| Show ci ense m in i tIle i Case Docio is 11 ic on ci lije Q Stand Sand and Testifies to 10 Leading lg Up to lo Hills Excited ed and Declares Dr Di fayo Has It II In ill For Him Il Describes Miss MI Hills Convulsions V The proceeding In Iii Judge Jude Dl Dishis court today toda In the cue case of the ihus State Hate vi Ur JJr U II S Payne charged with the mur mar murder murdel marden den del of Miss Anna D Hill lIlli were of a highly dramatic character and nd were particularly I eo 10 when the ant at attempted attempted tempted on to ex cx explain IJ plain away statements he lie is II i alleged to have made annie shortly after arrest concerning the lie condition of or Miss II Hill when silo she life his hi From lie Oie course courM Pursued by Mr Ir Wan Wax leis leas fur for or the tite defense It Is II evident that Unit he lie will make u a I strong atron effort to 10 prove that lout the operation informed upon Miss MiM IR a done domme by hers lf and Ind that her liar condition to so 0 far eg iii a he the alleged lIe od con COli were rare concerned wai wap caused by II hier UKO UHe of i Il nn l it was WiS brought out this morning III In the tie mony of 0 G I N McKay that Miss Hill had hati a Q box of ot pills hula In her room nod and that list they the wore store supposed to be penny pennyroyal pennyroyal royal royalA rO A 41 great gleat surprise was created when Dr Payne Paye WIS as placed upon the lie stand He lie described the dead denti woman condi condition lion Ion when site she entered lili hi chico and ands s snore ore that thai lie ho hind had ha never scott en Item her he for Hut Hu t on tie Ito was put hut through a u moat limit rigorous test of oC his hll lit knowledge dge of medicine and nm It was wan anything hut favorable to 10 the lie defense def n e eAt At t times time Ito hl became very sery e angry am anti excited and refused to tn an answer answer questions asked n k 1 by ly Mr Waster Weller uter volt seit ell until ordered 11 ere to tu do HO so by the lie court While trying to explain the cause ant lint and symptoms if convulsion lie be became hopelessly tangled While huIe on the stand he denounced Attorney len ln anti and Dr Mayo Maya He lie sail id that time the latter laid had had It II In lit for him for a II long time hue anti and syu 1118 seeking t to tomake tomake make trouble for tor or him Dr Pr Mayo Ma o had u a sent seat next to 0 the prosecuting attorney anti and frequently prompted him hIm during the examination Dr Odeli Odell was also nino present for a n time Mrs Irs Payne pled a prominent seat leal In the fIts court loom and anti at lit the conclusion of ot this Ihla mornings f session lon slon she darted angry glances at Dr Mayo Iao and said he lie had better Jetter borrow some money and anti return to college anti and learn a n little about med mad helno The Th doctor however hower paid patti no at III attention attention ten lion either to yIn Iu Payne or item her re me remark remark mark that tIit the tue latter had hill had It In for him ant was very Cry er trying to him lilt lie He was nervous haggard very sony tunic pule and amI his Dyes oyes were bloodshot At A t times time he could hardly speak laud enough h to ho bo hearth heard ho Ito sold saul lil he lie could no nomore more Inure questions then lien anti and IIII said S lit lie would have hao to leave the courtroom Ills itt at attorney torney tome fought hard to save sav him turn from the ordeal and objected to 10 questions at every eor opportunity The Tho court however ruled against him hum saying paying lIa that the de tie defendant had hinti AS AH to the lie cause CAUl of Miss Hills death dath anti and the lie ion had a Ii right to him uK n his know ledge of medicine It Is 18 quite