per- I power to discharge the n negro ro troops and notwithstanding the tho belief that tho the fate of one or more moie political l cal eal aspirants hun hung In the balance The Thep unusual good humor prevailed spectators p were Impartial They laughed heartily over the telling hit hits I and ond there thole were many of them The i Vice Presidents President's l gavel tell fell frequently but hut not harshly A quiet quiel admonition was given at one time lime that applause in n the thC galleries II s of or the th antI Hoo lt sentiment was not permitted but It was advanced In such an Inoffensive wa way by hy the Vice President that thul the spectators seemed to look Ionic upon II it n as encouragement Mr Ir Tillman's Tillmans declaration nHon atton that the th South would perish I If necessary In Its light tight against oqual- oqual Ity Hy with vilh tin the negroes brought vigorous applause from flo u a number In tIn the senators senators' sena sena- tors' tors private gallery l' l 1 Asks 1 for fill When hen Mr MiS Tillman had hall concluded Mr Do remarked that Inasmuch inns Inas much as he had gone to some sone trouble to present nt a i. i condition he ime would like him to lo present som a. a solution n Lot u us UK hoar from the senator from Indiana replied Mr 11 Tillman I have ha already occupied 0 over 01 1 two hours Mr B gt was Insistent The rIte 8 senate nat I am nm sure tm would be delighted to hear the senator st several eral hours hour's more If Ie that length Ie nth of time was wal re required re- re by hIm him to tn E nt his reme remedy Mr Tillman TilIman wild Fad the be remedy reined should come conic from those p who brought about aboul the condition Loll and those e who were re- re for cau causing in It U. It was ns thon then that Mr 11 Patterson got the Iho floor Ho He paid saul that he would pre jue- for fei not to continue the discussion but being a n Democrat he lie f felt hIs hiM silence might bo he construed ar an giving full assent assent assent as as- sent to what whal hail had been ben said f lie I pointed out lilt that at present lh there le were on ott n Page Two T TILLMAN TILTS TS WITH PATTERSON Continued from ruin lit JH e Oust One only four foul a senators from rom northern stales and that t after atter March 4 oJ t there would be only two They rh appear to 0 be lw I the he best that can be bl produced up lip there exclaimed lI d Mr Tillman Later Latel ho lea declared In ht response 1 to grilling th the Jo senator from Crom Colorado ado thinks he lw alone about Is for fOl the lit wifely ly of tr th the Democratic party but bUl I T W want him to understand that If there thero Is n never nr r another I emo senator senator sen sen- ator from flom th the North Forth the tho people from ruin the tho South Houth will stand tand against the tho negro until they perish He lie declared that ho represented the I views of tho the people of or his state lato I I dont don't care whether the people of or Colorado Colo Colo- rude rado It or not he shouted He lIe challenged 11 Mr 11 Patterson to moot meet him himIn I In debate In Colorado on the the- race ques ques- Ion Hon In repudiating r the tho charge that thaI his hll 9 views were Injuring i the Democratic Democrat Democrat- ic party parly ii Mr l r Tillman l So o s far tar a as m my own party parly in ht the trio North is I concerned It hn has such shilling exam exam- examples i 1 pies ples of or ward politic Inn and told low luty creatures crea- crea tures who lI List uvo l' l their thi-ir I means to buy votes totes j that I 1 do du not cart can if we wt never r have any of or that type to lo Lack back of u u. u ul in the South Lift ills Message In I n nil nit 1 ranching 1 As l Mr 11 Patterson was vas reading a message of President nt on lynching r Money Ion y Interrupted a him to 10 tap tay a that the mine inure writer had In hl his 1115 bo book on Ranch Hanch Life tl defended ned wholesale sale lynching of or horse thieves i In hl Idaho Ho lie Inquired how the tho th senator would classify till the President Mr rushed to a t defonso of his hh stale II JI declared with warmth that It never lr h had a t lynching Mr Ir Patterson Pat Pat- terson telson tf 1 said he Il probably hash had make u a um m mistake t In t the ht location tin 11 l I Air Mr r. r Money honey I on taunted tin lIe Colorado senator III on en wh what t ho Iw declared was wa the th wholly and Ineffectiveness of nf the ilia 1 government of that status stall during the cite mining strike I Upon request of AI fl Foraker hl his Isla rj went wont o e over r until Monday wizen when Mr II Spanner Spooner Mr Air Mallory and Air I r. r Clay may It it While Mr II Tillman was wa denouncing tho the President for fOI advocating equal treatment for COlot colored