Show mt GI REPLIES c CRITICS OL OF England Cannot I Dominion Scheme Schem Irish Malcontents s 's Note The Note The following arti- arti written by David Davi l Lloyd tJ G British prime minister LJ yd y George M Magazine gaz nc now now liSh d monthly in m the inter- inter li he coalition oa ion gover government Nov 13 ft It is z charged ii politics have ruined e Suppose that we had reIme red re- re d home Ime rule rue as a liberal govana gov- gov Sn ana gone back to the situa- situa 1914 when we agreed that be placed on the ook only only on condition that it ITs amended If party had been renewed on the in- in If f t th liberal party the union union- would have been tempted to toe e e new policy polley with t the e full theIr old hostility to home homeI I lEhat that hostility would have ng by tile the record of ot lur jm rig ng the later years of the th theo lir o 0 not want to go back on that JUt Ut It contains some serious not the unionist party ll ded us of the championship ch ein gave to Germany at atrol rol moment of the struggle g section of the party is even now making l inder day by day if Jr we had that protest would wouldn n he prevailing prevailing- voice of the opposition and we should Sn n further urther from an Irish seta set- set tha than a- a awe we are today H TO REPLY ed cd Mr 11 Asquith in the house PUS to tell me what he ho meant i io i home rule and he re reply re- re reply ply to my mv question 1 I do doat doe e at that was quite fair or orr of r his great parliamentary Ie Sn 11 OIL lt Is all very well for or an anC ann n C o 6 play with those terms 1 Ik in phrases I have to c t parliament parliament- parliament They can canS S arge about self Erge d mInion home rule but I Ip Ip p put all all these things into theila the f Lr bill ila the difficulty about the tIle thed Id d nav avy Do they Intend to and as it stands at present their own military and g. Otherwise their pro- pro ases to be dominion home he sense in which the phrase ted teg throughout the empire n a a form r de ep- ep POSITION ness men in Glasgow and teri going goIn to be willing to pay g the pound income me tax men in iti Belfast pay Killings Killings' Is the working man to pay 8 shillings on while the working rel reland nd pays only 6 C pence Be- Be Ireland larid is g going to be let off offa r n a the war debt that is Lm to and if you give her zAher own taxation you must ost certainty of her doing m mone one entitled to speak for fori i ira Very well we are pre- pre take ke our fair share of the obI ob- ob I Incurred by these islands' islands g we e were asked to accept a aTI an TI n with men whose trusted trusted then then It would ferent matter But if it we wo are Give us the customs ex- ex orne ome ome tax and we are to rel re- re of any kind in ren reou re- re n l ou place Great Britain in ss ble le financial position Ire Ire- jomes r Thes es a privileged country countr Wf remain maln responsible fo for for- forner Tier her herto to posterity and yet et she no t scot cot and lotON lot ON ONI ON POLICY annot annat i t cut the painter The I policy as now put forward I ave us in a terrible position point at the present moment Is ish h t ver the merits or demer- demer I I Irish policy could il party arty carry such a policy 1 I IJ methods alone alone- What could I tY A united Ireland But I Im deeply pledged against 1 11 Are because Mr Asquith minister to ii S lf against coercing g Ul- Ul m I er would now have have to seriously n I home or home rule Do po they they say say Id d not believe that in their I hey Pier have the st assur- assur t they could carry le even If it they had a ma- ma I house of commons I |