Deseret Evening News | 1910-07-14 | Page 10 | Statement of Brother of Murdered Woman

I SITI m I or ri It 01 WOMAN O I New Nets 1111 York July 13 In view of ot ro ye lasted IH that Porter Chart Charl Charlton ton l Ic n i will walk from tron jail Jull u n free treo than man nl III though ho loo him hits confessed to lu the murder of ot hi isle IH wHo w Ifo at III Lake Uiko fonio Co 11 o Italy Capt pI Henry Scott Mrs Charlton brother gave 1111 out u II statement today In which he hi a ks for far halt fair play Justice and anil a II fair trial I belle believe Scott said In III part Irl that when I 1 discovered Charlton my lilY coun country try If would then Ih 11 step In hl and see aee ec not nl m t that taut my m sisters death was avenged for I 1 have hao not nol Uen ho eri seeking vengeance but tUI that justice Ju be done dOlle I hao non 1011 I onlY for tor fair play lay Justice Ju and n trial so o u that th the some conditions may maybe maybe be bf ed 1 to 10 this cliMe case as all others othern when whon hen a n U le committed an and I have hau secured sufficient competent evidence In the opinion of ot my toy m counsel to 10 establish beyond the slightest hll 1 doubt three vital lIal points First that Porter Charlton mur mu murdered tiered dered my III sister In III cold blood In a It man manner tier ner ne that required time and deliberation to and anet that subsequently to In the Ihl murder oven every net nIl to hide hI hl crime showed l and fore tore forethought forethought thought Second thai at lit the Ih time of ot the tho roni rani mission of ot th the he ho was wan sane Third that thai Porter Charlton In is I now sane nano I rind that say ny attempt to 10 de laro him hInt Insane Is I nothing short of ot n a re rehn hn ud Intent upon the tho part of ot Charl CharI Charlton Inn ton In III proof of ot his hi contention C apt pt III Scott showed two 1100 letters one mm of nt which h hn h hn rave avs n Wll vin n written by b Renton Charlton 21 I 1 hou s before the Ih murder and the Iho other fr m Mr Mrs to 10 o n a f p ster 1 letter seems eem rational and 1 lu tails his hi with bin hi bride Mrs letter ilo M her II fl husband hUHl She Hie wy 11 In one nn He lie If Is II a n student hut but absolutely full nf of t cheerfulness In fact tad In disposition he h reminds remind me ale of ot a II lot except that thit Ih t Porter Is I always sine sane The Tho wold wort sane itano wn ens 0 underlined