| Show PAYNE BILL IS ISUN UN UNSATISFACTORY SA Republicans Admit This In a Mn Mea Measure sure While D 0 It In T HOT DEBATE IN HOUSE ON IT from 1 V II ut ry trIa er I Iroe Tn t I I Iw w tic the PIa I t I III witts i 4 ow Impert r rn o on n W V up the tI Meance of th the R ed d dI I that tt ft did not Melm It ad the tho art t lit 4 that r hl party part wr ne n nt f Ih II th thur the ur h by Ih the rate In ht the UM UMI I ter Inter of f th the II the 0 of Olm l de det deI who whon ho t I n phi I h Philippine n k 1 th the for 01 free trade I Ith the Ii I I the II tar fr south exactly uty opposite lets I w a exp I non In tier I na of nf plead ng r I U It on oa 0 of the or of hR I rill t ite while Mr Hr tit of nd j Mr 1 Clayton of nf Alabama 1 r ore lumber free firs hunt oot anti Ind free end free Un II I F F In the h come em the pup tl or n permanent n and nr none entirely th Ih th the hill hIlI FOR FOIt vr 1 r doon of dr I r ae u 11 who ho be beI beur I ur r In hl hi own land Ind and t the advance nt of nt his hili on pk VII We j I I r pr tattoo for tarn IMn An nnA om n who know the of their wn and a 11 1 peek k to In h held ld Item from rom the thern rn It a thet boh AmI American g niu and the wasteful An who ho hitters away w Ib on upon tops topa and II wR Oft FREID III DES Mr r Yung err New York u urged th the of t hide eq tile the f free Let INt duty been a upon ullOA our In autem tm tur It a eat a It old hl the ur Ihl tIngley Olne bill the tanning bull 0 of thle eon try w wee In a Mil bUt shoe the of I the duty t tb the In Inde de teener who w were en lb the ham trade rt h have become dl II end ul nl of them h have pim aim pimply pi ply h an r tile the tV th the tote crested H sd Ih of r the dun tI tIon on male and n belling hum 20 u 1 pro eto to 1 per par ant It I la humiliating to her hee a ty 0 em emIng Ing up tram from the th south hr nr per te lion Oft on m artl I UJ and tilde hide u th they ha t r Iw I pin durt en n that n Bald 11 SI ur M Mississippi 1 If he h argue I the ct bill would pet shop h on II the tr II I P tram Ww would nil rrt b be rip It consistent Mr iii 11 Il not with wit t Ibos opposing th the er of nt the dill duty on 0 lumber f And It lie wanted tie Ue put n I h tr ht list The Th Nil blip In th the 0 of Mr till els or Mississippi l did hat hl NIt Mp lit the pled 14 1 1 t h been en 1 Ot hll lb Ih n of lire ha bad been lux nut it of 0 In Mr ur r rI VI VIa a dut duty ot of lit 6 cents t j sound e often t ton t the true osley ot of IU ugar end Ad the polky 0 or Gifford In to toe e eiton of the tl ANT 1 nOo tl that lilt I It Neap II a Ir even n to tn the of f the th patter Mr Langley of Kentucky de 4 he w fuss Kill el tint t M Mat of at the Ih of the Payne Pam bill were ill la full tull It with u the of Idle I II Paul They ha hato hav piled to to h he amid d that U the pro I of the duty on lumber lumbert t I In with those t H Pty Flape w be tl ta deliver the ends t the reduction U In the 4 would 14 llac increase the ot of I nth mn XI Mr dented ABU 0 tAXING POW The Republican i weld Id Mr Clayton of labama d th manufacturers of 1 the tit Quat 1 by out If Io by JM and 11 h by poll r C that the government ment hu has Ih the rt right ht to the taxing power en a to 10 hand net citadel 0 to th them m The gov cov government he hh declared I had no right to tax except to revenue The Payne bill III Mr 1 wee c I In thAt IbM It 18 gave to b New Naw nd fre hide coal and d I lumber limber He H argued that whits h were beaded oat Jut Malts totton lOtton ties and the German be rimmed to the free list lit la order that th the begging trust my may get have tb the benefit of a on 11 Ju Jute The gain tuner of Ih the w pt t h Id bd bad his hh twine r free by HOf 1 and there we no reason why lute and cotton cotlon Use should not be tree Mr Jr Clayton maintained that th the w pres present ent nt or of the grew W out or et I sad aad that U lb IU IM bill WI was a tales pre temp offered y th to re doom their promises for tor tariff trItt Mr 1 Clayton charged that II a gu shed senator tor from loald a stale te IW e I that we In III who IU can spit It nero tt It and who the whole pony l In M lIt crl with a relent few and aad andle le h making a bill which cb ell aU Re lie publicans will TM The Mr 1 l or of N New a admonished Mr Clayton not lIot to violate the rule about referring to the o ha branch or of CO Congress Mr Ale f Insisted he had kept within the lb rule ruI and nd said d tout that end tooth u wail 1811 u I had d been lUlled from I lh the It committee room rio I k It not II a tact t Kr Burke of 0 Pennsylvania that Mot with while Pa In mem members of 01 the err lon conducting Ike Ir nd members or of that same commute te are the same ne cou on the tho MIn Ilea 1 1 hope bope are ant In 1 Mr I r fliNt nied by applause Hu 11 paid ut that It Ie when a let 0 ot t tea list It top In some e unfit Ut th tou or of the people It Il be behooves hooves the to got t together lohr anywhere at any Urn time 1 ul hi his Mr 1 Bunts asked It if I r Clayton waa charging that such a 11 wit belli Ming fn enacted That iii III my deliberate Judgment the wel welfare of the people of th the United state UN he Alabama II member Mr Clayton declared h he wee MOt se seIne inn Ine t to open up a school bOOl of DC ne Its said Id that It always D that e hit tog dog howled you ou talk Ik about tb the u ol of the Rep Republican phy he old II and net bring the country to f with a nac ot of what ht the et your party III fa doing to