| Show I BILL I PASSES SENATE 1 A After a Warm Worm Debate Over Two and a Half Hours I ALLISON LEADS OPPOSITION homo Santo Supported tile he Mill Out Nt If ci l lo to time ilia of ot Their The Tho McMillan voc vac dilation bill tho the Senate Bennt day lilY with n a voto vote of If t 13 to 6 G af ut utter after ter tor nn an earnest o discussion thud that was ox cx I over two anti and u a tumult linK hours So Bo BoCar far Car OK as Is In known own however was not no I Inn an sin opinion changed or a I conviction al 11 altered by hy I tho appeals that wore vero made It H may lOllY bo be said 81 III In la justice to some seine of ot tho the who supported tho the bill lilli that they expressed a faith In III tho lie of ot vaccination but felt Celt bound to support the tho measure in deference to tilt till wishes of ot their Choir Tho Tue snaiL mon nh champion of ot the opposition was wall an Senator Allison part at of whoso ar argument appeared in III last Ilist evenings News Nessi Ho He I ho contended fervently that hat I tho the pa of oC the tho bill might result In itt tho of the health board resign Jag then best what Would your wives children do mb exclaimed tho the Senator What means would bo ho In iii your hands to prevent the lie of oC the tho contagion COli tUition Senator Thomas suggested that It be b e a good thing perhaps If It lie tho members of uI tho tue board would resign What Whal would you do then asked Son Sen Senator S n ator Allison on give the power to tl the lo Ia local cal eal health boards I have heard that argued but Jilt It worth anything While the thu hoard board of ot health In one ono local locality locality ity might enforce the tho ito board In tho the next district might bo JQ lax and the mutter matter becomes a ii farce Senator Allison AHlMan said that ho he suffered front From tho lie smallpox when a n lad and that hint h do he WIl deprived of ot hut his liberty moro more than Ihan ho hI would have been had he Ito heen subjected to vaccination He Ito expressed tilt the belief that vaccination was WIlH that hint the tit sentiment In III the lie State tato In regard tu tf It Wits Will misdirected 1 tind nd that the tho measure should not pot pass NOT Nor CONVINCED Senator Tanner snub mild that ho hue would uJ the th bill because he Ito was ivan not yet yetI I to thin the of ot vaccination Furthermore I the tho board of at health lund had exceeded the tho power Intended to tl be bo It t by tho the lust last Legislature The Tho major maJorIty ty Ity of ot the people copl l of if tho the State Stale nit felt that woo wan nut not u it got KOOI thing The Flue board of oC health while b 1 log Ing rent gln In III HH its efforts to vaccinate tho the chool children WIS very vcr careless In regard to quarantIne Ho Ito hind hat met n ii unit nan nn on one of or the streets of oC this elt city In III whoso whose who o family there vas smallpox I and ind yet the house way ivan not quarantined I Pr The ho lii nit lilt n bill hili hil I Is ha only on I v t i iii what II was as designed cd to lt lw hums expressed t two tw years rears ago limit hut the tho hoard board of health hind had token taken of ot a It technicality lIe He bought that tho ho people pc of o this lila Stilt State would revolt n against tha tho lie rulo rub of ot tho Ito board If It the pending measure m sill lid not pass pasA The people arc demand In hug ng the tho passage of 01 tho th ii huh bill and anul under tho the circumstances ho lie said Mid it was 1 the lie duty of ot the tue Senate to pass pas It Senator Dennion also expressed sumo somo skepticism hs tin to the lie virtues of ot Vaccina lon He lie ulso tilso that the State of or health hued hall been b Jn unwise In the way It hUll gone Kono about to lo accomplish things thin It If vaccination be lie muncie made tom com ul ory It op ly to 10 everybody ant be mode made u n condition cnn precedent to entering places of it such ns nil theaters dances and any public gath gathering ering HIS 1115 WISH WI SIt IT Senator Smoot paid that his bibs people p to compulsory vaccination yet pt they could miss na nit intelligently on oil any public as II any all 1111 p anywhere They desired M him to support ho to McMillan bill 1 and he lie proposed to do lIo It Senator thought that If II vac vito Ic In is enforced d it ought to begin with the tho Governor anti and then IMn the thin Senate at nl the head and amid going to the tho feet Ceet Would you ou support such uchi a measure asked Allison AO 11 Personally I would be II In favor of ot lust Just such lIuch n a measure replied Murdoch but of my constituents aro 1110 opposed to compulsory vaccination anti antiI I am nm here hero to represent them In the tho Senator Allison Allson had been heen hU his grey groy m tn er lr with the result that he lie h had the following amendment to make in tie the title of oC th thit bill sill An net act to tn promote the tile spread sJ rend of contagious diseases III ense Klesel seconded It it but hut when It tt was wu put to a 1 C voto vot Alli Alii sons tone lono treble tre le voice oleo was wall heard In the tho thon n rm tI VI THOMAS GIl S m Senator Thomas said that he hI had been opposed to vaccination for tor twenty years lOar and amid that opposition hud had come como through observation find and study Ke ie road from Crom nn an eminent English who hio Inveighed against vac vaccination nc In strong sirens terms Senator Love laM mahl that he ho believed In Inthe inthe the efficacy of If vaccination his ht con on wished shed him to the bill anil lie be therefore there Core do so no Senator Names ant and I Larson spoke In favor fn or of oC the bill dooming deeming It their duty to lo carry out the tha wishes of their con can constituents Pt DILL mUA Senator Whitney cald said that hat he ho would take for Cor his text of ot a very cry inlet din dis discourse course 1 I came rame not to do 11 0 my will but hut those who I n me Inc In He lie see 8 why h the Senator Selin tor from Crom Weber Velier Weh r Allison could believe In Im 1111 Immunity when wh n he ho hall had had hall when hien a j boy bo and hail had broken out two or three times tinieR luring during the tho P lon He ne fur further timer ther laid Said that some como are best bellI answered nn by silence lie He then lien to Thomas ThomM Carlyles beautiful tribute to unit commended It to the Junior I from rota Weber along with tho tue Swiss proverb Speech eh Is in l sliver silver but bul sll nee 11 I golden I t this measure concluded Senator Whitney hitney because my say In constituent ent wish me toe to not because I nm am a 1 foe lo to vaccination or nn an enemy of ot the health board Senator Alder unqualifiedly In fa tn favor vor or of at vaccination lie He thought that It the lie greatest protective measure uro known to science lie He said Mill tint that the children of Utah were wert th tM roost most precious of if nit all thin th States State he lie honored tho the health officers for or Join doing nil till the ennui to Protect thorn them from Crom the Senator Allison had the lie la lat lant t Inning and In reply to Senator Whitney he that he hI not runt read ret the tho particular pawnees passages of oC referred l to by the thi hut but he lie haul had re rend d the story of or Pen Don Quixote nail nn he be remembered that Don Dolt rode n a horse nt at the head bend of ot the and Sancho roll rode nn an a n nt til the Now ow I l would rather tather be on n a horse leading the tie pro CO IMI th thAn n tin Pancho Sancho riding nIt nil ni n as at nt the rear Senator Smoot mont called for the roll mil cill arid and the vote te was nil sue n follows CoU For the bill Barnes Howell Howe Johnon I u Loran Larson Love Iove Murdock Smoot o oI Tanner Thomas Th Whitney 13 Allison Lawrence 5 |
