Show BY TELEGRAPH P apsa UNION ra arc AMERICAN washington 24 dito 2 1 to the jury the junior counsel has said salil you are kings implying that you may override law jaw and evidence in grasping an au almost intangible doubt and ignoring the solid structure of the evidence of guilt you are not kings and the man who told you so was only one man in who could or would recommend guiteau for office judge porter after recess dealt with cunning ald and duplicity referring inferring to Gulte auls pious plow outbursts he said with deliberate emphasis idonat believe there is one soul in this entire assemblage that contemplates with such abject terror the possibility of facing his maker as does this brazen murderer Gul gui guiteau with the ferocity of a wild animal fairly yelled thata a miserable lie and you know it por ter and you are sin tin infernal scoundrel I 1 hope almighty god will send for you soon doth voth you and corkhill col Coi khill referring to reeds reference to mrs Garti gartl garneida olds elds prayers porter sald said magine imagine the aged mother coming before you draped in black imagine according to an au old custom of ng laws this trial taking place in the presence of the corpse farfield ilu uil til dilated abed by the murderer and wrapped in white linen through which it was supposed the mere approach of the murderer would cause blood to flow imaino imagine garneld lying there not one of the clavicles of his backbone but the whole man cold in death with the death sweat not even dry on his hia brow with expressions of agony on his face which this thia prisoner put there and with the tho cowering assassin yonder shrinking from approach to the body imagine the aged 0 mother who had looked to that thad bon son to close her eyes in death bowing with grief at the conin coffin head with mrs garneld whose lips were those coid cold lips of the president sitting at his feet in dust and ashes if in such a acerie mr charles 11 heed reed stood up and said the woman who seems to us to bo be bowed in prayer that thu murder shall ba bo dealt with leniently what would you ahll k of ll 11 it Is well for us all that the law does not call upon jurors to leave the immortal part pare of their nature their moral nature outside of the courthouse whoa they come to administer J justice usaf ca although garfield is dead the prisoner speaks and has spoken on the wa witness stand the words worda which prove him to be not only an assassin asea saiu but a deliberate sane and responsible sible assassin of tiie the president this man slaughtered garneld garti Garli eld eid as ho he would have slaughtered a calf he would eat ithe the doctors did that said the prisoner and having disposed of him in mat that way in comes cornea his counsel and charges with the crime those who occupy too lol iol lofty ty a pos position tion lion to notice the vipers that said it and who would have degraded the dignity of their office oy vy noticing it one of them a distinguished american senator who at this moment except that he was too lofty and proud to accept office would be bitting sitting as chief justice of the united states the eon of a great and honored american jurist a man who still young in years yeara has commanded more attention at home and abroad of the admirers of intellectual grea greatness tripps of the loftiest loft iest eloquence and of the greatest statesmanship statesman hip than anyone perhaps even of his time fl a bitter partisan a it man honest in all his undertakings a man faithful to bohia hib his friends faithful faith falth tul tui to his convictions even every though they in volve sacrifice a man who capable of doing what but few men are capable resigning the leadership of the american senate and done at the peril of his own pol poi political des destruction truc tion a man of unstained integrity courage fearless fearlessness ness neEs and manliness which chich made his hla withdrawal a matter of regret oven even to his political adversaries ver saries such a man is today to day arraigned before an american amerlean jury and arraigned not by criminals but defended without my knowledge interposed ter zer posed aa responsible of the tho gar field murder another of those arraigned is a man more hon bored ed in the confederate states than any american state than their own cherished leaders for rendered first in war and afterwards in difficulties difficult las les which grow out of the war a man chos whose a ilfe life has haa been without dishonor and without reproach 3 a man cleva cluva elevated ted tod to conspicuous positions the su successor cesair of tona jefferson jackson and lincoln who after he left that place was welcomed in every european and oriental land as one of the ablest men and purest personal characters to be named in the history of the nineteenth century that man ia Is arraigned by the lawyers of guiteau but not by guiteau interrupted the prisoner as responsible for the murder of gen garneld bartic ld more than that we have the president of the united states the prisoner made so by the inspiration of guiteau do not you forget that mr porter you do not represent him here either porter continuing said that hayes lincoln jackson jefferson adams alid and washington Vas hington were elevated to that position not by an assassin but by the