| Show FASTENS MURDER ON DOCTOR PAYNE Dr Sure S Defendant Caused Death Deat of Miss Hill STRONG oli Wu Not for tUn Health of the Hie Death UBI allied The Th I for lor the state tat In the case c of lit Itle of or Utah Ulah vs VI Dr K F 8 R J with murder In tho Ui III Dr I r ty I He Ile wan II on the wit new stand till morning und ml W I examination an In hour and a halt Wh a court took lt It noon hIs hla direct l 4 not been con 1 Dr Jr Mayo pave faYe tome IOme very Yer strong ox port which to CUI en the crime erline upon the defendant He stated that the attempted oj mut h ha haben ve ben been within tro hours of ot the time ot Mis Hills death und that the tho rupture which at nt atthe the lit ve been b on caused by bythe bythe the Instruments contained In Dr which found at nt atthe the foot of ot the couch upon which Miss MUa Hill died Her Hor lie be attributed to of ot the nerve which could have luwe boen blen by a II shook shock to tho th heart such uch as liS n I person would experience tho pain of ot an operation ODe ration similar to tho ono In Inthis Inthis this Ho lie stated tn l that It would have been toen Impossible for to tho young I lady hilly to 10 perform the operation herself I Dr 1 r occupied Ills his u seat Mat In Inthe the court COUIl room and hi wire was able to b be present again today after atter her tainting fainting spell ot at yesterday e afternoon and the h and her little daughter occupied o u pied Iliad choir chairs beside Lc the lIe doctor There were very few lew spectators present nt session WILLIAM H Il The first witness culled Ms morning I was William H U Tremayne an nn assayer who has hns an office omee just across the jolt jail from Dr Paynes Aynes at East Temple street He testified that he WAS In his office all day clay on Dec 20 and did not see lee Dr until after the officers arrived He lie loomed ot at the tho occurrence after the officers arrived At Attorney torney lorney Wanless moved to strike out nil the tho testimony of ot the witness on the ground that It was Vas immaterial and had no connection with tho case cose The mo motion tion was denied by the tho court DETECTIVE D TESTIFIES Detective Chase Chue was then recalled to the stand by Mr and a jacket and fur tur boa bOl at al the ones on that were on a chair In the of ot Dr Payne layn when he entered the same lame He Mid that He lie turned them both over to Mrs McKay He lo was wal asked If ft lie he know knew the distance between Dr Paynes and tho police station Mr objected to the th question on the ground round Will was Immaterial and not elble the th corpus delicti Is 18 After hearing arguments on the matter Judge Morse tha state to proceed and prove the cause of ot death tho OH DR MAYO 1 YO CALLED Dr Mayo was then called to the stand and testified that he was called In to see ace Miss AIls Hill at about 9 that at In III Dr Paynes He made madea a n brief examination of ot the body hody then but later at nt about abou 4 In the un parlors he made another ex animation and found a bloody cloth up upon upon on her was not fastened to her clothing Th The cloth was then Intro Intra Introduced Identified by the witness as the one taken tram from Miss lIell Hills body At about S that night Dr Mayo stated that he h and his the tho county attorney performed an on autopsy upon ullon the remains which he described d In He said that the liver heart a and lungs were natural except that the lungs and kidneys were con congested and the heart was slightly small mall smaller maller er than Is Iii natural An examination of ot the brain of ot the woman disclosed dl closed the fact laet that l It was V 8 perfectly normal In his judgment he stated that the rupture was waB made within two hours ot tilt the time of ot deuth d The rupture must have hae been caused by som 5 hard Instrument that could have beon so as to dilate the canal At this point ha he was wall handed the sat satchel satchel chel In Dr Paynes and asked ask If any of or the instruments therein could have been used an a Q sir any of at them could have hae been beon used sed for tor that purpose was WIlS the answer He could c uld not state positively that the rupture was wa caused by b a 0 but I I I said laid that any hard Instrument have caused d It State whether h r or not In your judg judgment JUd ment Miss MIM Hill HIli could liac performed that O upon herself She could not was Va tho answer The doctor then Ihen explained hl why It could not done clone by the young woman Stale ilIa Ie whether or not In your ment an operation wits ne to tove nave ve HID Hili life or for tor her health No there th was Vaa no operation neo I Iery ery He lie stated that the operation must I been performed within two before hi r death The doctor explain explained ed cd In detail how such lIuch operation lire are generally 11 exam examination he stated that this thle operation was VIII not a lL very ery one Tho corn oom cornmon I mon dams dru used u ee in auch operations he Mid are arf ether and chloroform and ox In detail the tho effect of at such dUll drugs ullOn n a person lortOn When n It person linn a