Show Report On Ship Subsidy I by bp b Herri Urged That T al ri Bill Will Wil No Nol Ac ilc lc Its If deposed u Measure is i Dictated To o be lb lt I Wrong in ii h Principle Unjust Vicious Puce Class Legislation I I 15 8 tor henry Derry representing the Ihu minority of l tin hit m mate ln ate nto committee on today al pre pr seated len tell the report In lii II opposition n to the lie pending ship subsidy bill bi Most Moat of ot tho the points have been beon coveted covered in speeches In tho the senate ho minority deny Ion t accuracy of ot both bolh the tho predictions and ami tho the facts in imi II the this majority report They Thoy urge urlo Ii rge that tho t he bill bi is II wrong Iong In iii II and 1111 declare that hint It will 11 utterly full fail In iii tho thin accomplishment of ot ltd Its IH ProfeSsed ob objects objects They hey also say nay Iny lint while It I IH is l not hot lot no 10 lb complicated as OH a the tho subsidy bill bi ot or lie llio th Congress u it I Is u In some to ro oven more inure The Thu Thol minority l continue The Flue bill bi proposes proposed to tax tho the whole people to the lie of ot several millions for the lie benefit of ot one single Industry Y Besides BI hll tho tim statistics of or the tho InRI two to wo yell prove that the shipbuilding In Industry II does docs not need nd such special as nut distance but bul la Is rapidly Increasing under natural conditions They Thoy Tho criticise the lie feature of ot the hits bill Mi which curries carries the tho subsidy for foreign malls and say 8 Flue Tho highest ute lute i of oC subsidy is 1 given to 0 vessels while tho Ito fust ocean are really rely carried In 23 and 21 2 knot kno vessels The rhe mall mal to 10 tho the slow American already alread too high In made Immensely higher by this bill biH bi Wa We pay poy more entire ro for u is 1 weekly service than England pays for tor n a t weakly soviet by ly much fa faster falter t r ships than thun outs ours They Tho further urge that tho the bill bil maTs no provision against a timid mid 1111 claim that It encourages a I com coni COI loading leading to ouch such a I trust They ilso 1180 say The Tho he lines hines might also merge merre with wih foreign uncut lines to control freight and t Ind poe pas Pos Hengel eng r rates Thereby our subsidy would be ba aiding tho ho foreign partners of ot our subsidized vessels The report closes by sayings saying Vu We o know that there are aro ru hundreds and thousands of Industries In our cur Ur country doing a n losing business but we deny that Congress COl gress for tor this reason con can congo cango go Into public treasury and save them from bankruptcy Wo We sympathize with wih till nil men mel In tho the hard struggles of life but bUl It Is not clot the he duty of ot our gov gay government to interfere In the private t af It fairs airs of ot the tho citizen Wo We Vo believe that lint nil all ni men inca mOi should Jiava an nn equal and fair fairchance fairchance chance chanco In itt the lie race nice for tor or wealth and hap citizen I should bear his lila share of or tho thin of or the tho govern government ment l nt ono one 1 never nover bo be tho the re recipient roo of ot root mot Riven given to others Absolute equality ut rights Is 11 a doe doo tine wo we 10 should n abandon Tho The bill bili bi Is In wrong In principle unjust vicious pure class clan D |