Show 't 'i 'V'r 4J i TTTE SENATE OKEHS land Costigan Fletcher George Har-- j rison Hawes Hull King Morrison Robinson of Arkansas Smith Stephens Trammell Tydings Walsh of Montana and Wheeler — 22 F armer-LaborShipstead Total 34 a gallon duty on oil The half-cen- t was kept in the bill 43 to 37 after a debate of two days climaxed by a de mand for a lobby investigation by one of the tariff advocates Party lines broke on the oil roll call Eighteen Democrats and 25 Republicans supported the tax while 20 Democrats 18 Republicans and the Farmer-Labo- r member opposed it The issue throughout was one principally of tariff protection rather than Estimates varied on the revenue amount of revenue the oil tax would produce but the treasury figure was Senator" Connally Demo$5000 000 crat Texas led the fight for the oil duty Senator Watson of Indiana the Re publican leader supported it and the Senator Robinson of Arkansas Democratic leader opposed it The actual rollcall was 42 to 38 Senator Tydings changed his vote at the last minute to aye in order to He promptly move reconsideration moved reconsideration as tne vote was announced The senate went ahead however with debate on the coal tax Utahns Divided ' The rollcall follows: Austin For — Republicans: Bing ham Capper Carey Couzens Cut ting Dickinson Frazier Hale Hat field Johnson Jones McNary Metcalf Oddie Reed Robinson of In Steiwer diana Shortridge Smoot Thomas of Idaho Vandenberg Wal— cott Watson and White 25 Democrats: Ashurst Barkley Brat ton Broussard Connally Dill Gore Kendrick Long McGill Hayden Neeley Pittman Sheppard Thomas of Oklahoma Tydings Walsh of Montana and Wheeler— 18 Total 43 Against — Republicans: Barbour Blame Borah Brookhart Fess Golds Kean Howell Hebert borough Keyes La Follette Moses Norbeck Norris Nye and Schall — 16 Democrats Bailey Bulkley Bu low Cohen Coolidge Cepeland Cos tigan Fletcher George Glass Harrison Hawes Hull King Morrison Robinson of Arkansas Smith Owens Trammell and Walsh of Massachu setts — 20 Farmer-Labor- : Shipstead Total 37 " IMPORT TAXES FOR COAL OIL Rale Kepi in Revenue Bill Only After Bitter-StrugglContinued Prom Put One- - would increase building costs and hamper home construction The roll call on coal tax follows: For: Brookhart Republicans — Austin Capper Carey Davis Dickinson Frazier Hale Hatfield Howell Johnson McNary Metcalf Nye Oddie Reed Robinson of Indiana Short-ridg- e Thomas of Smoot Steiwer Idaho Vandenberg Walcott Watson and White — 25 Democrats — Ashurst Barkley Broussard Connally Dill Hayden Kendrick Long McGill Neely Pittman Sheppard Thomas of Oklahoma and Walsh of Massachusetts — 14 To- tal 93 Against: Republicans — Barbour Blaine BoHebert rah Fess Goldsborough Kean Keyes La Follette Moses Norris— 11 Democrats— Bailey Bratton Bulk-leBulow Cohen Coolidge Cope- j ECONOMY CLEANING SPECIALS Men’s Suits Felt or Sailor Straw Hats Ladies’ Dresses or Coats (Plain Darker Wool) Silk Dresses Sport Coats Sport Suits r PIG HAS TWO SNOUTS KENTON O (UP)— A pig with two snouts is owned by Ora E Allen of CLERNefSS 6o OYfcfSS 114-12- y 0 EAST bfSOaDUUflH In addition to an ordinary Kenton nose the animal has what resembles a miniature elephant's trunk between its eyes The pig is unusually large and is in perfect health SALT LAKE TRIBUNE SATURDAY MORNING MAY 21 Catchwords Obscure SCOUT FLEET Efforts for Clear View of Problems ca m l on PACIFIC KEEPS Vessels Writer Warns Against Confusing Phrases in Discussing Ways for Recovery By WALTER LIPPMANN e Service York Salt Lak Tribune-Neutmost Is of the It really Importance that opinion be not confused by catchwords In discussing measures to promote recovery Herald-Tribun- w The problem is difficult enough in itself But the difficulties will be greatly magnified if those who discuss them do not take the utmost care to find out ex actly what it is that is being discussed This is particulart ly true of the discussion a public about works program There are three plans to be consid- ered The first is ' that of Senator Robinson w h c h was set forth on Wednesday of lastl 1932 MEXICO CURBS FOREIGN BANKS AQUARIUM PLANNED digo hue under normal conditions ha Transformation of the old seal said The pool is just west of tha old milt aquarium at Liberty park into a fish pond of giant goldfish and blue carp In a recent month 349 Industrial is being made by Robert S Sleater The water arises buildings in Germany were superintendent from a spring and has a peculiar in Sharply Restricts Future Operations of Institutions New Law West Coast Until October WASHINGTON May 20 ()P-- The scouting force of the United States fleet comprising what is known as the Atlantic fleet will fce kept In the Pacific until October 1 Announcement of the navy’s decision was made today by Admiral William V Pratt chief of naval operThe reasons given in his ations statement for the decision referred to economies "of steaming” and gunnery practice The decision however is in line with a request made to the navy recently by the state department that the scouting force be