the th the Iniquity that It boa bite he heaped upon them and what It pro proposes ro poses O to do 0 you Ou let t up and howl and suggest ne of er c thie that are re wholly unethical WILT WitT Does H s HOWL I Is that the reason n th the gentleman truer Alabama I howling quelled Mr Madden Ill III wI Mr pictured Mr r Payne coming In Monday with whit u backing of nf the rules II committee and nd making makinI ready to put Ih the bill I 1 u h he added Dr 0 an II non lion will ur eta nd by the bedside Id and he h will way privately to the rank end lie dl or of hta hl party y who want I preferment n 1 a J tower we tried to take from rom him and nd I vi we laD had taken It and 1 If 1 we ha had den 10 0 w we would bee Your part I It a state II of be XI Mr I tartAn layton referred to Ih the In Iowa td idea and we Interrupted II by XI Mr XI Ken ball 1111 ol e I lewa with h th ahr that th there w was to no 1 Ides In lu lower that dId set 1 lad ladore ne This led to LO aw mulling colloquy lit hi which Mr III layten referred rd Mr II Ken Kendell dell to ator Mr III t paid III be hd had been told Uw 1 h has md tit statement that same me tariff tart bad hod robbed the II of f store moro than a hundred Bon n a H ae asked cl II 1111 to correct blip If II h Will went will wll I I hala turn the replied r Kendall o 0 Mr CIar Inn Ian t I I Ili so er M net now ow 0 that It ta Is se that hat It M tent su 10 or you U don dont know Kno Mr Kendall 1114 that waUa he heIta helid lid Ita no nn w speak Mk for he had too mush fOU fOUIn In hi his and ranee n la believe be mod tf to 10 bins b by bythe th the Alabaman Mr sisal jot that II Ih the I commuted b by the II haur an n for all U kap pet ud by in tN tM lie I II too American pee people are aN vi ut scar Y y yen under hl hl hi high protective JIt lit LUMBER Mr Townsend 0 of n thet f tree lumber lulIe would Ilk help orl orly the theas as II tf I tU Mr Mores 0 ut WIlIn i d nonce that It If permitted be would ul aa a am m f tn In hJ for tor a permanent lie of the boll IU an the of r rUc g Uc h of 01 It lie b n Ii 1 tO et who hn nest hi I heed m 1111 lulu lb the re 10 It A Pa pIN prop ten for lor th IM I wee k It by r PI tf M In XI Mr tm elId at ai tt Ill Ih Ill is it w hl hi It Pr r r rIt late It l I guy w Iona pas I not excepting those to mt meet th the exigencies ot of tl the war Mr Hamilton of Michigan pointed out that th the American mut manufacturer started out with a handicap owin to the higher Copt of II this plant am ya net tho those of th the English Tench Getman n and l That handicap therefore h he argued had bad to tobe tobe be overcome b by protection of the home pu Praising William J Brayan tor Mr haw hawIng lb Ing prior to the room dental Ih Alabama t the ant speaker at atthe th the night Ion contended that the Pa Payne bill wt to the true trub h he paid Id furnished the campaign funds tun of the Republican party rt III of t Nt New said aId there we wa little 1111 Ino Inters In the price Irk or of paper weer 1 that of nf 10 tl r ago 0 the coat ot of w Mss high ff lumber Mr DB Darts of Minnesota I Indue trial conditions today are It ferent than Iban when the DI law enacted He d declared th the importation M 0 lumber under uner the proposed reduction Uon tion would woud bel be only slightly while lie 0 Ike to th the consumer would I be lessened Ined I IFOR roll FOR TAR TARIFF I Mr Fowler 0 of Sw New Jersey in eating a permanent tariff declared It would give fIve the country tariff b evolution and d not b by lion 11 said MId that the country countr would 10 o forward hy by tae large leap and bounds If Jf cor Congress were ere to 10 declare the present tariff Ift schedule In tore force at the same me time Ume and ni edul as the boundaries within which an n expert tariff 11 commission could dx the actual schedules Iff teel t to Ih the I of the pre president That he the Ih Republican patty sustained s II relation with the n 0 11 1054 and 1 profitable that It dare dar not net give Ih the great 1 mUll mama of consumer relief from the bUl burdens e Imp Imposed d upon them b bUna by Murg Una tariff tarl law was asserted b by Mr Mo Attacking the th placing of dull on t lea c coffee spice o 0 omens m mens loves 0 ladle stocking and boots bool and 1505 OM Mr Rucker deplored the tact fact that tut the lax on beer er had not been Increased the glove hO and leather 1 Mr MI Clinton led Ond rha charged that teat th the Payne Pan bill Imp Impe ee high In Ib favor or of some om eastern tm interest that do not n need It and aM gives to those Interests an undue advantage I Ip trade I will not vote ot for bill be mid I will lacrosse the living PI PIot ot of the th laboring K moon men and tit the salaried men try by ng co coffee ft tea lea pl and 1 that retains the many pr prohibitive dull dullos now I fa force forc under th the present law Mr Hughes N J argued tar the of American lumber which he M said aid have bave dim dill against t The Tae laboring people know that Iha you are ant free e I trade rde In auld eel Mr Hughes They know their only chance 10 and lid regulate the Pence rc necessarily following situation cam aa only lee made by thorough pod 4 otle You Tou have dented them than the rl right kt to te wit with sack other through theIr organs to that t might favor tho those wac honestly do sired aired to Riv them a share ot of that pro which and nd to d dl unfair en who upon for them themselves selves all the advanced 4 ed pricer which your our enables tha them to 10 corn co |
