| Show I ORAL BETTING NOT UNLAWFUL Albany N X T i Nov Nin 9 Hotting I ii a I crime only when accompanied b h hoor by a record l or the th uee Ulle of at come ome part of or the paraphernalia of ot professional gambler to a decision d llalon handed hand down tod 1001 today b by the th court coun of ot ota appeals a In III effect the decision holds bold that bat I oral dot dots not constitute In violation of the iii Ih track gambling law The Th court affirm the th order of ot the tb lower court for tor the dis discharge dl charge from of ot Orlando Jones Jonea Jon and otal ol who wit were Indicted in King count county on a charge of or book bookin g gIn in holding that the th laying of ot odd alone doea 11 not la a crime Judge Height Mid eaid If It I f a 1 man Mn should offer o or to 10 bet the I lid I of Ids hi part party a pair of ot gloves Iloe or a I box of candy It II would not b be the lay icy Ing I of at odd and ADd the th paine caine m To Te hold him to be a bookmaker would In ni HI Judgment be bf a departure from front the rule rul that II to II the ha terms term of the Ihl tk talut their ordinary r and accepted moaning meaning and as would be he a lon which waa wa not within the contemplation of ot the Judge Cullen In hla hi opinion OLI fi I bould be b I I and andU II U la I at t tout teaM Mat doubtful wh whether Ut r a tItu staking every evary offer off or accept acceptance oe pl pla limos ance a of ot a bet et or er wager mager a r a it online crime could In iii the present date datI 01 or morals Arid aud at or the Ume community be Mi forced While White In la reality the Ih Ii l II dl di agaInst Rambling not Dot It Incidents Incident the hi tb law iw la ha hal baa laid Ild hold of or v Incident on th the theory that Ih being prohibit the evil Itself be e l of the th of ot carrying on GO gain gam bling on a meg law et 1 without t Mille caine ine at fit th tIn denounced by b the I statute lahI lIe far elan Bum lan aa has proved pro u Ut UtIn In I la for th lite be tune tur lu not nOI the II court ourt to lo determine and fWd w hold thai I th tb aim of or th UI men a II rim It taU fall time the II term lenn of or the I he In lii I a opinion Judge y 1 Tin Tb tug itie lt without it and the lea dilute forbid ng lug In itt 11 U It i without defIning It In Iw view t ut of the tb lb explicit of I II tie i anti and th the blab t of l on ull the ill well wall u a th the origin of Hi ii word book making end nd It Ita meaning In the country from fro rom wh we se borrowed It ii I J think the prohibit In book bach making with or the Ih aid IU leI of any writing beus writing I II not nol It at lb Ii e and 1111 seed need nut not be to 10 and If It to I la is a mere atari liv Idiol In iii the Ih of public tabling b and 1041 laying In aid lou odd to 10 I a multitude of wa was waa U tin Us vil 11 l al at not nOI the lh ta king of If a rord of at the lh Lb business I III al i |