kept in the Pacific On May 13 the originally scheduled date of departure of the force from the Pacific to the Atlantic Secretary Stimson was absent from Washington Admiral Pratt ordered a temporary extension to May 28 The force was sent to the Pacific for maneuvers with other vessels of the fleet early this year While there was no official comment In fiaval circles there was conjecture that the decision grew out of a conference between Pratt and Stimson when the latter' returned from Geneva several days ago BROADWAY DRUG CO MEXICO CITY May 20 banks operating In Mexico will be sharply restricted by a new bank ing law that went into effect today The principal Institutions affected will be the National City bank of New York which has a branch here and the Bank of Montreal and the Canadian Bank of Commerce which have banks in Mexico City and numerous branches throughout the country The law provides foreign banks and credit institutions which receive deposits on 30 days demand or less must be associated with the Bank of Mex ico by the purchase of its shares It also provides that foreign ’banks or branches of foreign banks shall not receive savings deposits or Act as trust Institutions issue mortgage or cash bonds obligations certificates of deposit or pledged bonds A11 deposits in Mexican currency except those deposited in the Bank of Mexico or other credit Institutions in Mexico must be invested within the country under the new law in the same type of currency This clause in effect forbids foreign banks from turnnig peso accounts into dollars and sending the dollars outside of Mexico for investment or It is designed to loosen speculation up credit at home CD-Fo- reign 3 Broadway at State The Drug Store of Quality and Low Prices HOME-OWNE- FREE—12 lb CHOCOLATES plan to overcome this initial hesitation of the investor by giving him the assurance that the national credit d A box of McDonald’s Roof Garden or is pledged Let us take a concrete illustration Keeley’s or Ostler’s or Sweet’s fine Chocolates will be given Suppose the port of New York authority undertook to build a away free vehicular tunnel under the East river Suppose it issued bonds for that tun nel which were guaranteed as to interest arid sinking fund by the tolls of the tunnel Suppose then that the federal government announced that it would buy those bonds at par whenMentholatum large ever offered I am no bond expert Kotex 19 but I should suppose that private inModes vestors would be glad to get such Ex LftX (ihocolfttc bonds and that actually the governr r ! 17 ment wquld not have to buy many of Rubbing1 Alcohol pints 23 them Now if this happened an acAmbrosia Sets 20 tual increase of Investment would He Jad Salts 69 taken place have it as fol Llsterine large Imply More Deflation lows: Pepsodent Antiseptic large on Those who object to this idea With assurances Hinds’ Lotion 34 63 the ground that the money received that the budget' Ovaltine pounds 69 contractors will and will be balanced® i employes by 35c Kleenex be deflated out of existence 19£ and with emer- Llppmann simply W Llppmann Kolynos Tooth Paste by the banks take a very ominous 33 in those for in situation of the sight view assistance Paste Tooth present They gency Pepsodent 33 construc- imply that after the most drastic dedistress a 60c Italian Balm 33 flation of prices and credit of which tion program may be promptly authorized and entered upon by the is- there is any record a still more drasCO Now it LOS ANGELES May 20 (D— An tic deflation is impending suance of say $2000000000 of bonds to be spent upon may'be granted that there is still con- airplane dive to salute the wife of Lime Freeze or profit making enter- siderable scaling down of inflated one of its two occupants resulted In SHELBY Mont May 20 (D— A J Shoppers’- - Lunch Juice ot Lime two scoops and capital structure to be gone through tragic death before her horrified eyes Hendryx 63 publisher of the Twin tunnels as bridges such Deiicloua half spring tried prises Hr pineapple 1 in was with But it is perfectly possible or today City Advocate at Sweetgrass the destruction of slum districts Chicken country atyla butJUC sherbet inPehr-soIn at least it has been perfectly possible Roy Smith pilot and A A shot three times and fatally wounded the great industrial centers tered new peas creamed new Dutch Lunch stances where their credit resources in the past for investment to be resecretary of the Cycloplane com- yesterday by Frank Neville aged potatoes hot roll and cholc and succeedhave been which sumed too 70 he in enterprises whom far depicted of Tea Coffee Served with have not been recently pany were hurtled to death as the about 9 be can others behind or deflated while and treasurer town as or Iced Tea lag where authority exists draught Becco wing of their small ship collapsed in ed Inand the are and states is in an and the Neville passing through receiverships a power dive over Pehrson’s home jail here promptly obtained The crippled ship demolished a pri- quest will be held