OCR Text |
Show nan NUMBER 23 Bacteriologists Explode C. H. Theory In Water-Born- e Ogden T yphoid Outbreak Statists Give Reasons for Belief That Infection . Spread From Eating Places; Defense Intro-- ; duces No Water Analysis Showing Pollution Barton, Financier, Dies experts was the outstanding matter Wednesd- tb Fred Carr Receives Medal for Bravery For bravery in action during an gagement at San en- Quintin, Fhillipine n Island, during, the war, Fred Carr, of Ogden, was decorated with the distinguished service medal Wednesday at Fort Douglas by Major General Frank Hines. At the age of 18 Fred Carr enlistvoluntter ined in the Thirty-fourt- h went to his and with regiment fantry the regiment saw the Islands where active service. During the San Quintin engagement December 4, 1899, Carr sustained three wounds, and after having his wounds dressed by W. H. Fitzwater, one of his comrades returned to the firing line. It was for this act that the then Major Julius A. Penr. cited him for a certificate of merit. For twenty years the major Carr and tried to find Sergeant-Majin located him Ogden. finally Through the efforts of Colonel Penn, ion of the articles. George S. whose recommendation for Carrs ciJudge Baiter ruled that testimony concern-h- t was acted upon by congress, the matters subsequent to the public- tation of the medal was authorized. bestowal ation of the articles on 14 could July at the ceremonies were Present only be considered as applying to the seven of Carrs comrades of the Phil-lipiarti-wenewspaper's contention that the insurrection: James Colgan, truthful, but that matters James Peterson, Peter Betts, F. E. occurring prior to July 14 would be Rgvded by the court as evidence re- Barrett, John Winter, W. J. Keating had sitting the plea for mitigation of and W. H. Fitzwater. Fred Carr last seen Fitzwater the day they were umages and privilege. . of the service upon the Dr. Daines testified he and Dr. musteredof out that to the Thirty-fourt- h the return Graves had met with Dr. Savage, A. T.Bsnett and the city commission and United States, and it was only two mat they had been instructed to ago that he learned that the find weekswho had given him first aid on me source of man the infection, no matter ho or what was that memorable day over thirty years hurt. Utah. Dr. Daines recounted his investiga-p- a ago, is a resident of Duchesne, Mr. work on the occasions cm which he ceremonies, the of In speaking J? Ogden last summer, stating Carr said that he felt highly honored had been so influenced by that his government had seen fit to tor'e t the outset that bestow the honor after such a long PWPw. m believed at. that time that the out-w- lapse of time. However, he said that caused by a water-born- e he had one regret, and that was that It was for this reason, he Colonel Penn, who is confined to n o, that he had made his first u government hospital in the east, could 0,i .at the water system. He not be present when General Hines that the fact that the residents the medal on his breast. creek had been drinking pinned Mr. Carr is well known in Ogden, J undiluted waters of Wheeler creek served as worshipful master having had first of gout contracting typhoid Unity lodge No. 18, F. and A. M. his attention from the water-JJJHe stated that he had with gjred thatDr.heGreaves and A. T. and Greaves had ;and Co. a list of ques-H- e ghed Barrett with to kro?ound typhoid victims, of visits Walter Kellog, superintendent ol (SLa ? kisandsubsequent Greaves had Sugar compeny the lunch room and candy the Amalgamated Ford, Colo., arrived in Ogden Rocky the typhoid patients the week. He will tke chajje and JMrioed conditions in during thou of the Ogden plant a auPetand?'; ,e ave 118 opinion and wiU succeed E- - C. tint ftttkmn!itbr?ak waa due to food has been transferred to the Rocky water, as he had first Ford. Colo., plant as superintendent. Loofbourow was Mr. Carriek has been with the Ogtai hwt-l- y shaking any of Daines ttimoU J? 1920. He will leave s Counsel for the defense plant since assume to for Colorado Mr. out the iscttW?? bring and wiU be accompanied by aie8 had placed great depend. who will return to Ogden 011 acta aacertaned Kellog, by Barrett shortly. is The Amalgamated Sugar copany i? 9reayea followed Dr. controlled by the American Sugar witness stand. He qual-tio- d company. .,fa? eaPcrt with the informa- reived his degrees Will Ttity ShTKn.Cultural college, Uni-- Gen. ani the University the suthn?1 aad that he was book, vridely used Bigelow .bar.tenlogy, one of which er to b iPterdetailing the man-WoI Hines will d in investigation of Major General John of Jha Owen Hb reviewed his be the honored guet UnitOfficers 10 Reserve lotto.. A .Mientific societies as chapter. ed States, at th trioWigtrnlenca,n Society of .Anerican Public Health evening. A reception will be held ofHe Asociation for 6 oclock at which city and county of civic organizations, Aeri' ficials, heads aTSdeS.116 and reserve officitizens nrominent Hf ft to the general introduced will be Tie Jff.ttat.he had assumed that cers guest Koedpr.