| Show I i i UTAH WINS THE FIRST SKIRMISH University Orators Victorious Ovar Novada Navada D b WASA rIs I 35 and Mi tJ ie r lt l In iii aDI a U riH flu II n The first debate ba ever in III II by the UniversIty of Utah I last at the he theater and It IL will wUI e be cited as the mOlt moat that ever v achieved ed The Th wept the University 01 o Nada and Ue they accepted their defeat Ter very tully fully Tb rim discussion wU waS without doubt on one of 01 the beit exhibitions of polemic ever Iver furnished b by students In InI git I Lake City The over whIch the ora orators tON contended was 1101 one was fruitful for such IL a contest being That territorial aba would be a benefit to the United State TIle The affirmative or of the question w wag by N 1 1 Porter Ernest Emt and Arthur of t the University of Utah Tb or orthe t tU U the negative Uv were Miss Kru Kruger er of California E B D Lyman and 1 P A both of Hmo Nevada minutes were 11 allotted to each tuh sper but th timeS all 1 had dior matter tit to present than they could dl die 1 pose 0 ur of within irit Um III ills waa laa te mOlt moat Interesting char laar character Beter acter oil tb the debate hf her sharp ha I Incisive provokIng applause and her direct a sod d 1111 and she took for tor granted that IIla her auditors had readied were YIT ry amusing The victory for the home hOlne institution W not of a dubious astute however the decision or of tM the Judges Judie wu was unanimous TIle The WIN were State Senator D O 0 Rideout of Dra Draper lr Prof m J wan of the Acha college of Logan and aid Ledyard Jalley The Ph theater w wa decorated tM U ln In festoon eves oyer time the lINe ste The rIm orchestra under Mr Willard Wellie furnished excel excellent 1 lent lIt musky anti and everyone seemed med to hi be In a cheerful mood Both Bolh bed their rooters anti and their lusty afforded much amusement The n had at ao cause to complain ot of that U of a froat a the audience was very and nd broke the r rule against the speakers of tb the speech et b when Mi U scored a point In hr her unIque and aad earnest style tyll It would be barel barely to My y which side received the greatest ap appia pia plains JUte sad tub film of the treat tNt fluent of It tb the Liy the audience was wa very gratifying hs spirit ran nan high It was wa to tile antS and not lIot with or bant and when the bat battIe tw tIe had been bieti aM won and aud the decision announced the Neva orators were b by their Uta Utah friends Oil the 1711 orators w were fair fairly ly Iy hu I The yielded to 10 the I er r and helped to swell th ti I tumult or of applause MAUI MAn nED LIE S There Theft WU was am impromptu rail rally on OJ the nit last nIght and for lor inre In It Its tIme the of Ut tInd that overwhelming en patti through the means mean ot of which th it or of the east win rank and JUIa HOWAT Judge And 1 11 acted Ill a time iii I Ih requested that no bt be Indulged In during the o I a but as has already I tb the caution autton Vo was I iii h h I precedent being ID II t tiu th Ih lady orator mad me of tit lill hl only feature of the Ihl 1111 Ir 1111 surprised elt Nevada 1 I iii h advantage of e and I It h debaters bad CO thru ihu Ih of their Dum number being I h but they are bright call oal callable obi able and reflect t on the they DR The I Ite w was opened JJr by Mr r Pot Por tr for tit tb wh said that the burden of proof did not lICIt tall talt upon the affirmative so 10 tar far as 81 the merits or of any of expansion w wu concerned md li b their con contention n was u as to thE the sup supposition up position Is III each ease tUt hI bt being that the method of acquiring the territory In l question wu was Just and It would be 1 etu a of the Ita Stales to embrace within III it government Canada Central America all U fr far as aa tb the route of the Nicaragua Cuba Cu the Danish West Indies tIme the Sandwich islands andt the Ladrone I Ind Islands nd such nah PIrt of the b Philippine groups III as would be as a cots COlla mercial and naval hair ball in III the tle of commoner lie pointed out what hat he thought ht be Inestimable to the United Statis StatI which would accrue from the pursuance of 01 the tie expansion policy It 1 protect and II its corn everywhere cad h have a 1 effect upon our national our f uund our ur social life The Th ann annexation tt n at o would wipe out th the last at vestige of nf Eurn and would ind the tIft t ver boundaries and The retention n nt of