| Show HOUSE RESENTS PRESIDENTS WORDS Committee That Message Be Ba Laid on the Table LANGUAGE NOT JUSTIFIED Without Basis of ConstitutIng Ing a of the liege of the House III lIiM t at Will lIl 10 rt Con Iu Jan Jail given to t the president furS fur they view the secret leeret service COli In hi message tU to the bOu hOUe ot of rep last Monda the special com committee mitt appointed to deal deala a Ith the subJect today brought in IL Its final I report port AccompanyIng It es t I lution whIch declared It to be the tue ten o otho ut tho hou house that It shall halt to 10 cOmm COli eider aldr any communication from an fly source which L 4 not r mending that the objectionable portion of the president be laid un on the table and that similar ac action action tion be taken with r respect to the me cage ot of last Monday because ot of I its I be being loe ing unresponsive to the Inquiry ot of th Iii Iou 5 to what the th pl ho he said Mid referrIng to the LIon hop placed upon the o of operations of th lie secret that the thief argument In or of the was that the dId not 1101 themselves wish to 10 h ic hen Perkins of New Yon Yota Yono o of the tho special committee ar Me to milk his report he be faced aced all aim almost almot full while the galleries wet were with Ith Interested spectators th the and diplomatic usually were re tilled Their occupants some Bome ot of whom wets wen to sit I t In the aIsles displayed the keenest In the p o oIt It was not observed that any member of 01 the 1 Immediate was present The onte corrIdor were densely cowd the doorway we Wore jammed and lung lines linea of oC people waited for tor RII am to git t even een a view 1110 t chamber amber Mu Tawney Tawne ot of lows low Shet by and were ere on the floor prepared by word ot of mout mouth h to La resent n t what they deemed to be the ot of the president upOn theta Ulel II a of oC the committee on They were wen not t alo III ii their thIr indignation Indeed for Cor ao some sometime ne time PUt peat the feeling ot of the members had been growIng more and more Is ID te tense and nd scum e ot of them have haV bPI been giving wy way to their tn In lall is gongs guage which fun fully d to their wounded 1 tR Mr add addressed the hruse houle as rollo fellows To your committee were referred reterre certain I contained In the an meal nual Ire ot of the preel We WIN were to decide whether In our opinion thee portions ot of th were couched in III such auch toxin torm that II a regard for tor the dignity ot of a great legle bud body should Mould forbid their te Ie We are ant ot of the 1110 opinion that some portions ot of the th message du do eels a ot of the Jirl It r f fhi hi hOIl house and that tbt time the precedent set I iii simile cases Ih limp huu house should decline to th LU the ot of thi th with reference to th use or th the I mci Dlen this h has Ing ilIg to do We e rull fully recognize tIme rIgi rhtH ut of th tb to 10 hi his dies ot of adopted by tho thoI I un to ut ul II Its tid to ask that they IN h I The Th question t III I lie ion Wed by loUI rd nd taken as aa ilia sony 10 to lu be b n the l publIc Uc III interest But Your you b has to the critIcism mud by the ul upon on the motIves r 1 onre oi II Its III si lion lat last loll and to consider hi suggestIons a as to future and to report pOrt whether Cons with proper san OlIn conceive then them It I Is stated Irl iii the ID that till the chief argument In favor ot of the waa wa that tile tim congressmen did not them themselves selves Iv a wish to be investigated by so se met 1 service men mend thu la is repeated In iii the tho annual message It If this was wag time chief blet argument It must mut have av been by title argument that tb the maJority or of the were led Id to vote in favor tavor or of tb the funding Your O commit committee tile tee Is III unable to Lx Iba share In hi this belief In III Inthe Ih the argument ot of th the bout lUll tM lIsa g gentie tI II from In favor r rot ot of the tite amendment asked aked If It wa tim III tended that It a ot of COlIC was guity of conduct the department meat would he In III h lii hi hIs by secret cret r rAnd ii men And the from New NewYork NewYork York oP Oel that we all n kilo hymn d lawyers that we were re not federal that W we wire component ot of the tb there was wa n one I over WI urn Therm the gentleman from Kentucky said the h vIews ot of tit the gon n tIman from New York Tork the private conduct of a member ot of Co be hail l once been n b by secret sort ce men Inn but the from Me New NewYork York Tork denied even thie on one and Ad solItary lItI sad stated the IA III the case cited had bad not aol been mad b by byS S member ot of the secret ret service IeN kt b by bya a police officer of at W Washington We do not thInk that even ven the he mo mosS of conar could hays wen bean induced b by th the arguments 10 Ii vet vot III favor avor ot of th the tre fear tiit 1 It hu hi hd IJU the t tn sen n Ic ItS mIght t ut hi his secret ship shipir t Nul ir does tf it II that lii III 11 0 I IL newspaper I IList 1 List 11 r are ano loll evIdence ot of I lot 11 I which bib bibI tb I li i li t 1 tOS loll hi 1114 TI pt Ui III I ib pera si 1 I i C ii I at t t the Whit Huu 11 0 lh Ut e In sic that tiu hh r I In III Savor favor of lOr lIst It ui list the ee Q awn did nut tim Ih 1 s irish to lie lu lii inn 1 I t ue ow I it I that hal 11 r I fur tur u the iIi lilli I 1 I Any a I Ia t l tie be deter lIi by bJ t V hi his II I i I 1 t k ls 11 oth 1 Iii IiiI 5 1 I by Nil to I hub r l lit the I las It ir t 1 I til I vU aS ib h I 1 HOUSE RESENTS PRESIDENTS WORDS c from page All our that a majority of f lady w In tear that their arts ad might be 11 1 gated and nd 1 discovered the respect ot of tb the p opt which It Ie I Important Import ft ant tor the republic that Congress hould possess would be Impaired It not destroyed If I It I Is to 10 the republic It that thata a III large ra portion of our flur people should have their shaken In III the jU who interpret Ih the tart la equally dangerous that Ihal their should I hr hI Impaired In those thOM who enact enatt the Ibe I VII anit It ii to III for this that thaI