-!- : ?eatty'a report andA distinguished dinner will be served at 6:30 t which Captain Chas. V. K. Saxton, chapter ofthe 1? ft behind occurred to mm President of the Ogden will wsociation Beatty report, but Reserve Officers the act will Ora Bundy inves-cf5Mayor 22? revealed by the 80 conclusive that he at the headUblevnll 'h rothrpt,n0i.concuaon concerning Amongthose HinesCol. Asa W. J. that the in-- be General Col. bn Lber H. C. Price and his rJO?. . .from food infection. Singleton, his method of tabu- - adjutant Captain Calea kj nation and explained Douglas, Colonel Thomas Canningdetail iiivJ! be had reached his con- - ham, Lt Colonel A. C. "ms. a1 ft tbe enlieat points in On Bundy, Captain N. P. veitu!l?-Francis J. wa that he could Fredrick Jorgensen, lion. reconiff chamof ie SefjJ fj?e "ater-born- e theory Fowles, Keri W. norkins, commerce; fourteen males and ber of t9; fff, and the ifrnalej Wpr Lt. Colonel James A. Howell C. O. T. the It of colonel on page 2.) cadet Spanish-America- CHARLES II. BARTON de-fe- me or ne re . as in-H- .37? New Official of Arrives Sugar vJ&t ed r in-n- ot ta nt? of onW'? text-cantaine- H w-tie- be Hines Honored at Dinner Tonight At id -- uoX Pted de. ld k Bt V-my ad -- 0 vice-preside- nt Arthur E. rratt, who has been a practicing attorney since 1890 in the atate of lltah, died suddenly Wednesday evening. Wednesday afternoon, after court adjourned, Pratt went to his office in S. D. Badcon Raised the Kcclea building, and shortly after there he collapsed. George C. Degree Mason reaching Ruckle, who has offices in the same suite and who is chief counsel for tho Sidney Pee Badcon, son of Dr. Sid- Standard-Examinin the libel case NY. Badcon, waa raised to the ney third degree of Masonry Thursday now pending, rushed to Judge Pratts and called in Dr. II. C. Stran-qui- st night by NYebcr lodge No. 6. It ia the aid, and L. S. Merrill The judge fourth time in the history of thia jurisdiction that a son has been given waa taken to the hospital immediately, the rank by hia father as a third de- rallied and then suffered a relapse. He died p. m. Cause of death gree Mason. Officers of NVeber lodge was at 10:15 given aa angina pectoris, from who arranged for the conferring of the degree in compliment to Dr. Bad- which he had suffered for about a year. Although not in good health, con were Royal J. Douglas, worshipful master; W. II. Blackman, Frcder-ci- k Mr. rratt had given aasidoua attention Ochs, A. V. McIntosh, Frank E. to all legal matters before him during Nichols, Clark Logan, Herman O. that time, and especially to the libel Fetscher, Thomas Leslie, Kber F. suit in which ho was chief counsel for Piers, J. Frank Gimlin, Jr., and George' Fred K. Williams. II. Bartlett. He waa bom in St. George in 1864. He who attended school in southern Utah, Maaons d Thirty-thirdegree Dr. St. included Mark's school. Salt Lake City, work in the participated Badcon, worshipful matter; Governor completed a special course in the uniGeorge II. Dem, aenior warden; versity of Utah, and graduated from James H. Brown, junior warden; S. C. the University of Michigan in the Fulk, treasurer; S. II. Goodwin, sec- class of 1890. retary and chaplain; R. L. Conley, Upon returning to Utah he immediaenior deacon; C. W. Morse, Junior ately was admitted to the bar and bedeacon; C. F. Barrett, senior steward, came associated with tho late Senator and E. R. Gibson, junior steward, all Arthur Brown. In 1895 he came to of Salt Iake except Dr. Badcon. Ogden and formed a partnership with Members of the floor team, all thirty-thir- d George Halverson. From 1917 to degree Maaons, were A. G. 1921 he served as judge of the Second NVherry, J. NV. Collins, B. R. Howell, judicial district, and then became asJ. G. Bywatcr, M. E. Lipman, C. II. sociated with his son, E. E. Pratt in Fischer, all of Salt Lake, and 8. I). the practice of law under the firm Evans. F. S. Schramm of Salt Lake, name of Pratt and Pratt. formerly of Ogden, delivered the He served as city attorney during 192S and 1929, Judge Pratt was ever Milton E. Lipman was toastmaster, a prominent man in Democrat poll-tidegree and the following thirty-thir- d in his home