Show urr I J us It If were score w ro to 10 demon f atrato the H of or tho the measure to give hc healthy children the right of entry to tho the pUblic which Imn panned aed both housed houseH of tho the Legislature by n large larlo majority It lies has hn been sup HUp plied piled by liy b tho the ml of 1111 opponent They Tho either elthor do not under uland lt purport or they cannot appreciate date ciot their own failure to furnish a Q rele role relevant roler vant argument against It 11 r The McMillan bill which must await actIon by Otie no Governor simply Dimply puts mite In plain English J ll that which wan waA Intended by previous l gl t In reference to tu the powers lowen conferred on boards of health It taken away avay nothing hereto heretofore tore fore conferred by law To Tu F the ordinary render etter the law an RK n It stands tand on the tat stat tile uto book of 1500 m oven cven Including that of ISO 1891 H 19 I plain without further I legislation legI Hut But it haN hall mn been BO eo con construed tru d and strained to reach the tho design of ot u LI few tew doctors that something was absolutely needed dd to place the he matter beyond further dispute fM rh bill now passed does not as ns Ire fre frequently stated oppose vaccination Home of HH its 1 strong arc are be believers believers lievers hovers In the tho n of It f lots doss dO not hinder binder the full rull operation of sanitary and amI quarantine regulation It does riot not attempt to cripple any board of health In measures necessary to protect the public from Irom tho the spread of ot contagion Tho provisions of ot existing exl laws ml nr left Intact by measure that hits hug been The bill mined to meet tho the desires nd demands demand of ot un an overwhelming ma majority maI I Of the people P Pie of thin this State forbids the Imposition of ot vaccination as n a a neon con precedent to thu tho admission of healthy children n to conta a lion into Inlo tho the public rho I That Is all nU Will not the small minority who have tho the measure look at atIt atIt atIt It In the tho th t of reason and without t the tho spectacles Pt of oC prejudice 19 i no itc question In the present movement m us to tu or ur not vaccination atlon Is a n preventive or a palliative of or That docs 1005 not figure In tho the discussion No one disputes the right tight rightfulness Of t the tho powers conferred by law lav 11 tn In quarantine persons with a n dl or who have been leen b en ex exposed e I jio posed ed to It There Is III no attempt to ad mit to a Q school lI child chilli liable through disease or cr exposure to It to toi i carry Orr Infection to other othel school children The he endeavors made during tho the de do debate dop p bate to 10 confound these r mid and andini mix ini them up so na as to tn t muddle the tin pub hub t Ho Ito only serve to the op up opponents r ut of lawless tyranny In their lr de dl determination d termination to carry curry out the will of or the tho people After discussing tho the merits ot o the thet t bill In ht committee and In open session there was a J no 10 need for tor Ill Ita advocates to too togo IIO go o Into lengthy arguments in Its It favor The notion that they thoy could coul l not nol because they the would not do so was worthy only of a a lawyer who finding himself IC In III the tio wrong wro n 11 sought nought to Irritate and provoke tho the other side aide The same ame opponent n a od ld ns nl reported to tu tho the press Suppose it 11 w ro a It cholera epidemic and thin bill Is broad broud enough to tu Include cholera and diphtheria tot this bill would render th tim board of health pow powerless erless to act and mil cholera and would rage through the State and andt t where would We w 0 b be beI 7 I That shows a lack luck of or understanding I P ot of the tho bill that Is b truly surprising In a 11 ii I senator Tha rho bill docs does not Mt prevent any nn If of the trie precautions necessary In an epi epidemic epidemic epidemic demic na matter of what hilt It U does not touch on cholera or diphtheria I Inot not noC not dots does It hinder regulations regulation As da s to tu toI I smallpox as may bo lie enforced jj Lb against any other when eil epi It If either disorder were preval prevalent f ent nt would healthy children fri to It be shut out of the public school ii If It the bill had not been blen passed paRsed would j healthy school children be ho selected u as objects object of regulations against I ti t cholera Should they the be 00 vaccinated j against It or ur diphtheria If there Is II or Ir be La nn an epidemic I l I of or smallpox mul vaccination Is s the I I sure rore preventive It Is II claimed to be b ber I r why Vh the compulsion to school schoolchildren k children who according to the health reports report have hae been bOen the