voice of his countrymen and when this creature says he be was inspired to make arthur president he forgot general arthur was made president by the voice of his countrymen by that very voice which made garfield he was president under the constitution and laws millard fillmore was just as truely elected bythe by the people as the president whom he succeeded the prisoner thit that is a false statement mr air arthur and mr fillmore were nominated as vice presidents and could not have been nominated as presidents a t the time mr porter th this is man told you in his bpi spi speech cecal last saturday that lar mar field might have died from any other cause that ho he might have trod upon orange peel and received injury which might have caused his death or that he might have trod upon a rattlesnake whose whoso fangs might have pierced his heel bee was it an orange peel or a rattlesnake that made arthur president porter continued the fit st question q for the jury was the prisoner insane on july ad if not the case is ended second if he was insane was it to a degree that he know murder vas was morally and legally arong wrong trong tile the jury was by oath bound to convict him hini third if it i t was in utter disregard of his confession under oath the jury found fouad that he actually and honestly believed god commanded i him to kill bill the aud that lie under a delusion unless the j jury ury found such delusion disabled him from knowing that such an act was morally and legally wrong they must convict if such delusion did exist and was caused by in insanity then and then only they must acquit ho he has sworn he was able to control his will fourth if he was partly insane through his own depravity and malignity they must co covich coi vict murder hasL neen been in the world since the firstborn first born of woman slew slaw the second born and god knowing mans nature inscribed on tables of stone thou not kill human life to guiteau is of small value life said lie he in one of these letters of his hia is a full dream etc whoso choso shed deth doth mana mans blood by man shall hl his blood be shed says fays the gospel and against this we have had bad the gospel of Gul gui guiteau you are to judge whether the gospel of our maker or the tho gospel of this murderer shall prevail reviewing tho the claim of the do tie bense to hereditary insanity judge porter said mrs mra coville scoville ts dared not say her father was insane his family physician who was with him till his death would have kown it and yet not one dare kiss rhe holy book and make oath to such euch a statement this defense is a falsehood and part of the imposture and shame that wraps about the whole case cage this incident judge porter turned against the defence with telling effect andthil and this raising of a murderous ax and against his own oali sister aister which she a in her honesty of soul imagined an indication of insanity but which in reality was but in keeping keehln with the cowardly attack from behind upon his infirm father and with devilish depravity which culminated in his murdering the president this raising of the as ax was the only evi dence which his bisler eisler recalls through her 40 years of knowledge of her brother guiteau twisted uneasily and with some bome nervousness and hesitation of speech called out the prosecution are making a good deal out of nothing they are just juat J us using evidence altogether different din erent from what scoville intended he never ought to have said any auy anything thing about it it just shows how little sense the villes have got at a quarter past three judge porter not having concluded his argument tho the court adjourned until tomorrow to orrl oril morrow QUO wa tiie the committee on public lands has agreed to recommend the passage of saunders bill which directs the secretary of the Interi interior ur to ascertain the number of acres of the public lands entered by the location of military scrip land warrants in all the states whose enabling acts of admission into the union contained a stipulation for the tho payment of 5 percent on the sales of public land therein and which thereupon requires the secretary of the treasury to deliver to the governors of buch euch states treasury certificates payable in 20 years from date and rearing interest at the rate of aga per cent a year for the full fuu amount of 5 per pen percent cent of lands so entered estimating their value at per acre the states named as beneficiaries of the bill are ohio wisconsin minnesota louisiana alabama mississippi florida oregon nevada and colorado the house committee on ways and means authorized representative mckinley to report to the house with favorable recommend recommendation a the following bill fixing the rate of duty on manufacturers 0 iron steel etc be it enacted that title 33 of ve fc tte e revised statutes be amended by adding to the schedule of baid eaid title the following provided that on all iron or steel and on all manufacturers wares vessels and articles of iron or abeel steel or of which such metals or either of them snail bea bo boa a component part or th the a material of cheap value whether wholly or partially manufactured there shall be levied collected and paid no less rate of duty than the duty or rate 4 f imposed upon said goods or upon