t the would result In lb the of our m merchant hA t marine which II rapidly decaying and nd the tim American would be able bie to gee et into the end nd establish a p pies tip tige much higher than It Is now DOW Mr Por Porter r WU was clear clar and pointed In hi speech It at the fn or of which a thunderous trou applause arose aro from tb the audience TUB TIlE NI SlOB Mr Lyman Iyman opened the for tor forthe the negative and ancS stated lilted that im h pro proP proposed posed P to sow that tUt would be and morally that In holdIng the Philippines the American laborer was lal Holn being to tn the greatest pea ethic menace n Hit I that neat the retentIon of tile the Philippines could never hi be ot of commercial raise 1 to the United States III as to tn compensate for the loss ot o lite lit that has baa resulted over there The pu purchase of the n toni tory 1111 and I the h of 01 I wit hot a good HM Point at 4 that was wal con anti and people of tb the it II That But u the IOU unites ava away by br byI i Ii I miX Ovid be of n flu possible W Mr dr the second speaker on tim Ih affirmative that the tbt United States should own on th the In lla ilia Island because of their I CHI and lIe lIet t out the value Alue ot of the Nicaragua sad nel stated ted that It would Jt be to tM the hemisphere what time Suez gana Is 11 to th the Tile United could not afford to a mat matter ter ot of such vital Ital financial In the hUa of anyone but herself lie He out outlined lined time the that would result to the wt Western rn farmer It if expansion ob tainted It would open up a market markt for tor them and task make ot of Sail Bats the theN N New York ot of th the West Welt Ut the London Lundon ot of tM tim The westerners above all cli null mell hould be TUB TIlE LADY IAD ORATOR hiss Kruger sharp ant and sive but took many thin things for granted SIre She rented the t from the army aMny point She styled the policy lit of expansion as a the very of Democracy boasts UI that l she has baa her traders In every tery countrY under the un sun but ab alas doe nt have han to expand to get t them there theM The Monroe doctrine wu was cited In to the argument of another country time tIle Nicaragua canal That document hId had been shown to Europe on several II allon and can be shown again when necessary Ml Kruger plAted elated that Ibal In a con conversa conversation tion she he had with Congressman N New land and Nevada of that gentleman paid lAId that when the news of Deweys victory victor Wa Washington be called OR on the President and at that time he was wasaji U III aji much opposed oPP to tb the retention ot of the Philippines a as w was MI Miss In she elt said that If she Ihl wel a Filipino as she be I is An Amert AmerIcan an she ahe would never lay down her lIr arm II aa long am au an American soldier was waa on FIlipino soil 1011 never neve never neverA A I S The side wu was concluded by br Mr whOle whoa effort efort was a moat skilful one he w was a perfect treasure IoU of lie sahi that expansion was AI not Dot Imperialism is II a monarch In name o only lr nevertheless she he hu has fur for hOn han hOndred tired dred ot of yrs years She Rile Is the mother ot of parliament and the greatest civilizing force In time earth Jt It would never be possible for poll to lean this nation Itra th the people would not permit and the gracious freedom enjoyed II by the tit dill I HUS ens or of the Untied Stats Staten would tIme the flag wherever It g gA goes A Mr Ir l concluded for the nero neg alive athe In IL a spirited l and appealed to the American people to desist from froma K a policy that would turn down don all al our tradition and menace the perpetuity or of title pmt country whose mission million is II isto to shed hell enlIghtenment and peace not notto to tl wars wan of oC II lie that tIme tilt WN were Inimical to the white man and their possession b by bythe the United States State would mn mean arm n Influx ot of Into this country which would reduce the we wages of the to cents per IIA day TION Miss II and Mr Ir Porter r had bad badten ten minutes In which to summarize the arguments advanced b by their tive sides The points on ocr which UI the de debate debate bate wu was decided were orator oratory famili amity with tile the subject Abject and tion After conferring rOt fot a few main ut the judge returned a unanimous tor br tb the affirmative which was sas wast greeted t with tremendous cheers and applause |