etl men In uniform Mr 1 Nelson of or Minnesota n asked leel Would the Ow senator deny that tent nt Int-nt n nt If the Hi soldier was a white white man Of OC course not lint ted elm i Mr Air Fill mats mall I want him him to lo get gel the th treat treat- rt n nl that It Is given I f n all all' white teen men Why hy h not accord the colored soldier r fi AArne same rights queried Air Mr I r. r Nelson I il a Mash lash rune came the retort He It C cause God Almighty made the colored tl man mun and amI did not Lint make male him white Tho want senate roared over vrr a Joke Jok at nt the of the White While House f Mr MI Tillman was vas emphasizing the extent of caste cast prejudices Negroes can not get equal accommodations at our loading leading hotels I an any anymore anymore more than the they could at the White WhiteHouse House and not as OR easily emlIy as they could there he lie exclaimed He III referred to 0 President t tas as III the time uiKi great and good goodfriend goodfriend friend and apostle of oC the tho negro To 10 the charge of Ml fl of or Texa Texas that he Iu- differed d from Crom the tho po Donator pona- pona tor tOl from Ohio Mr At Tillman exclaimed in in- defending his hiM position The fh senator from ruin Texas knows known ow that I 1 am not such uch a n. big fool a as all nil that Information Vm n Wanted I Air Mr Culberson ThatA all aU 1 11 wanted the senator to lo admit Air 11 Tillman scornfully We Well Nell I you ou didn't expect mo me tc to deny It It did you Sett In declaring Hint tI the tho PI Presidents President's order of nr dismissal had hAil placed tJ IJ a brand brandon on nn every discharged soldier M tr Tillman Till man remarked that lint one onn of theta them Sergeant Ser Ser- Sergeant geant was WUK reported to 0 be b. a South hell HeJl not come hack back It would nut not he ho healthy for fol him he lw exclaimed Would tin the senator kindly tell us what would happen if he dl did return mildly Inquired Mr Ir Foraker I 1 will get t to tn the race question later Inter on on and dont don't you fret Tillman shouted as av he Ill faced time the Ohioan I 1 dont don't want the lire fire alarm to lo go off arC until th the hell boll rings Sensation and laughter If there Isn't lInt a 1 change In ht policies H he declared the th senate enato will soon he h. solidly r Republican from tho the North and antI so solidly Democratic froin the South I submit that such Ruch a tL speech a as we wc just heard Is IN not tint Intended to soften or racial u. u asperities I has lias the senator from rom Colorado e over ever 1 boon been In the black belt bell of or Alabama Alabama Ala Ala- bama or nr Mississippi Inquired Mr Air lie Ho has haq not nol was th the response Air Mr Ir Tillman I r IL it tv uld be uC hotter better for the senator Sl to si dy y the situation at close range ranC th there re Instead of ot theorizing In Colorado Air rJ Patterson said It was wn Idle to talk of or the separation of or the ra m rapes Ps as they mh mast t continue to live II together In Inh thc iho same country I 1 Imn imagine that even the senator from rent South Carolina would oppose deportation of or them m. K it Menus I ln- ln Destruction It would be he the tho most cruel anti and must most Infamous p proposition ever prest pre pre- shouted Air Mr Tillman st tt tl Would t. t to God we Wt didn't hays have the tho blacks black t to God Cod they he novel never came to my sIll state II h he continued But expatriation t tion COli would he be their theil destruction Air 11 Patterson in tones of or sarcasm said hl h he did die not want to Impugn the he motives but bu t he lie thought though t i Hers Hers' was wat a n reason for tOJ his attitude that was waR more moro controlling than Hu the moral question that involved ol In Involved thal d-thal that was 1 the tilt commercial side South Carolina can not afford to lus lose h her I negroes She needs them m I Air Mr Ir Tillman resented the imputation imputation tion inn lh that t he was teas not sincere He Ill declared that a race conflict was wa im ln- ml 1111 t. t When th the throat cutting 1 conies comes those who theorize In hl Colorado will not mint be he there ho IW exclaimed I Tillman on nn the lit riddle I Mr 11 Patterson on kept the chi South Caro- Caro on nn the grf griddle tJ lIe He hip on his al advocacy of oC before f Il lecture 1 l Of If It the lit semi or OJ could IJ lio bi the J- J t- t 1 II I ISe e with i t tm ich-tm f t t 1 I t n Ki t IU 1 Ii J 1 kh h w vim ild i Rte c o 0 SOl S. o th did not t Iland alone ainne in it its d ant anther her women be protected l lie declared When hen people applaud expressions of In lawlessness sn 1 till they n ore are rl not mint the till best s1 elements In the I North retorted ll Mr I Patterson on I |