tho duty upon the law not nI to allow the integrity ot of their mo me Ivet to b be IhU We may be sure that no legislative body will be respected II by Ute the un unIt unless It th It ate We Ve are r jealous vf of the honor of nf the nation we should hu he equally jealous ot of the honor hollor ot of our In UNFIT In the are re time round found unlit unfit an and hont met hut but I bailey that with few rew t the h body I U com composed ot of men mell of Ill city who vote Ole I Ii not by bS fear far of It the pollee but b by an n IKArd for the pUblic service If UI the Um should hould ever come colne a ma JerKy of the chosen ehr en 0 of the American people were wre so 10 unfit for fol their trust their votes vot veers N con controlled on trolled by a craven tar fear of th the deter detec lion of then urel the rr will have come evil II days and nd the failure or popular l government will hr he Th The or the hn have sent their ep I to tIll of r Ih hA for Ing III been at I the poll or by lb Ih legle 1111 I u W We do not nol VI that pop government and universal arp ft such lamentable fallu failures that Ihl dl die honest hon cowardly or unlit mn men ate eho en to continue In In this Ihl matter ire stand not nM I mr ourselves but for t three who ho ant nl u us html here The impeachment of Ih those who are choice h Is Ih the hn of th those who chose Ill Th The president mys J that thai no me hol hold Ih the dignity rat of the of f lit the In higher than h hII lie II rinse It Il would therefore lie he a thin thing to tn hp deplored as a 0 of any n un on inadvertence of sir combination 0 of we words es 11 should haul remain to hi his m which might 11 be 1 Interpreted b by th Ih p pl as 1 U the dignity 1111 anti and than by the lilt or of the ion 11 grit OF It Is III said ht In Ih the m message that rIm should he be If found I Ithe in inthe the legislative branch or of the OV ment nt and with lIh thus w ws wholly boll Rut the president adds If ff this I to not considered a be made iii hI U the I law the Ihl liar 1111 or of secret Service true In In member or of Congress inether In ether words It II Is I suggested that w we pas a law watch will the ex ea or of other hut but will prot pr tet t our lv i I II a majority or of th the stand land In favor of the tai exposure of own they would be iced to tn vote ote for Such a law Iw but bul such uch uchI t I not the case all and against It we must mut protest prot If lilt listens not lame and timidly to upon char claar character acter or of Ita It members and It Iwo hoD qty t of purpose It will deserve and It wilt certaInly revive the contempt Of the public W We feel that the In III the me menage the CIt ca gross should refuse to 10 merely marly re and mild mildly I t consider It Durin During long centuries our nul 1 kin and that a representative government might be amon among people Our revolutionary more than Ihan a ago age struggled An and bled that our government ah should be a re reI representative I government that the Ia tow Of tile the American people should be passed by the I representatives chosen by the Americas people The TM Congress or of the united today III as a result of centuries ot of struggle for tor popular government Let Lt every man who I h a umber member or of It II vote on thi Chia question In Inthe the manner mannaI which seems m to him most moal worthy of nf the traditions tradItion or of which Wt we weale art ale the hel heirs ot of the Institutions of which we II are the protectors and ot of the people ot of whom We are tile the A As was 11 the ca case when b spoke on the question before tb the holiday Mr Perkins PerkIn was Wall interrupted by Upon tile lM pt pf his remarks he submitted the committees report which after quoting from the I w wag as follow A ON this language langua to bea be bea a reflection on the Integrity or of Its Ita membership and ware aware ot of its Ita own con duty duly as to Its Ita th tho house In respectful terms called ui etO on the for any aay Information that would the I ot of U Ume the me message or assist at It In Il its duty duly to purge the house of the tho charge ot of conniption Th president In III hll hie ot of Jan 4 dented that the paragraph ot of the nit annual An nual message caste reflections on the Integrity ot of the hOIl house attributes to the house hoWle an entire failure to under understand stand my message dI that he has haa made no charge of corruption against any members of this hou house and by states that he I Iles no nn proof of corruption ot of any member ot of house holUM the O se In Its 1110 ot of DIO eo 17 11 1 correctly Inter the meaning ot of the words used una by the president in III hi his annual message or whether it II that lan language guage see 8 the president Implies will ho he judged now and In the future Ing to 10 the accepted interpretations of Ih the English language This hou house charged only with Its to Ih the people ot of the United States and u It obligation llon W to transmit to the future the tho representative Inherited from the PMt past and to preserve It its own dignity must Insist In lat nn n Its own to under understand tand the Import 1 of the presidents language W Re the language of l dent In his mw message ot of Dec 8 1408 un and without haMs baele of tOt tact and that It con constitute Ulu II a breach ot of the privileges ot of the tho house therefore be it II Tool That the ho house In the exercise ot of Its declines to consider any front any I la nut not In It its own respectful and he be heIt beIt It further I ted That the special om mitta and the committee of the tho whole house on the ot of the t e Union Unton be discharged from any ot of II so much ot of the annual mM mes mMe message sage e as aa relates to the service and I Is above hove set t forth and that Ihal the mid Id portIon ot of the be 00 d on the table and bo be It Resolved That th the of the tho sent HIlt to the hu on Jn Jai 4 1509 being Inc to the In lull or of the house bouee arId and an Invasion ol of the of this IhlA house by questioning the and aHl Intel or of members In II the exercise or of their right and tunc functions be laid on the tebie |
