Show AVI HATS FATS TIlE THE TIC USE USEl 5 To the average re resident of or Utah S ho who sees yesterdays yesterday's cartoon In the Tribune the query quer hats hats hat's the use uso J 1 must suggest Hs Itself t. t If I you have not J. J I 5 seen the picture In question let us 5 give o It fair d description S. There Thero is a 0 group composed of one man man and and seven even women The women S are arc of varying age grouped so that the tho oldest of ot the number Is farthest removed both In distance and LAS n iTi relative grouping from the man S w wIn who w occupies the center That cen- cen S. S rat Iral figure Is an old man man man-a a man with wih S abundant gray gry beard and the smooth pate which bespeaks ago and at least leasta S. S a a.- n chance for tor wisdom I dom He lie holds s in one obe hand a n sort of crosier crosler from which extend seven cords one Cne to each of the thE women At the end cud of oC each cord Is nL Imitation hand and anil each ech woman S cl clasps this d device le e. e and all al turn hll urn theirS their thel faces to that man manin mann In the the center The picture Is so cleverly drawn that both distance and relative re regard rd are ex- ex tX- tX 1 d. d The oldest woman of oC the theS S 1 group Is at tho the back of or the man her tige Dge and Infirmities dl distinctly shown That one next to her In all al that should lie le venerable J la Is as far Cal from Crom the the central but not quie quite so o oS S Indifferent to the significance of oC the pose o oi of her picture companions The Tho next In iii point of ot age age Is a little nearer the central figure and a little less to her Surroundings Atthe At Atthe Atthe the feet teet of or the old matt mart sits felts ono one who lias ha been heen supplanted I J by two who Is two removes remove from the th place of or present prese present pres pres- e ent ent- favor faor Ther Is regret and sorrow sorrow sor sor- 1 row OW In her face keen face keen though con con- trolled ed At t th the side f side of or the man and ard 0 leaning on his shoulder r with wih that at attitude at- at Q of which b speaks ales the I necessity ly of ot expression Is one moro more recent In favor faor And on the old mans man's knee sits alls the tw light of ot the harem theS tho the S nt pet pd and favorite of r the tho masS mash mas mas- h S i. i f Lr A 4 ter youth youth beauty grace combining to tell tel the stor story of ot her preferment This Is a n cartoon from Puck a aNew aNew aNew New York publication which seeks to amuse To Its audience It I presents the picture that audience being misinformed formed Is pleased to believe beleve It I Is as corroboration of or an Impression Ion sion that already exists And It has that effect It I Is captioned Holding Hands In Ulah Utah Conception skill In drawing humor all al combine to a fix fx that group Group In the tue tl memory of the reader a and nd It will wi ha have vo that effect Essentially the Import of or the picture plc- plc ture turo Is a brothel Import There Is not noth h ii suggestion u J ston so dominant as ns that of or 1 lust of heartless depravity cpr v I of selfishness selfishness selfish selfish- ness so o perfectly animal that the hope- hope It th the tue unfathomable depths of or It ft o ha overshadow ow all al the picture It I Is the Easterners Easterner's l Idea ea of or domestic life In Utah It I Is what ho has has been been told exists here It Is put forward as the type of life here as tho the representative live tive home grouping It I will wili wJ assert aSelt with wih what old oM Tom Torn Taylor called clel the pencils pencil's laugh that that thai Is the tho typical the representative domestic establishment establish establish- ment of Utah And Just just In the meas nicas ure that assumption Is untrue unlue tin the Puck Puch cartoon hurts hurt Utah But there Is a basis for or e defeno Ii In InUs 11 I Us its original publication The artist t knows his audience He lie knows their Impression of Utah conditions and ami au I that It will wi be easier casler to corroborate I that impression than to correct It lt I easier casler to concede than reform more profitable to fall fal In line Jno than to reverse re verse opinion He lIe le has ha no reason a as I I tIC they tiey have no desire to servo selvo Utah What's hats Utah to him or hit or to Utah A Alace place lace about which fun run may ho he made malle a n community where the relations olmen ormen ot or otmen men and women ar ark supposed to be a Jest And so h he makes his cartoon cartoon- al and It IL wakes a smile smie and plants aa an al L LS Impression or 01 strengthens one already alread S planted plante and he lie draws his pa pay pal But Dut wh why print U it I In lii Utah Vh Why affirm af at- a- a firm on the ground that the stOl story of oC that cartoon Is true Why hy corroo- corroo into lato Iato the Impression lon Innocent Innocently acquired ac ac- ac- ac that the essential bestiality the h heartless tes brutality of oC that pictured life Is typical of oC anything In Jn Utah Why f soy say to tho the Easterner Yes DYes that's life In Utah Ulah that's true true And reproduction tion ton In a local paper means Just that lint that The two thousand Ea Eastern tern subscribers of oC tho the Tribune see It I approvingly copied on the front page of a Salt Sal Lake Lale paper and they can not possibly pos pos- ios- ios sibly have an any other othel Impression than that It I Is admitted as true tue Is It I true truc true true-of oC the owner of or the Tribune Trib Trl- tine une Ule Is It true of ot his associates In business Is It true of ot an any one with wih whom he deals deals In trade or 01 mingles socially Is it ii true of t an any representative tie tive citizen of Salt Lle Lake l Is it 11 true true true- In Its is message of of any one ole anywhere Is that life le In lit Utah Not Kot at all al Then wh why print It I What Is the resultant of that printIng printing print print- ing irig The Thc Easterner finding confirmation confirma tion ton of oC what he ho had been told o of Utah Utah for the appearance In a Salt SaU Lake paper makes for Cor confirmation confirmation- S. S says sS s'S I r 1 do not care car to go there thero to live I r do not care to take my family fam fam- amIly am- am I ily to a place where such conditions exist exist I r do not not want to In Invest In- In vest st st mone money there that If-that Is the domestic domestic do do- condition In Utah Utah and and It certainly thinly Is Is or the states state's own paper would not so proclaim It It-It It I-I I It Is no place for Cor decent people people Why hy should a Utah man contribute to that decision 7 And why should he Ho lie le to make that contribution |