Show H Mit ASiC Q lun l n uc St At Con of 11 lr Address When Mr hil his sPeech I H general oner 1 ell ed In iii which delegates shot I a steady ot of questions lt at tile A portion ft if the Iho Which WIlch ensued follows Mr Del Edt would like to ask Mr a question I would like Uko to as ask I two of them This la tony not 1 iii terest you ou ns as much as I it will rae I If YOU ou had bothered wih with your our forest su It YOI you have In any instance round Iny any ot or partiality to people who should have gotten Into the tho reserve Is that a fair queston question 7 Mr II We have a about bou t sUpervisors Somo Qt of Al And some art hot I told you ou about u a mal inca who two bad In Inthe the tho Mr Walker Is In We Vo do trouble but I 1 sa say this that consIdering tho low the tho forest servIce Is able to pay In III my judgment we e have havo un an unusually Ino Illie lot of men And the tha number of at corn com which reached me inc last year Qt of Iny LIlly mistreatment of an kind will J bellI bear me out In that Mr thing Po Do you 01 have havethe the most trouble abolt about tensing leasing the tho to ro seIVe from men that are not In 10 cst et reserve or do you have al as much trouble from men In the forest Mr can SY say that 9 Per pr cent cont of at 11 all the tho trouble we have hav comis tram from men dear clear out or of the tho forest re ic servo Ild and 99 9 per cent ot of the agItation comes Collies from froni men who never nevel satin got in th ho forest reserve nt at al all Mr II II Poter Potter and Mr 11 Pinchot gO bak back to Washington I would ask tem to report that the tho of oC the tho state of Wyoming are aro opposed t to croatan election of forest ro re serves We passed resolutions ur ot that hind III both local and state con comi Mr Pinchot said 0 a tow Sow mu mo moment ment ments ago that the forest reserve was here to stay el I aware ot of the tho tact fact that there thero were nn any rules or regulatIons created In the tho city of Wash Vash that cant be changed b by the tho Loud cheers arId applause I want to sn say further that there thero noel newer wu was a president since the days das of at Washington that was genter greater than the tho people who created him Applause There Thero Is not n a man present who does not remember th dark clays of at tho th Wi Wit Witson son Ind and bil when whon it t was 1 lit tul full force torce We were told by men In qt f fco lice that the tho Wison Wilson and German bill nail free treo trade act were hero to sta stay but that Is n a thing that has passed tWI away and the men who created It have havo passe passed out ot of ImbUe life Au 1 Il I hlo two replies to make In the first place I as asto to Mr tr queston question so tnt fur nS as asI I am aware no one In this Iu huts s seer aver eer and 10 no man wi will evOr eor controvert tho statement hohas ho has made mad madI madeI I tolt took great care to say and I repeat I it that I am hero here simply a the sort ant of the people That the tho mulo make the laws you 11 all klow know I It Is not necessary sar sary to dwell on that but I repeat that taking the or of the tho United States It at large there is no queston question whatever but that the support ot of the rarest forest re reserve reserve serve poley policy Is agreed to year oar by br year I make mako that statement with no cation whatever That there thero Is dissat dissatisfaction In cortin places I knO know That it II can be removed In certain places al and not In iii others I But Dut the fact without qualification caton In InI I may mind that we have havo gOt tile tho reserves and tile the people ot of the United States be beIng beilIg Ing ilIg ul all of the people of at the United States las east and vest elt who make the laWf lawIt behind that policy olcy Ild I have thin tho authority ot of the prest president dent dent Of at tile tho United States for tor that for Mr Sullivans argument nolt I Mr Gaines wIsh to ask Is on the tho same Bame Ino line that lr Mr Johnson or of has asked Mr Johnson ns as I understand ills hIs queston question Is this I If there thero are aro A D B Ild and C of at Idaho who wilo Ir ar homesteaders und and ono one has haa OO and ant one head hend ot of sheep It any aie one van cnn como come In there or will In there thero and offer to buy up theIr sheep and nna Is willing to po pay more than what Is considered their valuation that Inn man wi sell Their object In buying those sheep from that Is to close him out that they ther In may have access to the tho range Ind and I it wi will follow up p to ever every smal small man maim that there II Is on the range Nol Now then thon the queston question Is here Is tue tho forest service going to bind every other man that had nothing to do wih that hat dent deal to them Supposing there WUI was lt af sheep 01 on 1 a range ted to go co there Among that lumber number 50 o were lold sold to another man In tat that neighborhood who desires to go on the tho tango and place sheep there Would the they bo be given preference over anybody else who lIed had nn an application Would they be turned down or would that man be It if he wanted to got Kot In that business again The Tho reason I uk ask the Is this titis I If such Is tho CINO every overy nere of at land In the tho state ot of Idaho timId and every other state wi will ho bo In the of corporations and the tho people who Iva live adjacent to them wi will be serfs und and lu in lip Ap Mr reply t r would say that tills this queston question beIng brought up now Is ono one of oC which It II In to tomako tomake make mako any set rule rUlo There Thoro Ire are 10 so many mamy varyIng c conditIons different Wayn tays In which stock arrive pr if time the country to quie nn en extent WC Wa lust must range privileges on the tho merla merits ot of each Individual case nc ac according cording to th the 11 lii that section ot 01 the country with which we Iwo ara dealing but we two tr try to follow out certain principles But in granting privileges wo we give glo orenco to the cIa class sa A w who Is 10 IlO tIto small man maim I It tile tho 10 re servo Is stocked to the tho limit which Is known as the Iho cia A limit that mint mor a certain number ot sheep shoop or cattle wi wilt be b ent coil ted tied to n a renown I As the tho country up nod It becomes necessary to take tOW men Into the tho to re Iero these new meU Wi wilt bo be taken In Innot innot not lt at tile Iho ot of tIm tho class A men hut but of at the larger arger I It must he h that tue tho natural evolution ot of the tho tilI wi wilt bo be IR 15 the tho country settles up that the Ilg big outfit man wl have to 10 give gho way to the tho hona H settler tor We try to pro oct the man who has rang rights by giving him so HO til far faras R as Wo We a right to transfer that tl in eUlo case hI lie hal has goad reason to 10 leave the country n a man is compelled to lelo leave n a certain of oc the tho coun country country try on ot o tile tho O of hil his family und and there thero is Ie n a probe ton tion II Ill that WilY that ho must be We 0 try to lold avoid In avery reasonable wily I a ot of Ilin ho range Wo We alO are In Instances to 10 to ro strict the tho number of nt new OIl to 10 go Into a reserve tar tor bite tho thim It if w we allow ni all the tho now new mon nien who VItO wish to 10 SP go It tic ho to too n a CI cute jog down lt cit the Iho largo large 1 men un WI e tout tool the they to be con nd I It would 10 u o tn Ism NIt cut down holdIngs and for tor that thatTO TO reason On bel ber ot of now new mel al allowed to go Ino I 0 range Hut flut lS as to haying down an any set rule rulo to apply to cases I it Is a mot mOat motter ter ot of tl to tile the rIghts of at the of the cases Is an they are arc presented |