tomorrow aftercities desiring to carry forward con- foreclosures been which which no There certain have is noon sign vate garage as It cracked to splinters struction programs suspended because of lack of credit everybody recognizes as the signal In the rear of a Third avenue home Hendryx was brought to the hosIt is legitimate should deliver to the government for resumption Smith and Pehrson had rented the pital here with wounds in his shoulHe died last obligations and therefore to assume that some re plane an hour before the crash The der arm and stomach their own the revenues from the undertaking sumption is possible at this time and dive was meant to salute- Mrs night about 10 30 after an operation should be impounded to pay first that it would occur if the nerves ol Pehrson At the hospital he told county offithe running expenses and second bankers and investors had not been While police were removing the cers that Neville came into the office interest and sinking fund to the gov shaken by the harrowing experiences battered and then unidentified bodies yesterday morning and fired without 2-po- uhd through which they have passed It from the wreckage a weeping woman warning as the publisher was sitting ernment the Robinson Hoovei brushed that be may at were machine There his Difference was the crowd linotype It One Important through scheme will not work great results She had come over no witnesses The second plan under considera- No one can guarantee it But the Mrs Pehrson from avenue home after her Fourth tion is the president’s made public risks of the attempt are smalL The the day following Senator Robinson’s country will not be worse off come witnessing the sensational fall "I think it’s my husband but I’m statement There is only one impor- what may for having made some innot sur-- ” she pleaded with officers tant difference between the two plans vestment in useful and seeking to get close to the wreckage Both agree that the federal credit projects On the other hand in hopes that he might be alive "No should be pledged only to risks of not doing anything ot one the will tell me" she sobbed enter and sitting and letting the vicious spiral CHICAGO May 20 ((P)—State Senof deflation spin are very great prices” But the president proposes POPE REC VES AMERICANS ator Daniel A Serrltella and Harry that the federal government make There is the risk that ’ Hochstein formerly city sealer poloans to private corporations as well will become impossible There is also VATICAN CITY May 20 (P)-P- ope as to public bodies the risk— no I should say the certain- Pius XI today received 19 American litical friends of the Capones were The 'third plan is that originally ty— that the country will not endure Catholics who are touring Europe be- sentenced to a year in the county jail sponsored by Senator Wagner and by the consequences of continuing de fore visiting the Eucharistic con- and fined $2000 each today for conIt is backed by Ration and that congress will resort gress in Dublin this summer They spiracy to defraud Chicago houseSenator La Follette include Monsignor Raphael Fuhr Los wives by allowing merchants to Smith It proposes to to really inflationary devices to cure undertake public works without re- it The Robinson Hoover plaq is Angeles goods aR ef therefore a truly statesman-likquiring that they be to Thus among those who wish take fort to deal by sound principle with centers positive measures the debate a problem which will otherwise sure on two questions: provoke the adoption of entirely unly limited be 1 Shall the enterprises If the people are sound principles enwhich to projects to bear what they are suffering they infor on the budget tail no charges must be convinced that those who terest sinking fund operation or claim to be sound are also willing to maintenance? take all the positive measures which 2 Shall private enterprises be in- informed opinion can justify The cluded or shall the projects be con- Robinson-Hoove- r plan can be justifined to public enterprises? fied by informed opinion though no one is finally expert in these matters Call for Answers These are the questions of principle it can be said confidently I think to be discussed These questions have that there is sufficient weight of exto be answered before a program can pert opinion behind the screme to warrant the experiment be agreed upon If it succeeds in some measure Before seeking an answer we must rejoice If It fails it first of all consider the case of those everybody will the forces at work are who object to any positive program will be because greater than we are able to cope with The of this character m Passing over the fact and they willat run their coursenot spite objects least we shall have has confused of us But that the with having the Robinson-Hoove- r plan with the to reproach ourselves La plan the been unwilling to do what we could crux of the objection is that the new with such light as we have (Copyright 1932) credit applied to enterprises will not that is in a period of