Show HAWLEY OPENS IN HAYWOO n CASE CASE Expects to jo Prove Officers of W WF WF WF F M Responsible for Death of and Others DENOUNCES INNER CIRCLE CICLE To Carry Out Its Is Objects Ho ik De Dc Declared Declared dared Blood Was Traded in and Assassins Hired and Paid Orchard to 1 do Go o on in In Stand l f O Ite He Hencil If tins 1111 hc BoLe Boise Ila 1 Juito Juie 1 William D I Hay vod accused of af tin tt murder lur r of or Frank SI lias hal ha MIX tie tic clabor tion of oC the charge chUI and the 11 has ha ha taken the stand to Ic testimony against 1 hl him n James A Hawley made the he 4 statement this morning and UK Is burden bilden was that an l of ot the Federa Federation tion 1101 of ot Miners planned unit procured procure the murder murdel of at iranI us as 15 one of ot the th steps In o u con conspiracy that thaI embraced many nta murders The statement nt consumed one ole hour hal and ando 20 0 o minutes ond anO wua was delivered to ta a 1 crowded courtroom without attempt a at lt oratorical effort It 1 mot lot si IL tire lire lc o a of ob objection objectIon from Cram the defense first against u the thc assertion o oC Mr h lawle that the th lenders of ot the Western Federation of o of or Miners W tva responsible for scores ln und and the tho th next against the thc charge that the he great Krent conspiracy ex extended extended tended back to 10 the Infancy of the fed tell federation Then there thern were repeated ob objections obI on al the ground SI that arguing ho Ule case cale By agreement I WIS the I he ivaH given Riven a I ex cx exception exception I to 10 any In ny part tho the opening statement that It ft objected to 10 The The of the tho defense Ccarl I Indicated a purpose to 10 defeat the plan planor of or the state to show n a general con conj j and to ta omIt limit the case cadge us its closely as us possible to the tho Sl crime cIme cime alone I COURTROOM 1 CROWDED The rue courtroom filled fled up ur quickly this I with wih who ho came caine Call to 10 hear II al the tile opening alIenI statement of Ut the tilO prosecution and and the first fitt flat witnesses In Ii MIC Ille famous ca ease cac e Tho jury jur flied led In II ii at 30 but bUI Jude Judie Wood was II a trifle tote late In tn arriving It I was os also stated that the delay deJa was vas wal walIn In part palt pai 1 title due to tho th defendant who watt waa tue said to be bc none too tuo well wel hel Mrs was wheeled Into court In let her Invalid chair she sho 1111 vat ras handed hand dl a large bunch of oC red 01 by Mrs Stevo Adams wife of o rosea wie one or oC the men len gold f hI to 10 have hl been Involved In the alleged ell Western Fed Fad Fedoration II al oration of or Minor conspiracy hay liny Un wood was tas a I pale pal as us he ho tool 1001 Ills litt hi a j place near the long counsel table antI ant antI I Icar well after his bItt declared 1 ho he hI felt finite wel Illness of 01 at Insl ast If I night II ht Judge Wood tt i appeared on 1 tho the bench at ot MiU tu i STATEMENT I Mr his address fo fly had minutes later Intel lit lie declared 1 he Ito 11 no Intention of going Into Inlo the details Jola j of or tho the l tal 3 ca c to 10 any riY great groat extent Mr Ir hawleY ho dun clunK lo to tho the no notion lIeu tion that the jury ah after at alt all 11 is tho thu tho best bc t ton if Jf t judge jurige of o the tho effect antI and tho weight the evidence IH ti well wel as a tiny any In I evidence he declared would fully develop tIm Ihn events the tho tate state wished wl ful hd tho the jury juh to li II consider Mr l 1 r Hawley titan then briefly brielly went yent 1 tUo Iho tIm the tho tIl events preceding death of it former Gov GO hom hr ha described na as one of tho tin fore fure of or tho lImo tato of ot hold by b II I Ii told lold also 11 tId 0 of or tho the positions Mover Moyer Haywood and Pel In lii 11 the I II Western torn Federation of or Miners Ho Ito 10 aid I that Harry Barry Orchard who is 1 saId sal salto to ta have confessed