Show AMENDMENT DEFEATED i lA 1 With Proposed Shantung Change Out of Way jOnly iOnly Only Three Three Remain 1 Ito to Be A Acted ted Upon WASHINGTON WASHINGTON Oct 17 W vv The long debated Shantung amendment to the peace treat treaty p presented by Senator Lodge and approved by the foreign relations committee finally was rejected In the senate ate late yesterday with a majority of an even score against ItIn It H. In to the vote of 35 to 65 fourteen Republicans Re- Re pU publicans Beans Beans- swung over to the fo forces es while unite three Democrats lined up with those supporting the proposal Of the six senators absent two Republica ca cabs s were vere put on record as In favor or of the he amendment an and one Republican an and three Democrats as opposing It VOTE FOR ADOPTION The The vote for adoption was Republicans Republicans Bali Ball Borah Brandegee Brandegee Brande- Brande ge gee Capper Curtis Dillingham Fall Prance rance Gronna Harding Hard Hard- ding d- d ing Johnson California Jones Washington Knox Lafollette Lodge McCormIck McLean Moses Closes New Newberry Norris Page rage Penrose Phipps Poindexter Sherman Sutherland Sutherland Sutherland Suther Suther- land Vac Wadsworth Warren and Waton Wat- Wat son on on 32 Democrats Gore Democrats Gore Reed Walsh Massachusetts Mas Mas- 3 3 Total for adoption adoption H 35 AGAINST ADOPTION Again adoption Republicans Republicans Colt Colt Cummins Hale little K Kellogg Kellogg- logg Kenyon Kenon Keyes Kees Lenroot McCumber McCumber Mc- Mc Cumber McNary Nelson Smoot Spencer sterling and 14 Democrats Ashurst Bankhead j. j Beckham Chamberlain Culberson Dial Fletcher Ga Gay Cay Gerry Harris Harrison Har liar rison Henderson Hitchcock Jones new flew Mexico Kendrick King Kins Kirby McKellar Myers Nugent Overman Owen Phelan Pittman Pomerene Ransdell Robinson Sheppard Shields Simmons Smith Arizona Smith Geor Georgia a Smith Maryland Stanley Stanley Stanley Stan Stan- ley Swanson Thomas Trammell Underwood Underwood Underwood Un Un- derwood Walsh Montana l Williams and Wolcott Wolcott 41 Total against adoption adoption 55 The six senators absent or paired were For adoption adoption Fernald Fernald Rep Maine 1 and Elkins Rep West Virginia Against Again Idge 3 Edge adoption Edge Rep New Je Jersey Jersey ey J Johnson l tisOn Dem South Dakota Dakota Da Da- kota Jota l Dem Virginia and Smith U D Dem epi South Carolina DEBATE is SHARP The which came at the end of another six and a half halt hours of sharp debate In reality swept away six amendments instead of one each change In the treaty text having been numbered separately by the committee in its decision to strike out the word Japan and substitute the word China Chin t throughout th the sections section re re- re I to the province province of Shantung By unanimous consent however the six changes were debated and voted on as one Only three of the committees committee's forty forty- five amendments now remain to be acted on by the senate thirty-six thirty previously previously previously pre pre- having been rejected Of those remaining one relates to American representation on the reparations committee committee committee com com- and two to equalization of voting voting vot vot- ing power in the tile league of 1 nations assembly assembly as as- I RESERVATIONS LIKELY After the vote was completed Senator Senator Senator Sena Sena- tor Lodge announced that later he I would move to to- strike out entirely the sections awarding the Shantung rights to Japan Notice also was given by a a. number of Republican senators who opposed the committee amendment that they would present reservations dissenting from the Shantung award I More than twenty senators took part partIn re-lating re In the debate extended speeches being made for the amendments by Senators Johnson son of California Sherman Of Illinois Illinois Illinois Illi Illi- nois and Lafollett Lafollett- of Wisconsin all Republicans and against against It it by Senators Senators Senators Sena Sena- tors Phelan of California a Democrat and McCumber of North Dakota a HeI Republican Re Re- publican Senator Williams Dem I Mississippi l Injected ted Into the discussion discussion discus discus- sion slon a a. bitter denunciation of the attitude attitude atti attl- I tude of some Irish Americans and sharp replies were made by Senators Phelan and and G Gerry ry De Dem Rhode Island Sr I After the a a. few minutes was devoted to the formal reading of f the thelong thelong long treaty t text The general prediction prediction j tion was that a vote voto on the remaining I amendments would not be reached before before before be- be i fore the middle of ne next t week I |