Show T TUB LAW 1 W IN TUB GASH CASH It hM has been a by A monde I t paper war that elm 01 must man mand d ll tut wui t as lu tut tor fot this It liu Ilse h cited Helium who It IL cl lm il iv give startling oti ml thin m matter tt r tho Senate committee l Iry by y which The Trl leered a WK tIC victory This Thue fht Hub sub J et hW hail ha l been n very frequently of rat late HUe but wo now Interest r it lI lIr lIi b bo r taken o MUIO u o of ot the Ille Volition portion i by A C N Nelson l on Slat gotta lt I of ot Iu WH IU a e to h Wellington Washington to 10 give evidence on the chi before the thi Ih committee e on th the Senator o ogees w and in ft m t mss cn c that the tin Monson Church hall hail Its tenets In la the III pub I 1 llo Io Tills Thill charge tad had born lIn made inada In th the h local r red re reIt It d ferret to th the only calor n to It be he beng heInl frig ng tho tact fact that what utI are called re ren n cI had haJ been h hh held ld In of ot J I the district In this It was WU very vory clearly and positively proven provo prey It II en Cut that no Illch chaos were v r lull held or at It Ito ata o a tempted to be held In the public schools 11 n they were wire separate and distinct I from school tuition anti and that horo tho ware vero utilized pT or foi tor the purpose of holding them they U II Wem vety vero not hot opener oP until after atter the tho for the day And IM then than for tor theo th the h only nf ot children 01 ere a d eel red 10 o 8 d to 10 attend u the Ule others being d Ili I ta to go frO home d Notwithstanding this and end the further I t taut faut that tha th tho Iho cl class clus a won OM usual usually 1 ly Iy 1 held hehl but bUI for tor about halt hlf h l f an 1111 hour on one day dy poly Ily In tho the we week k the i i and untruthful claim wan Willi still kept kepI V r j up that 1 was being taint Introduced II In III tho the public and n I those Institution were in III danger of ot be tM beIng I n Ing brought Mormon l caused the tb In Inquiry Inie Inc ie c quit quilt before the Ihl and amI t tl l hence the of ot In n Nelson which the Tribune announced oed t u ere a big bl victory rOt tor or that thal paper Thu Thua t a truth tenth ta II that lot Ht ut a II tine lino or of or h I nce e woe w n given to how show that re religion rea a d ligion or religion dames had Invaded it I the Iho public of tit Utah l but the Ib Very contrary wan wu thereby I It Jt appears appeal a that the superintendent h I had made diligent into the tile h t r and end learned that H a 1 large larlo num i III s I ot sf f 18 be 1181 df lit daises had hod been held I In In III country places and lit In sum bums the w cular r tOll after II n the school had bed been dill die d 4 for the Uli day alto allO aim taught t the l l ola clu clue In the sit slime me building Iy Tin Tile Superintendent fonn formed d the opinion th ii Ibis was waa n nI net t In harmony with the lh nl I aw law although the State HUte apil I I had bad twice declared that the lawn l I 04 tg AI AIl Ah Jh 1 stale tat were w not oi opposed Pi ed to 10 the theand iiI 1 Use and end co ro o the Ihl Superintendent r t I tl an official letter u a copy OPI of ot j b lell elt wee Wa to In th Tribune I t lil wa was w recd by b him to the corn coin ml J Q t U follows it lr S lt lAke fake City C t Itah Dec n a 1901 1801 l fO O the tile Superintendents Superintendent and end the ot f bol Boards Board of ot the State Stan SIll II of ot Utah F 1 Joor r ame time put pat thle ounce om hM ham been beell almost In re r l eel t of ot letters letter from n In different parts of at the IIII emit against 16 the ua ut of public for tor tort fori or t n i religion re claa cia cla a In order to tor a aln with th the Ihl n lotice 01 r of or thin th u II cue e of lr the public ICh Ol build 01 tetter of ot Inquiry were sent lent from front thle to 10 nil all of ui the county and MUr city MU cU school chool The r rK r o lv d convey Olle the Information t k Thus tin the Ih religion cla da ii are Iro condo p l I in ill l a i huge horse number cumber of r public f p throughout thu hu tate state Hc th these o l lt o are Art held In Id Imn after fter the clow of ot W e I the thO nod from further tt tion lIun n It In Is found that Hint out not Infrequently U to the regularly IllI loyd d teacher leacher of th the al If