t II to 10 placing pinel the bomb Into Inlo which blow Gov OU ati also a n member of Ot the Iho was wat 1110 Western Federation of If f Miners an as al AUS rack Jack who Wilt hits his never been MiS told tIle the Ih Jury that Ihal while 1 and tid Mover tire are I a lre In the Indictment IalY thrown or W exploded the Iho with having of tir tho tim bomb It t is s not nol the tho purpose u to that they were oven oen In the tho stull tat of oC Idaho at tho thu time 11 laws of or this crime Under the time of fr if tie tho crimI before tho thu Male tut however nut not as such hut fad fact are iro nl must lo ho bo l with wih tho tha an as n principals pals ho c who wh aid tild advise abet or ii assist In orlino are ala le under tinder of Idaho whether or O lIme laws nOl a tH principals p In the crime RESULT nES r OF Ol F It Is I our purpose e the limo loading Imn at attorney a t torney I for tor time Iho stab Italo went weil on oil 01 to 10 show that thai the death of or o was va tho th of ot a u conspiracy an cia ni understand understanding log ing In ott collusion between tile the leaders of ur If the thU Western Federation of 1111 and I Vo We OtI claim Unit that III the loaders rl of ff if this thiN union tie for fat tills this idid Jl It wH wIl bo ho I our to them bo be Mr Lr y then Ilon went vent welt Into 1110 the lime Ih form formation of time Uio western of at Iton rr It was ns organized In Iii 11 IMS 1 Tho Ii lie executive commute hu ho hl explained pIl I 19 s tl volt almost a I most II Comm ot 0 thi thu body 1111 hut huL a few fow mon amen 10 being In II com command mand I ad of OC Iho I Imil s of lt t i t tho Lb a big 11 or tl 1 B lie 1 said th Ih this rank timid 1111 tIle no Dt f what whaL of fr tC tho II little was 10 epi wing g cm tilt Oi these fow tov rol Then men lon of the I ht h cilin LI I it lit vo wo O will 11 show ii ho wild I Unit tIl hit of o this titis organization IUlIO not tiit only 01 I lor thin of or o html but SCOTCH scores of oC ho ito Hardly H r J Inid 1111 thao loft lel Air II ir Ally Aty At ty tUI tm t tm was wal a H on Uti hH it ii f ot wih 1 I I ii an nit objection tol which ted lell th Ihl 1111 11 of tit o ih lie to II It 0 I to 10 thorl to 10 II th thu tJ of or Ig MI Mr Dorn 1 the tho tl of If ti corll or of ther hud hll In 10 do 10 with time tho Ih calm caso nt at II bar har court roU lull cannot Lull tull at rl this lime the lime ha IH IN II I nr Ot not uld 11 hi hiJ J 11 go Wood Wood Mr MI lalo if hr ho Ito to by ly tIme tho ran 11 pun Ity of M tho I hi it I In II Ii i lit We VI tel 1 of tir lt lime ICIK a Int i ul received o a reply luIl In iii II JH irin I I hull not hot go o the tha Mr Im 11 Our object w Ini tt 1 ha n show Idioms that from ito Ihn I vury V In Iii II at It thu Ihu Western of ot M norl has han Ixl lel j B i floy 11 Iio tin 11 r Inner circle lint object of M 1 which not ml only Hily tr t tO pt ri tel ii i 0 i lie hel 1 1 I Ito ocr wet und Ull U toil con control 01 1111 of time 11 sen 1 d nC o A ti but hUI or D Ilu TU Juno tUII of ot of Ut time tho 11 country t tin the tl members member ot of the time union ulion were wee employed Time The lenders have em employed el d desperate from frol time tinie timeto to time hate 10 to do to it 1 with WI tim those who may milY have been beel selected for Or 01 one erie ole leason or another for disappearance nod and ld who have hac run counter to 11 their Interests ATTORNEYS TILT TUT Again Attorney was on Oil his hil feet objecting to 10 the sUites states address u 1 Told and denouncing It as a o I mere piece of ot rhetoric Mr Mi Durrow Darrow vehemently protested that Mr II Hawleys vein wem thrown In itt for Cur the purpose of ot prejudicing the tho jury ht It is nothing of oC the sort retorted Hawly It lt 1 Is n a 1 part of the evidence and bate based ba ca of ot this case rase The court commit wl will not permit nermit an argo argument ment saW said Judge Wood od but the at may HilY proceed with a I statement of limo tho states ease