n aheart heart which U I small In proportion to the other organs ot at the l od he h Mid that chloroform very vel dm roue to 11 use as I It Impeded the tho or that I organ From your examination state stale what was as the cause of the death ot at Miss Hill I Paralysis of ot the nerve Any ny great shock to the heart l would ORUI such ench paralysis he sale said Tho pain of the operation might have hn caused n a shock to the heart which would cause caust death He lIe stated that U It would be bo very ery dangerous to administer chloroform to toa toA a In a room where the tho air was close or In a room ro m that 1 Dot Ilot properly ventilated He was shown the pills lilli that were found In Hills room and gave 1110 tho contents content of ot them He slat sIn that 10 J of et them could bo be taken at one dooe and ancl not have n fatal effect The court then took a t recess until 2 1 this afternoon A QUESTION One of ot the questions flaked asked Dr Mayo this afternoon by District Attorney ney lie What In your judgment caused the paralysis paral ll of ot the nerve The administration of at chloroform was the reply It Is III very ery evident that the doctor attributes Miss Hills death to the administration ot chloroform which was 8 given before the operation was 11 attempted His testimony ny Juste tore fore the noon recess recell also goes III to that tho pills which Ml us Hill hull had In her room had nothing whatever to do With her death Dr Mayo wan WM under tion by Attorney when this re report port po t closed YESTERDAY YI Prof Irot McKay who was on the Bland when the News report closed day afternoon testified that he h hAIl had known knowlI NISI Hill Hili for lor 23 years that she had taught school here for tor eight years She WIlS a 1 second cousin ot o Mrs McKays He stated that on the morning of at Dec 20 Miss Hill left lett the tho house before he did and tho n he saw her eho sho was Wall lying encl dead In Dr Paynes Witness Identified fied the hat found In Dr I r onice o lt as one belonging to lIss Hill MISS HILL HAD BEEN DEEN Mrs McKay vs all the nex next witness and It was during her by Mr that the fact that Miss Hill was n divorced woman camo ellmo out She stated that Miss Hill was engaged to a n man named John Wright In Missouri 1 and that they came here together and he hI went on to San Fran FranCisco Francisco Cisco In 1880 1896 she h said that Mas II Hill wont went to California and married Wright but that their married life lite was un unpleasant unpleasant pleasant and only lasted a 0 few tew months when Miss Ils Hill left her husband huband and went back to Wright then secured scoured a II divorce from her on the ground of ot desertion and tiM sM resumed her h r maiden name nam Mrs McKay Elat Elated ed that she found a n box of or pills In 1 lIls Hills room which had been over overlooked overlooked looked by tho police e WITNESSES Mrs Mary Mar K 1 Dond testified that she saw aw 1 Hill at On the morning ot her death She was crossing the street diagonally across a from the Des ret National bank to towards wards the Utah National bank There Therewa wa W R nothing m her appearance would Indicate anything unusual said the witness C B E L a clerk in Auer bachs store Il sold Mica Me l Hill tour four yi U hI ot che at about aboul 1116 on mottling J of qt Dee 20 She purchased which is III tor surgical He lIe said that eho sho seemed to be lie In quite a 11 hur hurry Fy ry Gordon H 11 a n t cr testified that he Wile was at police hood hondo Barters nt about noon on In Deo JO 0 When hen Dr I r Payne cam camo In And said that a n woman had come to hi and as dying The seemed to ta tobe tabe be very ery much excited went with willi the tho others other to Or Dr Paynes Dr Pr Payne and OI entered the Iho room first and was Imme Immo Immediately behind them He III said that there was a n cioe clOft smell Amell In the room and that Miss lIss Hill was on a II couch and evidently tiled died without a struggle Dr told laid that she Iho had come to 10 his hl and aud asked for tor a n restorative which he hall hail Riven her after h she asked for tor u and while he ho was getting the key kl she became unconscious BY DY OFFICIALS OJ Barlow and Detective Cha Chah corroborated tho testimony of ot Mr r Place concerning Dr Paynes visit to the police station and the return to hi and finding Hill there tho dead Mr Ir Barlow said ald there wo a satchel nt t the toot foot of ot couch con surgical Instruments nt He wai Ial unable to positively po Identity Identify the tho satchel l but bUI was wa positive about the instrument Detective Chase Chue positively Identified the satchel he and tho Instruments both bOlh bOlhas us as those found at the tool of ot the couch Ho Ue testified that he found a II bottle of at In the doctor laboratory which he had hac out from a large number of ot other bottles n E W Hall wan wall the last hut witness called yesterday Ho stated that he hewan wan 1111 employed at lit 8 S D l under undertaking taking establishment and that he find an assistant All Hills body from Dr Paynes at about 3 or 4 oj In the tho afternoon |