likely that lint the ease caie will occupy all till of today toda and aini allt probably lie be bel IH continued l until tomorrow gH as It la ic t un understood that the defense will putt put on some expert witnesses The Tho defense e in the tite H I ij 8 S Payne mur her der case cal had lied an Inning In Judge DIehls court this morning As Au A soon soot ns nl the pro proceedings s were opened Attorney Wan Van Wanless Vanless less CIS for defense I rense arose and amid asked the court to compel the lie state to elect which allegation In the complaint wan the tho cause of ot MUM MIss 1111 Anna I D Hills death County Attorney At Westervelt vigor rigor rigorously objected und anI In support of hIs bis bl remarks cited riled the cane caMe anti and the lie ruling of the court nut limit did the lie attorney for or the lie defense ask Alk the state III ate to I elect elett what caused death asked Mr 11 I think replied Mr that I the attorney R for the lie defense knew the law bettor better titan than to do that Judge mehl held that the complaint com did not nol allege that list any Rn one PartIcular oct act caused death ileath and tIle the motion of ofIr Mr Ir was waa dented denied FOUND A BOX nox OF OP PILLS Prof O 0 1 N McKay WM was then placed on the stand and arid aked ked if It lie III hi found a box of pills pili among Miss Mil effects treet He tie replied that hat he hi ii did tIll and turned the box over oer to the police pollee The box was produced and anti placed In III evidence DU nn PAYNES 1 TESTIMONY TE TI The defendant Dr R l 3 S Payne wag waa then tItan placed on in the stand Answering An Mr Ir the accused gave gasa the fol following following lowing testimony On this the mornIng of Dec M II O I 1 came down to my toy about IB IS minutes at af after atter atten ter ten 10 lilIes MIMS MI Hill Hili came Into my m office clOne at about almut a Il quarter to 12 and anti asked If I 1 snap the doctor dottor I motioned her to ie take A fI seat sat I Sh ithe paa PASsed ed by b tilt the chair and threw on oti the lofa sofa Site Silt SIt and lId w emed wearied and soon begat began vomIting I PlOt got an all lh pan n for tor her hr herIt to It vomit In She Clue continued to vomit and her ber tongue got thick until she Rhe lost 1011 her IMF power of ot speech I took oft off her hat and aad she attempted to hei hi rubber hut I removed them for fur furher her I held her bands Then I removal mol 1 her II coat roat and set t her luau hand satchel 1 by the table I got lOt her a XH S of nf water Then Thea en I beard a I knock HI lit th the tho Vor ioor It Wag waa a had Jah hut but I h toI hEr I was waa w l Wh Wino n I 1 returned t to 10 Mii YoI Hill she lite WI w TB nn oil the lounge I and I mw she wi we c in com What Whal did ou do tb I mixed up some anti and gave g It U to fo hw law I gave lier hr Santo porno every overy f few w minute hut but lid ni mit 1111 t take all nil of ot it H t DId you use Ulle ue No Did you use ulle any anal anaesthetic I J did not nol V What wa ns ilie hp troll hum My Iy opinion IH Is I she Rh at h hal ul akin thing which brought nn a 11 u II 1 und nd ad death tI ties a Ih ii Nut Not N 01 knowing wim 1111 ts to die 11 Ii WWI seas I run ran over In lit re reo I 1 thought ht hi t to so cull call In the lie t p it 1 ill 1 i i iI Hud hid I you eui gj 11 i 1 o hi hr r before I f never had hiatt Hid you know of lr if MK Hills lIllis t I did not l Id you ask ash her lter herI I did not Did iId Id you Olt know nn fin 1111 h 1 used I did nut Her Ifor position was wall the he same Fame lh 1 I in 11 when Nhen 1 I ha The fht was a iati when solicit I lift left I tried triet to lu hurry the hit police n so th Y would see It lien her sh she died lied I made madea a statement of these