case caseI casp I r know what I 1 am about said glaring nt at 11 Mr Ir Darrow iatrow across the two counsel tables not itoh 11 look like it deviated deflated Dai row Quick us its it t I nash flash tUI I d upon his opponent and amid with wih angel aimer bristling In his hi voice 01 shouted I I dont tol ion care car what it looks like lle to you ou J am a not 1101 running this ease ac according IC cording eor to 10 your OUI Ideas thank God Gad and andI Uld I dont dout propose to stand tom for these con constant slant stant I ulc like to suggest st to tt the court said Raid Mr Ir Darrow DalTow that I have no ito 10 desire to call counsel to task I 1 object to any an suggestions to the court coull from counsel shouted Oh Ob dont be bl so particular called cled Darrow in 11 a drawl l to o the time exulted excited at attorney Ionic torney Dont Donl you U bo he b so ho particular about me retorted Haw Itaw HawI loy I I will 11 interrupt at nt any UI time little the thc Interests of ot o my lay 1 client demand it Li II said Darrow If I the attorney will wi ba bt h comm calm call for a II minute I r wont want to 10 mahi mal to except to the thi I state statement IIII ment mind and ald I T want ant to cooperate fur for in tin I trial IIII t We Vp will wi meet you Ol halfway on that said ld hawley 1011 Now Nn salt said Darrow to the court courte We e I Insist that tho the state has ha no tight right to tn make proof In trial to 10 all fl o of or time the alleged allt disorderly or at unlawful arts nels of f the Iho Western Federation Ion of ur o Min Miners Mm ln ers CIR which has butt extended nIl all ul over the western country Vu u ate arc 10 not nat trying t anyone 11 lure litre but hUI Wt V D TJ Haywood and the charge dim go IK is lint Iho t murder ot at If former furmer Gov i Thin Tho h entirE court 1011 said Wood cant tell lel the tho th prosecution will wi be IC al allowed allowed lowed tO 10 make such proof or not until the tu the time ronus m s It was wae finally agreed that thai the the whole of or the address K should be he considered as its exe to 10 by thin tho defense Mr Ii 11 hawley Hawk resuming declared that the limo Inner circle 1111 of or tho Ih I hu Western red Fell oration cration of Miners had haul traded III In blood had bad as its his needs to tub require find hud howl raised by h meat ment from time to tJ time an nn emergency fund which h large minis rca for uses and lI for 01 the re cc retention I bitt ion ot or the host heAL legal l talent to dc tic those of tie Its members who wr accused Icu ct of or crime rim AN IN INCIDENT Tho killing of Ion eon continued Hawley was tint not the Iho primary I object abject of or till the main conspiracy but was wu merely melly Ui incidental itt el i to 10 I o It II Tho The speaker titan then passed 1 to the III kill killing killIng killIng ing of ot Ho lie graphically described tho the scene at III nl wel when returning to 10 his homo home was Witt killed hilled by u it bomb Ho Ito told lold of or c th huo tool and cry 11 raised by h Iho fit it explosion the I ito suspicion directed to 10 Orchard It aiu evident at itt It once on ho Ito said lOa Id that hat something more fiord than Ihan private to wan wall aiu responsible for lime Iho kill killing ing of ot Continuing t In ning h ho traced true eti Orchards In and all l his hili mico Li lieu In III company with 1 John L r 1 Si wall shown llo I to 0 told of tf the tho in tit of ot Orchard l anti and the unsolicited tender of fir ui limo tho of Atty tt IVd l Miller of lie He hi II said that tho thu shun would show that an unsigned let lOT tor received by II 1 iii Will was written by hy A The rime then told of or the cantos ot or Orchard to 10 lames We WI a will 1111 nail this thiN to 10 tho bland he lie wont on Oil Which gentleman 1 asked Mr tir Ir par Dar Harrow Darrow row You IU may think those Iho remarks arn very VOl running 1 oh tig retorted eel II a ale hilt but they Ih tire aro out of ot place horn hero and anti If you keep