lie least subject U I to the tho The majority of eases cases Jih alleged to bo be smallpox are arc ot of persons r I above school age ne a c Why h not compel 1 vaccination of at adults adult There ThaN has ha bern been no lit epidemic among school children or ori i that thaI can enn be traced to that one OM class o or the tho population The senator who so 80 strongly supports the th course of or the tho secretary of or the board of or health also Ilbo made this remark It ls Is absolutely proven roen beyond yord v t doubt that a n child In perfect health can con the Ih to an un another another other child hiM In a school room through carrying the tho Infection of or In InU I lt U its clothed lOtheL True rage race Sancho Panza Pania but If a n achild achIld child can cnn carry rl Infection Into lata u II school I cannot ton nn m adult carry It Into a theater an assembly u a l street car cor a n crowded store or to his home Ant And tn If It so 80 why h choo h children bo be discriminated against Further urther does vaccination va I dis disinfect disinfect infect the clothing of children If 1 not notT L T cannot t a 11 vaccinated child It If exposed communicate the tho dIsease dl to another child In tin tho room through carry CIUI ng pg the Infection In fn Its clothes tow ow lot Oo tit ill senator compare his hl own statement which l Is true truo but ti to tn hN hl own argument with th the thu assertion of the tM autocrat of the tha health board Whom horn he hI supports which we havo pub published before and which w Is III as us follows verbatim In my tn opinion there here would bo be no clangor to be anticipated from the at Qt of ot teachers tI at the SUite leo herll heril convention provided they shall have ha been successfully vaccinated ed od otherwise 1 there then th ru would bo be gre gret eret t danger They Thoy rho would wool not to bo liable to carry the disease to tl others unIes they themselves should first have contracted It One Ona On more moro assertion made by the Sean Sena Senator S nn tor to who w o would V bar har UV out healthy posed based ll e l children from tram the schools we will briefly notice It Is this A great many lIn people r In favor of It tho bill bull I who do not know what It ItIs itis Is III or lr what Its I hI effect will be Je I am Rm In Informed formed that every State In the tho Union has IlIla a n law similar to 10 the tha one onn which this thin measure Is in designed to repeal which gives the tue board hoard of health the right to Judicious authority under po JIO police lieu lice regulations If the tho people whose Intelligence Is thus thull depredated depreciated have no nil better bott r In Information Into Information formation to rill n than the Senators as JI dIM dis displayed 11 played In those thoe expression they are nr l Indred In tn the dark durle and to pass nn on tho the question Flint First the bill does not repeal any provision of lu V Second till all the judicious authority retorted referred to La will still remain If Ir tho tIm bill becomes become a n law Third every oer State in inthe Inthe the tho Union does docs not have 1110 such fluch a law ns as ashe he hl where compulsory vac vaccination ne emotion Is established 1 by law In healthy school children arc not selected as a n class claes solely to be bo operated upon The Ihie people of or Utah Uth or at as stated by several legislators leGI ninety per tr cent of or them unite In calling for this melUre to abolish certain arbitrary regulations re which they deem oppressive partial and not warranted by hy law Are Ara they to have hwo no voice oleo In a n matter niter that con corns their welfare anti and that of or their children lint Has It come como to this puss pass In Utah Itah that popular government Is for forthe forthe the tho time abolished and the will of a afew afew aes few es physicians and their follow tollow following lug ing Is III to and stifle the pub public lie lic voice spoken In no iio uncertain tones Wo Vo We hope h pe not We advise celia calm Judgment In the tue set settlement et of ot this matter and fair treat trent treatment meat ment It rr compulsory vaccination Is proper make mako It obligatory by law lass la and anI enforce It upon all nl alike If It It Is ad advisable for tor children only say lY so 80 In Ia plain I that there may mil be bo no dispute over Its itA actual meaning Dut But let tho the present unsatisfactory obnoxious at domination through a II doubt doubtful ful fui construction cOll of our cease nail and let tho the bill passed pa ed by h b BO io large a it 1 majority become a law la Thou Then voluntary vaccination as much mitch an as you yoi Ol please and enforce all rational lucas tires ares for tOl sanitation I and quarantine and nd thus thug effectually arrest thu progress o of contagious disease |