s also ah u thu I teacher fai her of ot the HIP religion daw t Permit Id use me tar tu to If tall call your attention to 10 I tier 1 ml erL III 10 to nf rac the or if r d of nr lull Inh It tt 1144 Ile f I I Tito shall nolde fc tM for forthe r the f ami and iiri of nl ofa 11 r H II uniform y tl lcm m of r Iii s all atul l nn n h shall l upon 1111 tu to all Hll children ren of the lite tat and b h M tree free from rom 11 I len n Nt IM of th I l n i o ot of o 1 lies 9 s N MN 0 tu to I the th men mention nr r tion ill of hr hi l i It Ir IN v A i i ml II It I Kr MIt H 1 t 1 1 Ui iIi n 1 II 1 1 i in or IM I d ii dili I I tad I 1 M i laugh Inu h Id la nay III e Of elf the dl nit d d I r f ihli I hl r r C lei I local t legatos Il 11 upon I the Ihl minds of II i 1 the HP pupil pupils tit 0 tu im at t f p 1 panty and In InN In N shall hll I b bf be ghi t 1 In Terry o I and till all at Uh lIh fh ach hII oln ola Khali Khall be he befree befree free tr from fren control I Ie e I It II U t th i 1 1 th ith the tho thoth pl pr f th the t rn unit t the Igle nn 11 lUUIe whirl ni d the tho rI l i t of Utah h to bo be frog from from aa aft well an oa from from tho influences of ot and Th They y w wr were re I In entire harmony toy loo with willi the American on ll Even Ev the propriety mere of ot reading the UI Dible la l the pub has Mas been called Into renders render mil nin read and tn have reft re their peculiar views Into Berl lural tural quotation The Th hool I II deigned aa 1111 n the common ground Around of ot every child and youth of ut th the I Iland land Ind of or Itle or 01 or party perly It II must ever remain fr it Ire from any allY Influence or condition which would have h hit v VI u a tendency to change I It preeminent among the grea gre of ut our country AN Is K rhal It U IM la our mir duty t tn guard condition whit might give ghe rh an en opportunity for f venal Rul m to 10 enter Into into lito or 01 Influence o ou our pUblic school Wherever rell ref U Ulion lion glon classes 11 are orf held hll before leaving th the tl tor for the day the pupil re r I a a well wall lIS eft secular Iular In III Ii too from frum th Ihl tI lame Hume teacher lecher It 1 le II trot not to I be that Immature minds mends will clearly m as to 10 the unction III t tho choral bool and the tb In the re r clear claM work but It 1 is III to w bo be II ex IX el thud that it n a of ot thi u children will look upon all ail of their ilK us th Ih the K school h ml work of If the tho diy The fhe religion t nifty may be hI of or the thi ti roost Inot wholesome und and 1411 haN ter Irr yet cl In III n a country like hike our nut th right to 10 according to thi It of lit Individual ha bill i given use to tn varied belief ant an nd where the lid III lint are lIu by 11 at an a taxpayers nf or the community to hold hok children lifter after th the regular w hoof hool hour of nf tho day lay for fill the th purpose of ot Inculcating ing If Into Inlo their mind the ol of c cany any 1111 treed creed must munt of ot be more or nr lei leis N objectionable tn to th people of ot the Ille community holding differ different ent cut religious view The mud law nf of t Iho th State RUte emphatically declare that th public chool shall he hI free frev from re reo or lr control Much KUth be beng ng the caie ce ca and the condition ne as hereIn heren here her herIn In n rat tt t forth I t am of or th the lon Ion on and you yon era arn hereby nereby w so a that the th religion rel Ion ciao clai work u when hen con conducted conducted ducted In school If Is I In ii violation of or the Ihl spirit of ot the tho Con lion Uon and the 1110 minutes of ot th the State Blala of or u Utah A C NEI NF ION slate Slat of or Public In Now It will bt be clear to every ever artful trader that there then the In le nothing cited by hl he the tu from the State f toil Con or the th that ibM the th multi of ot All hU hil hi quotations relate to l and control In the public The u nee e of ot the roe for other than public school pur HN when vh n the schOOls are ara Is II another matter nuttier entirely antI and there la Is nothing In n what he gives aa as authority tor for thu UI trained deductions In III which he In 8 that affords the t t war warrant warrant rant ant for tor liU hi opinion o and aM advice lie o own ni sworn tUmon prove II that