Show i r ARNICK SEATED AFTER ArTER A HOT HOTi i DEBATE Charles 8 L. L Warnick the representative of or tah county in the tho lower Jower house of oC tho tah legislature will III retain his l' l seat ed in hat at bod body Tho motion to unseat Mr Ir wo was defeated In to the lower Jower house st night following tho warmest ora ora- contest of oC the session Tho The vote voto on contest taken at clock dock List last night was marked b by three en n breaking away awaS' from rom tho the ranks with they I havo bovo eve been allied Charles R R. voted with vUth tho the Progressives antIE and antI E to un unseat eat W J J. Tort Ton Itch of or Carbon county count and antI T. T T W W. Pe- Pe Person Person erson broke fron tho the rank ranks of oC tho the Pro- Pro and Democrats Democrat and voted to eat at at Warnick With Ith these exceptions tho voted to scat Mr Ir nd rid the Progressives and Democrats to unseat him Mr Ir Mabey denned defined his hla attitude b by do- do laring that tho the question had been sub sub- to Attorney General A. A R. R Barnes or a constitutional interpretation and andt at t the opinion had been adverse to tr fr Warnick Furthermore Mr Mabey he had conferred with numer- numer us attorneys and h ho he ha had yet et to find n attorney who believed lIe that Warnick r qualified under tho the constitution Op pinions Against Warnick Three opinions each adverse to Mr I s rl right ht to hold his seat were The loiters letters were ere from rom D. D O. O Villey E. E C C. Ashton and Ben L. L Rich Ur fr Rich is the county chairman of or the X party part In Salt Lako Lake count county I The Thc entire fight waged on the mean mean- l tg of or the tho Constitution Those Thole voting Mr tr defended their nc- nc lion Ion b by declaring that th the constitution Outlined that a 8 man should bo a n. re rest rest- lent l- l sent Jent ent of or Utah three years ears before servIn ur nA In tho the le legislature Thc They declared hat this meant three years Immediate Immediate- y prior r to action Those voting to seat Mr de- de ended their action with the contention hat Utah county was entitled to its till nil representation In the lower house he rho vote ote to seat BeAt Mr lr came at nt athe athe he close of ot a discussion on tho the floor Ir if f tho the house which lasted two hours and Inc me Geor Georgo o F. F Goodwin ar argued against Mr Ir being permitted d to take t. his sealie seat seal I ie le humorously branded those favoring f his I to hold his scat seat as who ho had no regard for tor the con- con of or the state Wh when n It Interfered Ith personal alms aims New Party Mr Goodwin proposed d that these be betided tided prided together i In a a. now new political part party le Ie e proposed a platform for this party part ruder inder the title What Is IB tho the ution Among Amon Friends Intends Wilford Day championed tho the cause of oC I and argued that Utah county coun- coun y ty was entitled to its full ull Jon ion in the lower Jower house He d declared that thatto to 18 was waG entitled to his own lon Jon of ot the C constitution despite the one onu of Attorney General Barnes Barrios and l I D. D H. H Morris declared that the I sen- sen n- n expressed ed by Mr Ir Da Day that beas he be heRas as vas entitled to his own interpretation vas as ae that held by every ery common horse i J. J Alex Bevan Sevan declared that If It the thele le were going going to disregard the tho Constitution they ha had better do away frith It Do away with your tion or else live e up to it argued t the Socialist member of or the house hous' J. J Louis Loula Brown declared that it was no less anarchy for tor good men to disregard disregard dis dis- regard the provisions pro of the constitution constitution constitution tion than it was for tor bad rod men Others who ho talked against Mr Ir Warnick taking his scat seat were C C. C R. R Mabey Samuel Old Old- ham T. T W. W Peterson and Dan B. B Shields Shield Tho Those e who talked In favor of or Mr Ir Warnick Warnick Warnick War- War nick r retaining his seat Scat were J J. J W. W Van Yan Wagoner Thomas Sc Sevy A. A A A. Hinckley anti ami O O. F. F McShan McShane J i |