Blackmailer of deflation “set in motion a series of Confessed stimuli which spread gradually Sentenced to Prison throughout the country For after it one or two changes of hands returns to the banks where it merely KANSAS CITY May 20 m— Walceases to be like any other credit ter Ogborn 36 year-olformer rug that is not needed ” This argument salesman was sentenced to serve five assumes that the money received by years' imprisonment today as the reemployes and firms engaged in the sult of his confessed attempt to extort work would be used by them or by $6000 from Harold Negbaur under those from whom they in turn made threat of kidnaping and slaying his son purchases to repay loans at the banks 3 year-oland that the banks would make no Ogborn pleaded guilty to a charge new loans This I take it is what is of blackmail and the sentence was meant by saying that the new credit the maximum for the crime His plea was entered less than 24 hours after would quickly cease to be police detectives arrested him as he Do Not Want to Invest a rendezvous with memThe argument assumes that the approached bers of the Negbaur family he had time has not yet come for a resumpan anonymous letter tion of investment that debt paying arranged by or m other words deflation has not gone far enough Those who argue this way can point to the fact that although the federal reserve banks have been creating credit on a large scale the member banks continue to call loans and to deflate The banks do not want to invest and therefore it Is argued that a positive program of credit creation and public investment must fail Now it would be admitted I suppose that the essence of recovery would be a resumption of investment If tomorrow morning the bankers anGrand Opening Today nounced that they had sold successfully a bond issue let us say to elecSaturday May 21 trify the Pennsylvania railroad and the next day that they had sold successfully a bond issue to construct a large power plant the objectors to the Robinson Hoover idea would unquestionably hail the news as most encouraging For longer than you can remember Schaffncr & Slant have Now what is it that stands in the On a Quart of Ice Cream a of such Is been at best way undertakings’ styles finest tailoring crowding greatest fabric value (quarts only) if presented belief that the country will never store at the and most refinement of detail into their suits at the lowest posagain need capital improvements’ Hardly Is it a belief that capital imhis sible prices when everybody wants most Now provements cannot yet be made prof sixteen of records have the smashed itably? Yes Why can’t they be made value years in money they OUR PRICE profitably? Some would say because these new the costs of materials and labor are spring suits still too high others that the volume of business is not great enough to make any enterprise profitable Matter for Negotiation The objection as to costs is a matr ter for negotiation with contractors and with labor the objection as to volume is a question of being able to Dornm DECK ICE CBFAM CONES wait for an improvement in business For this walling means uncertainty In the mind of the Investor He wants 208-21to be very sure that the money he in0 vests will be safe as to capital and in930 SOUTH MAIN cur-rtn- ' 1 week half-poun- With Every Purchase or $1 or More SATURDAY SPECIALS m 69t 69t Two Perish in Air Crash as ‘Salute’ Fails Montana Border Publisher Slain BROADWAY DRUG FOUNTAIN n Ice-co- 0J - box MARTHA WASHINGTON CANDIES ' f Trade Mark U 8 Registered No 251438" Capone’s Friends revenue-producin- g "income-producin- SATURDAY SPECIALS Look At ’Em Go! The Smartest Array of Men Greatest Ever Assembled f to Sell at $1 Men! You'll find It hard to believe your own eyea see when these you SMART STRAWS in this offering! Newest colon! Newest shapes! Hate inch as you would have j paid two and JR times three our price forllv yes even VS® Check Sff old feltvjP On with the ' II strawa J ht e Th MlTYTS more the "debt-paying’- short-weig- Men's Straw Mats S Hear Sentences v Herald-Tribun- Dollar Bill Herald-Tribun- Hen’s Shirts e e Follette-Wagner-Smit- and Shorts "debt-paying- n rayon ahlrti and shorts in all sizes and Heavy colors non-ru- Special £ 1U1 Men's Work Shirts d S Brother brand blue shirt chambray work Coat atyla Ail sizes Special JflV ” HART SCHAFFNER & MARX n f fUl Bine Ribbon Men's Union Suits Genuine white broadcloth union ault athletic atyle All sizes Special 4-F- 3 for oot Step Ladders con- structed has shelf t top for mops pans etc Needed ft in every home v C o n v e n lent and handy for cleaning windows walls etc Strongly CANOPY TOP BEACH CHAIRS Made with collapsible top and footrest Adjustable to four positions Jm gp ft —ill NEW ORIENTAL THEY’VE Smashed ALL VALUE RECORDS FOR THE LAST 1 6 YEARS with their This Ad Worth 10c Ilart just 10c Half Pint 5c The fundamental argument for the Robinson Hoover idea is that it is a il v jjjgjg for Arthur Frank SOUTH MAIN ST terest 1 PRIZE WINNERS ICE CREAM CO 35c Quart 20c Pint are |