tha l such ouch religion ni cm ha hd had l bun bean held once moo a week W In ht a number r of ot the school schoolhouses nausea houses went cute not made a part vart of o the lift UI hool nod were ere never nevor Relit held h un tin II the school wee WM and therefore not l be an en endeavor to is religion Into the public wheals v to vIn f In III elting h 1 W on thU thie K If It ho I to tobe tobe too be o fair and candid might have referred to the Ih section of or the win which direct And Ind ox authority to the Ih school board I In Inch to 10 do the tho very er thing that he m re objects to Tho The boo Is h given ha Carr CHII custody and nn control of ot nil all property rh belonging to the tho district die I riot to tho the of ot the law lid ind It Is la further Section 18 Iro man US OP OG Ion FOIt pun PUR OSES os s It Inay p permit a school house when not occupied for school purports tl u be Le for any purpose PUI which will not lot interfere with the tM Beating aUn or other or property erty end and shall make uch Buch charges charge for the UM of ot the mm came u a they the may Ina decide to be lie Juat Jut but butor butor tor or any ny ue use or privilege the district hall not be bI at 1 any for lor fu fuel l or It ha baa haa been under he an au hority huriy that I at trustees In many pace IIa where the vast at majority of th the people who rho built buill the the ea of or those building for tor part of ot on nil lour rota one on liar dar In the week k for lor the hold IIII lit at Of a religion claw el not of oC the dill I Ien Iran en of ot other faiths but simply limply of ot those thOle who rho ho to attend or OJ whose whO PArents lanced It II and nd BO ao u erg not to Interfere with rub the school property or cause causa any II to tn the school district compiled complied with the Ie request It has haa not been down that In doing w toO they Ihy violated any my provision of any anT law Ii that has lieu hasU lieuwen U wen en n cited In n thin this connection The Tiu Th argument that stoma home of he children attending a district school were Vera permitted after atler school had ind nd many o cf r their companions had lone gone one home hom to enrage engage tn in n a religious religion for tor halt half an hour on ont one day duj In Ina a week they would jump to 10 UK Ule t e sin oon ludon that It wee wai port part of ot th the regular chool work does doe not appear to be IM very cogent agent and oven onn It if immature minds mind would could not bt be u able to discriminate der Iy y y n ft as to 10 the respective function of oC tin the he choral and the Ille chute church what of ot Ill It Itt It t r the law I la not violated It If th the schools are kept free tree from nectar ct r ran lall an II religious or denominational Joe doe who I la hurt by 11 th the tee Ilia of oC the choral once In III a while for tor torIl a Il lure a concert a debating or r re Iclon claw elan or any oUter other orderly and end proper roper tin use sanctioned by the trust truSI trustees In n control r Hut we do not just juat now to tl en an ener f er r loin Into tho lito ho manta of ot the religion claw chi qU or the tit wisdom or policy IlOIlo o or of cia lu In the Ut publIc buildings We W merely l to 10 how lov ho thud that the Sui attempt to o lau law as n the opinion of or h he State Atle yU U Is I nn ern utter failure allure and horn does dOl not meet UM UIe lace liU sti at et t till ill it No one claims that U tt U la lawful or Ight tel 11 t tend r or conduct re reo glows i in tin 11 the public his Thill paper lill 1 ill Ii an as much opposed to fy rely mich nth by o vor made mall M as Mn Th The Su b n r the till moat mo t ardent has h been empty empl pare pace pal and pimply the Ilia lone of lIr f mw hut have h fon ml their way wa mo tin tin till columns of or a I Jour RI ml and mt l hy by x the thu way nay wa even It If the were we arbitrarily elated saint the classes that have be been n held betel therein herein which doe d not 1101 necessarily n tol fol ol 10 nw w front tho lit Ih opinion and nIl advice of ot li re Superintendent there thre l I no u by 11 i lan s in must tut as All bo averted asserted by I that paper The Th tu fu furre uro at ot tI I rests r ell with their and conductors and Is II an art another arther other her and different matter mutter entirely |