lIed them Liuni up Ui you will ho III in kind kindI I merely n kod which ho ha means appealed Mr mtr 11 DarrOt to 10 Ihu time I Y referred reformed to 10 Mr Mi 11 James shouted Mr Mi A terror tenor to doors doers In Iti this western n I wan nato whose whoso Is III a it guarantee of good order I You have encountered 0 before III In defending your clients client Mr MI Harrow Darrow who mis still tot 1111 his hili feet fat evidently desirous of ot but hut Iho ilie moult told him there was vLis noth nothing ing lug before thin tho court In III Ii sit nit It down and a nut thou then directed MI Mr Hawley to in proceed TO 0 ao jO ON Mr 1111 enitI the Iho tatt would rd dill n II the Iho I itt tiland mi to nil would YO by b nil ito Iho I Orchard that such fuch u ti condition exl toil as liS m lie h had 1101 III Ioa d outlined He lie 11 hack buck lo to 1 9 to itt shams hol Iho tim run reasons pond lead leading ing IlIg up tip 10 to the nt of describing de the tue blowing up tiit of Ut the concentrator r nt lit lieI which ho ito wild ho ito would provo wan ta time the r result fit f C eon con ot or time the Ih 1111 of the Ihn nt rut Minor Whim Mr 1111 Haw I lut joy 10 was hitS of or Jf Ilium of ot a II atrain atrain train at ni ho Ito us 1111 by ld an lit from Mr MI Darrow who Argued MUlled thaI limo thu In tho thin ii In III I a had itami lint hum g to do III wi Iii tue 1110 cn vase e now hub argument Tho Iho ob Mr Ii Ir r I In a ie wont vent on Oil to It that hat I nn ho to II It provo that the tho of o en Sl ll r ill III H t I out the tho u u 1 rioters at Unit WillI time brought on him tilt the tJ 1 enmity a of tIme the Ih olivIa of or the thu est Federation of or Miners and that tha as a a R insult of oC that enmity he Ito watt was killed at the order of or the tuner circle n THEIR TRADE We Ve e will show ho you oC of If the jury jur M rl i continued tint the inner circle of the Western Federation of Miners composed ot of this defendant his hl codefendants CO gathered about them u a few rew choice spirits Murder was their limit and assassination a means of livelihood They rhe even had a II settle seals of ot wages fixing a t price for tor tb crime Among those tho Iho e who committed the crimes at nt the of or the thc Inner hitter cliche and who hmo wore paid pahl for tar them train from the time emergency fund were one Harry Orchard and one Steve Stee Adams Mama The TIe crimes climes were ver but bUI mete meie Incidents of ot the tho larger and Ime objects object of or time Hie big bl conspiracy We 0 will show how a that the In innet nor net circle of the Western estern Federation of at Miners is responsible for borne unie of or the most crimes ever Cler committed anywhere all to carry carr out the purpose and objects of ot tho the big conspiracy eon of at the hue circle Wo 11 will wilt show you ou that tha t these men inert were ulc for tor the mur murder murdel del der of Arthur Arlhur Collins at al fell u ot of Leigh Collins on the streets ot of Don Den Denver ver Id 1 Once Otic mote more Atty AUy Darrow DanaI was on Oil hut feet with an On objection that crimes In hit Colorado had nothing to do with the berg case I ag Judge Judg Wood tood overruled the nil objection tion He said ho ito would hear counsel 11 further when it came lime to l object to 10 the testimony THE THI OUTRAGE IV n I INDEPENDENCE loET DENCE DE CE Mr Mu Havley went on to euy that the tha inner circle was wis responsible tot for the blowing up tip of the Independence do de pot Itoh nt III Cripple Creek CIcek tho the blowing up of the tho Vindicator mine und and other out outrages outrages rages ra s lie Ho said that the tue th would show that Haywood any antI hits his code f hail had attempted many mall times to II assassinate Peabody Pea 10 0 Ih of fc Jo ratio In the tho way wa as mis the tha Ih mur murder murdel del der of oC was accomplished and amid a for the same fame reasons All of oC crime Mr dr Jr Hawley de tie declared were wre committed by b Orchard |