Met acl to the th hi of If f titers to 10 Dr Mayo May ana Ill the thus Junt at attorney torney torne How lies long was sIte she he In your om About bout half at an hour Did you ou know knoss who the ii other patient wiN vaa vaaI wiNI I did not nOI know knoll her name annie Do you cu IU know knoll yet vet et who she Is Iso No o I do not Do no you roo know of an anything thing would cause those convulsions whim when a 1 4 patient was In III the thin condition of MItt I n nYes HII 7 Yes 11 an n c would woula cause it DEFENDANT D The 1118 he defendant u WI u then Ihen subjected d to ton toD n D mont severe and rigid tion by Mr lt What did you ghe gItt the he granule for forTo 5 To Io stimulate the h hoart art action The defendant nil l tin lits bad bo Iru tl N rd medicine for 30 34 Mais nl ar At the nn OK r f ID t he lie graduated tho III i lb i of ot In rn lie Hi sie tn to time the J I cult us II assistant t sur Bur surgeon geon in the hilt h nimy Ilmy ui in Later lie ItO went WaRt to the Wt t indies He lit hai ai bf n in Salt I Lake Ik ik sin shin 18 s sIs Is 11 your our l or ns as 0 n a General but I did make maka n a specialty of cf o women nIl anti children NB Dr Payne lane was then w II a t I great length on told and it tt OUM was wu salted d to describe Mu Jl Hills He Jle sou Her Item eyes oyos Q ware rolling moltIng l Item Her breatt ing lug was su hard ala add her hur face race was a lug Ing was waa WI n a Vak sr v ak action of ot tri tM heart She tried to rise up two to or tilt thi hi e times Did you OU not say In to the th county alter attorney ney ne In the Ito presence of Dr Mayo au lUll 1 i Chief Paul that http Hill several times rolled on the Positively I did 1111 not nit r I said sall sal sin Mh pu put U one foot toot on un the Hour loor I Id lut lot of things lUnge then thell I would not say my Ive no doubt of Hut hI t Ih lv county attorney Ws W Vu te teany j jany any Uti Inducement nii hlll out to 10 you ou tomake to tomake tomake make statements No 0 but the i attorney fX ext X t V deed a und and manner over me ni In und itoh I T answered him lila himIn himIn In it glittering i i I saw iW S what their a u aIs uIs V Vis Is that tha all alt MAYO IAO WAS WM I saw en that hint Dr Ma o waa bound 13 t I have me convicted an Un the use of chloroform Why Wh Because e he hI me nie if It I chloroform Then Payne 1 ne berum bel angry an ant aM i u cx saId lIe He has hail bad It In ha for or nio m I Lu rOn Il e 5 told mo mile he lie vas was bound t tu ai ut U Ume me ne sooner or later hater Catch you OU at what What hat vvo we I n non you on afraid of ot otI I dont know did you OU malta malee up your our mind to 0 do Why doWhy not to answer an ne on my m oath Then you rou did not act Intend to tell th il truth ruth ruthI I did not I am telling tilling the truth now Rut nut you didot th than n No WANLESS OBJECTS At t hip point Mr Wm Watles le object d d 11 dhe t the the he line of ot but bUI ti II I I court curt urt ruled that thai stat M t ts me I nets voluntarily nut ic and the theion oi j ton ion waa Wu U overrule Mr Ir r ih th h n a wi WInt nt back blk to tf th lb of or i lit lie 1 l 1 t I tirl 11 Irl irl ner If he hI ii could ollie Oil 1 e Ih I lit Ith V h conditions of f b bt t was RII 10 I IS answer only in ini 1 i K general and limit 1 way a V All 11 ases cases are nut not ik Is la all ho lie III I pay tay III PAY lX Tr Dr fI Payne ayne wj va ito n exam In 1 f n length uj un m its it i F 11 n md the th Ilon sf r tl heart I p arl ri I nr u uPS tl In PS i u IT 4 f fi of if t Mi Mii 1 i s 1 i t Dr ayn nn yn in h I i 1 IK H i 1 I oo Kf 1 i OH RM th uti l v ul jit 1111 1 f net I iuli ho h su IU a MI IIIi I had hat to 10 1 I till lie V i 11 Ii I t then bert th t n il d dall all this |