city, having been a Masons spoke at the buffet supper that candidate for public office on several Governor occasions. followed the ceremonies: W. Collins James II. Dern, George The funeral will be held Saturday and A. C. Wherry. afternoon at 2 oclock at the Elks, The other three sons of Thirty-thir- d club. Exalted Ruler David I Stine honorbeen have who Masons degree will officiate. The ritual of Elks' club ed in this jurisdiction were sons of C. will be exemplified. The Reverend J. C. A. and M. E. II. Fischer, Lipman, W. Ilyslop and Judge Ilyrum II. Wherry. will talk at the funeral. Sidney Badcon graduated from Active pallheareri will be Samuel Stanford university at Palo Alto, Cal- C. Powell, Ira A. Higgins, II. A. 1929. in ifornia, J. Quill Nobeker, Stuart P. Dobbs and I J. Ilolther. Tomato Honorary pallbearers will be Hon. D. N. Straup, Hon. J. W. Cherry, Hon. Received in Ogden Samuel R. Thurman, Hon. Valentine Gideon, Hon. Tilman D. Johnson, Hon. A shipment of 390,000 tomato plants George S. Barker, Alfred W. Agee, was received in Ogden Monday from C. Richards, Ray Van Cott, Brigham H. Jones, Joseph Chez, Jas. A. Howell, Moapa, Nevada, and was prepared under the direction of George Shorten, Nathan J. Harris, John A. Sneddon, assistant secretary of the Utah ban- Chas. R. Hollingsworth and John C. ners association. The plants will be Davis. used in Weber county. Canning comFriends may view the remains this pany officials state that if thein frost afternoon and evening at the Kirken-dal- lthe destroys the plants alreadyIn Darling mortuary, and Moapa morning until 11 a. m. FromSaturday fields that there are enough 11:30 a. to assure complete replanting. m. to 2:00 p, m. the remains can be viewed at the Elks dub. Interment will be made in the family plot at Wins Mountain View cemetery. Surviving are his wife, Josephine Grim Pratt; one son, Judge Eugene E. of the Second judicial disRobert Jones of Hooper, Weber trict,Pratt, two sisters and ono Ogden, won first brother: county high school student, Mrs. Joseph Wilson, Mrs. Ida contest the in public speaking place Pratt and E. L. Pratt, aU for the eleven western states in Phoe- of SaltGreenwood, Lake. 6. school May nix high Judge Pratt waa a member of the The contest was close, with Cali- Woodmen of World No. 74. fornia taking second place and Nevada and the Ogden Elks' camp lodge. L. H. Dr. were Shantx, third. Judges president of the University of Arisons; Dr. Grady Gammabe, president of Arizona State Teachers college, and Honorable A. G. McAllister, asMotion in Case sociate justice of the supreme court of Arizona. Judge Eugcnt E. Pratt in the SecAs a result of his winning tonight, ond district court Wednesday afterwestJones will represent the eleven noon granted a motion for non-su- it in for contest national in the ern states the contest over will of J. P. BryFuture Farmers of America at Kan- an, who died at the a local hospital Ausas City, which is sponsored by Sena- gust 1929, a will in which 15, leaving tor Arthur Capper of Kansas. he bequeathed his entire estate of ap- son a 17 Is old, years Young Jones $9,000 in cash to St Jo-of T. M. Jones. lie spoke on the sub- proximately Catholic school in this city. sephs American the ject of the future of Mrs. Bertha M. Clinch, of Greeley, fanner. All subjects treated by the Neb., state contestants were related to the the a sister of Mr. Bryan, contested will The motion was made for problems of agriculture. non-su- it at the conclusion of the contestants testimony mod was granted as at the conclusion of the arguments. The attorneys for the contestant anCollide nounced that they will appeal the case to the supreme court. 3 at occurred collision Tuesday A a. m when an automobile driven by George Hartley, of West Weber, collided with a car driven by Richard Now Lundberg, of Taylor. The accident occurred east of the street viaduct. In the The emergency hospital, sponsored Twenty-fourt- h Mrs. Rose Hartley by the Altrusa club of Ogden, has were car Hartley and George Hartley, and In the other been fitted up in the basement In the ear Richard Lundberg, all occupants north portion of the city jaiL Mn. were, injured. Mrs. Hartley suffered Mary Rawson, president of the so- bead cuts and body bruises; Mr. Hart- ciety, states that the new unit is now ley was injured about the hips, and furnished and ready to accommodate Lundberg suffered a cut on the nose. emergency cases, and that other needAll received treatment at the Dee hos- ed articles will be added In the near future. The electrical workers union' pital. The accident was investigated by donated their services