Show SENATE LIKELY Y TO ro BAR SMITH ILLINOISAN MAY MAV BE HELD AT ATTHE ATTHE ATTHE THE DOOR OR SEATED AND THEN EXPELLED Cases Cuu of Vare Vats and Gould May Give Rite Rise to Much Classic Discussion I nM k Their Thelt Stand i I II I Washington Washington The The cases of of at Smith Fare Vare and Gould Could each involving a a dif dlf different different ferent variation Tl of the senates senate's power to refuse admission or to expel expel after admission contain complexities that from time lime to time for probably more than Ihan a year to come will give rise to many weeks of ot constitutional discus discus- ton ilon There are cleavages clell between tho those e who want all nil three In Ill There are ate cleavages II between those holle who want one of these e out and the others in because lISI of ot distinctions among the various circumstances of the separate separate sepa sepa- rate lite cases casta nut Flit the most technical cleavages clea of ot all run among those who most ardently want all three out but differ as to time the time And method of keeping them out and differ especially espe dally as to the grounds that shall be assigned for keeping them out At one extreme of the tle senate I Is David A. A Reed of Pennsylvania The principles he lie lays down would permit permit permit per per- mit all nil three of the troublesome ones one onesto onesto to take their seats and keep them Reed Heel of ot Pennsylvania reads roads the time clause of the constitution which says time the senate sh shall ll be the Judge of the elections returns and qualifications of ofIs ofIs ofIs Is own members That word ord qualifications qualifications quail according to Reed need of Pennsylvania Penn sylvania means only tho the qualifications of age residence and citizenship which the constitution elsewhere de des scribes To Heed Reed of Pennsylvania the Inquisitorial right of the senate la is limited to asking the time senators elect II 11 they are 30 80 years old If they are res- res of the state from which they are chosen and It if they have been citizens cit cU luns of ot the United States for tor at ot least nine years lars 1 |