any part or material of said goods in any of the forms of which it or they last existed prior to their passing into the form or article on which duty is to bo be levied this act shall not apply to nor in any manner affect arti artl ies les les jes specifically enumerated in this title by their commercial designation but shall apply to articles designated in this title as manufacturers of steel or of which steel shall be a component part not otherwise provided for manufactured articles vessels and wares not otherwise provided for of iron or which iron shall be a com mato mata material or the chlof cliot val mal of the metals not otherwise pro provided aided for and castings of iron not otherwise provided for the senate finance committee heard supt bupt snowden snowdon of the phila delphia blin tsin advocacy of the bill introduced by bayard to provide for the condemnation for government purposes of tho the remainder of the square on which the mint is situated snowden argued that the tho mint should be isolated from private property and that room should be afforded for the improvement and extension of tho the building which he thought might ultimately be enlarged as to enable the government to dispense with all other coinage with the exception of the one at san francisco and make the remaining mints simply assay offices and re fineries nin fin eries erles the committee then authorized zed bayard to report the bill for passage with sundry amend i ments reducing the amount of the proposed appropriation to the house committee 8 the house committee 8 judiciary to 4 adopted the proposition to pay from the geneva award losses by exculpated cruisers and pay war premiums and not refer the tho question to the court of claims or pay insurance companies new KEW york 21 tho telegrams paris das dis dispatch atch says after mature deliberation deliberation a powerful syndicate of paris bankers conspicuous among whom were the tho ideker determined to como come to the relief of tho the union generale stringent conditions have been imposed at especial demand to prevent abuso abuse being mado mada of the assistance given probably the tho bank of lyons ex loire will also be propped up there have boan bean conflicting reports regarding the treatment of the chinese students who were ordered brck back to china several months ago since their arrival home A letter just received from one of the brightest of the boys who was wms in the headquarters at hartford bays says that upon arriving at t shanghai the students were received very eily eliy coolly and they were placed in a damp dirty dirty school house the doors to which were nailed up with the exception of a front door which was guarded by soldiers el even ven those who had homes were not permitted to go outside thoro thero they were for two weeks when by the intercession of influential ly i lends rends they were permitted to live li ve elsewhere the josia washington special i says pays representative haskell of I 1 I 1 is rhum ansas who ia Is one of 0 the leaders in ju the house of the movement against polygamy in speaking of the different bills before the house relating to tha tho subject saya says ho he considers them valueless because of the impossibility of proving polygamous relations owing to the secrecy with which the marriage service is performed among mormons cormons Mor mons Pa bill which proposes to make cohabitation with two or more females proof of polygamy without the necessity of proving plural marriage is he lie thinks open to the objection that it would make the crime of polygamy an offense under the statutes haskell says he puts the fact of successful anti mormon legislation on the proposed reorganization of the territorial legislature the bill introduced trod by willetts Wll IVIl letts of michigan provides for the abolLah menu ment of the territorial legislature and substitution of a board of commis commissioners loners as in the district of 0 columbia and this bill meets with his favor he thinks it the only solution of the difficulty CHICAGO 24 john gales before judge smith today to day plead guilty of the murder of haessler Hae BaIer a farmer near evanston the judge remarked that the sentence sen een tence would be hanging or penitentiary for life but reserved hig his decision until all the evidence was written up the jury after a few ini minutes consideration on the murder have delivered a verdict of guilty xing fixing the penalty at hanging in neal neni ne a I 1 will probably confess crafts C ra gf ts case will wil I 1 be desperately con tested it comes next BOSTON bostos 24 A largely attended meeting last night in the plymouth church protested against polygamy in the united states lot averail presided the drift of the addresses was that the law which has been a dead letter for 20 year years should be enforced the jury system should be bb revised to exclude Mor ois dis also that the law of evidence be changed chau ge or amended so that the difficulties difficult ie in the way of proving mormon mar niage m abbe obviated and if it necessary order a change of venue eo so that congress may remove these criminals to another lu location cation for trial the resolutions were in the same spirit the practice of polygamy lao foj for acon julur branded with infamy by the crimi nal codes of every |