In wiring the room for the necessary hospital Ernest Shaw, of the police acces er Medical college, University In answer to Stuart P. Dobbs questions he further re-icu- Former District Judge and Former City Attorney Suffers Fatal Heart Attack; Was a Leading Member of Weber County liar and lrominent Democrat Third at Rush had performed post ntdute work at the University of flKfnrnia, University, of Pennsylvania ud had been engaged in special work at the laboratories of the United States bureau of public health t Washington, D. C., the laboratories of Massachusetts at both Boston and Harrard university, and that for three years he had done special research work st the Mayo clinic at Rochester, He stated that he had Minnesota. conducted typhoid outbreak investigations in Utah and Illinois; that he bad investigated swimming pool infections hen in Utah, and in addition had written numerous scientific articles typhoid and kindred subjects. Considerable legal argument began ehen Mr. Dobbs put his first questions t Dr. Daines. Counsel for the objected to the admission of his testimony on the ground that the investigation was made subsequent to the publication of the alleged libelous articles. Mr. Loofbourowa argument vis resisted by Arhtur E. Pratt and Sturt P. Dobbs on the ground that Dr. Daines testimony would reveal fact which were easily ascertainable ty the newspaper prior to the publicat- DIES SUDDENLY to on the witness stand. Dr, L. L. Daines qualified as an expert when he stated that he had received his bachelors degree from Brigham Young college at Logan, Utah; his masters degree at the University of placed of Chicago. lUted that he EMINENT JURIST Judge Pratt aa a jurist, as a man Stand-ud-Examin- er and his Ph. D. degree Out of respect to the memory of Arthur E. Pratt, who died suddenly Wednesday evening, Judge Geo. S. Barker ordered postponement of the trial of the libel suit, wherein l'red E. Williams U suing the Standard-Examine- r for damages in the sum of $100,000, until after the funeral of the distinguished jurist. and as a friend, lie recounted that Judge Pratt had served as a judge of the Second judicial district, and expressed the deep respect in which he held him. both aa a friend and aa a member of the legal ay in the libel suit in which Fred E. Williams is suing the for $100,000 damages. The chief expert testimony for the plaintiff came in rebuttal, when L. L. Daines and J. E. Greaves, the bacteriologists who investigated the source of the typhoid infection last summer, were Utah, ARTHUR E. PRATT The trial will be resumed at t:30 Tuesday morning. In issuing the order Judge Barker paid tribute to of Water Prior to June 26; Casey Says Situation Gare Him Right to Use Strong Language Testimony of JUDGE lUKKKll PAYS TRIBUTE TO PRATT 12 At 1 oclock Tuesday morning Mrs. Millie B. Barton; one son, HarCharles II. Barton, banker, organizer, mon B. Barton of Ogden; two daughbuilder, and foremost citizen, died at ters, Mrs. Mildred B. Eubank of Oghis home, 774 Twenty-fift- h street, Og- den and Mrs. Blanche B. Page of Rockden. For more than three months he ford, III.; two sisters, Mrs. Horace B. had been seriously ill, and with hjs Ryder of Baker, Ore., and Miss Hattie wife had recently returned from Cali- Barton of Baker, Ore.; a brother, Roy fornia, where he had gone in the hope Barton of Portland, Ore., and five of regaining his health. grandchildren. Mr. Barton was born in Kaysville Funeral services were held at the 59 years ago, and was the son pf home Thursday afternoon at i db- - Elks Alien Barton, p Joseph and Mary oclock under the auspices of B. P. O. neer residents of Kaysville. His early Elks No. lodge education was received in Kaysville, David L. Stine in719, Exalted Ruler charge. Reverent and there he commenced his business John Edward Carver of the First store. career as a clerk in a general Presbyterian church delivered the ser- While yet young, the family moved to mon. Ogden, and he resided there until Funeral services were held Thursday death. Before he reached his majority he entered the employ of the Utah afternoon at the Elks home at 2 Loan and Trust company, and he was oclock under the auspices of B. P. O. continuously connected with banking Elks lodge No. 719. Exalted Ruler as cierk, assistant cashier, cashier, David L. Stine was in charge of the The speakers manager, president and director, the impressive services. were Reverend John Edward Carver, remainder of his life. Henry It was not alone as a banker that James II. DeVine, and President A quartet he proved his great worth as a leader H. Blood of Kaysville. and progressive citizen. In all the composed of Lawrence Clayton, Gerald Klomp, Ed. Greenwdl, and Ed. organizations for the upbuilding of gave three selections: Ogden and Utah he had a prominent Peterson, Lead Loves Old Sweet Song, most all the of On records the part God and Nearer or My Kindly Light, worthwhile organizations those - to Thee. Mrs. John Hillabrant preprowhich have brought ganizations sided at the piano and played the preress and prosperity his name found. In the Weber club, in the lude and postlude.. Members of the chamber of commerce, in the Country Ogden Bankers association attended the service in a body. Members of the club, the oRtary club, State Banker society, of which Mrs. Barton association, in the fraternal order of Martha is and also the members of president, Elks, and many lesser organizations Junior society attended in he played a full part. Outside of Og- the Martha The Martha aociety had den his vrorth and ability was recog- a body. the flowers at the Elks home nized. He was a member of the ex- charge of the cemetery. clusive Alta club of Salt Lake City, and at by Active was recognized he banker pallbearers were Frank M. a as and being made a director of the Federal Driggs, Eugene R. Alton, Thomas Colonel P. A. Dix, J. II. Riley, Reserve bank of Salt Lake City. Islie, G. Dr. A. Dickson, C. J. Humphris, the in mover He was the foremost and Harry S. Anderson. establishment of the Ogden Livestock m show livestock show, tiie greatest Honorary pallbearers were Lester the intermountain region, and was F. Whitlock, J. W. Abbott, Ezra Richthe ardson, Charles II. Thorstensen, II. A. president of the organization and Ogof two stock Union yards, Ogden Benning, Fred El Williams, A. P. Bigdens greatest business assets, at the elow, George S. Ecclcs, II. E. Hemtime of his death. ingway, A. P. Miller, E. J. Harness, efforts his ; Chapin A. Day, H. P. Iverson, James It was largely through that Ogden became the chief milling A. Howell, and C. F. Donnatin, all of center of the intermountain region. Ogden; R..A. Pierce of Pocatello, of the Idaho; II. J. Plumhof, E. O. Howard, It was during his chairmanship chamW. L. Partner, E. A. Culbertson, and the of committee new industries in L. II. Farnsworth of Sait Lake City. ber of commerce that he succeededand Interment was made in the Mounhaving the Sperry Flour company establish View cemetery. tain company Globe Milling the their big mills here. He was also a a part good roads enthusiast and had were Officials in the road campaigns which successfully earned out in Weber Visit to Local Unit county and northern Utah. accomAs a banker his greatest of the Dr. I I. Hewes, deputy chief engiplishment was the stabalizingafter it National Bank of Commerce neer of the United States bureau of was organized to take over the man- public roads, San Francisco; J. D. National bark. Under his commissioner of public works, of the wood, agement this bank became one of the and R. H. Shoemaker, office engineer, popular financial institutions merged both of Boise, Idaho, spent Monday in city, and is just now being Ogden conferring with B. J. Finch, with the Security State bank. rnctn-od- s district engineer of the United States Mr. Barton waa direct in his bureau of public roads. Dr. Hewes of doing business, and once he ha- departed Monday afternoon for Zion hein- National determined on a plan or policysuccess-Onpark. to it through variably put was pving of his chief virtues full credit to those who helped him to H c.rnr op. to mcmm. and loyal to his his in friendship fast To Charles H. state. his and friends, his city, but Ilis place will be hard to fill his in At the regular meeting of the Ogthose who are called to follow stand-ing den of Rotary club held NVednesday at have will the advantage place he which the Hotel Bigelow a tribute was paid foundations on the firm to the late Charles II. Barton, presibuilded. His works, like thoss ar dent of th National Bank of good artizian, will last; they that built well so by the members present standare and ly grounded, and in silence for one minute. A comin ing progress Ogden will go forward to draw up resoluhe mittee line pointed appointed the prosperity along consists of J. W. condolence tions of out and followed. He is survived by his father, Joseph Abbott, A. P. Bigelow, and Marrincr Barton, of Baker, Oregon; his wife, Ecclcs. . Road Pay e . Rotarians Pay Tribute Barton dm Com-merr- e, cs Hen-edrs- Sod-erber- Many on g, Plants a Robert Jones Speaking Contest Judge Grants Nonsuit Bryan ' ; Three Injured Cars at Early Hour r: I r r.' i Emergency Hospital Ready for Use 5 ' ,y J - : s'r |