| Show BILL PASSES THE HOUSE After a Lengthy and Discussion i it Went to the Senate by bynn byan nn an Overwhelming HI HH H H I f X O 6 the McMillan lc X Xi C Cbill Jy tl the majority of 1 voile to llan bill i passed the lower huU house ot of the tho yesterday afternoon and will hU have fl as generous 1 a margin In tl the Senate this afternoon liens I is Ih the bi bill k as I it reads att after Ime which were made In II Its 1 It shall hal tm unlawful far tor fn any bean 11 of health board nl J Jot public board acting In State Slat under ot of education or SI other police regulatIons or otherl otherwise to by resolution order or of oC an any kind the vaccination of oC alY any child or person of oC oft t In nv age p or making vaccination ton a a condition to the attend ten 1 aries of an any public or private In the State ot of Utah either as r or tc teacher r rt t J 1 hn In the Iular COUr course the MC MCMillan IC Mian Millan bi WI reached ach 1 under the hAI heft or lt unfinished business there Wf was I a huh bUS bUSin In the House Members leaned back k II I ther their chira to await Awalt the shirt while the crowd 11 man InAn among thIckly lined lne the visitors fler gallery tp Iii toed loed or clane their necks the bette on the BOl an tt keep Oi tl inisi nothing that wal was an going on ThIl J Oll GUN GUNThe GUNThe The first I to claim Its privilege riI ot of the tb floor WI was Mr Ir Van an ot of Sl Salt Lake Lak LakI LakeIt I It Is oCen often ar argued e lul he th vaccInation deprives l lle lb at ot of his lIberty Nation Nationally aly ally this ma may 11 be rl right h but In must sub aub submerge merge their rights In the ti sveal L 1 ant am of an Ie age to for Cor myself or I be hut but n no has ha the nigh to tn th the health ot of hi his child 10 tt I believe Illee that however Is in time 1 parental heart there I that thal the I is it louche toUcheS the heart or of every citizen The of oC the he IRI JudicIal opinion fraternity ot of the worle Is that eser 1 should b be loathsome dl l the fore UI us II is the tue of oC Ihal children J 1 for tor on ono il l anti faithfully the passage af ol this bill Do YOU 01 bele believe In compulsory or atlon aIkin naked Mr Ir Yes Yell I do answered Van Horne home homeI I believe II in eer every person or Oh orold old beIng unless thero P Is physical reason why h he not J FA FAVORED IT Mr Hewlett declared himself In favol of th the 11 bIll He II cited the case l of it a youn woman In Iii hll his ward who had hod Ht said she would badly from Crom smallpox yet rather have I it a tunes than bo bc UTAh COU COUNTY Tl Mr Hore homer of oC Utah county sold ld that It seemed to him that this Wi I a qU ques oC ci lion which as the whole Utah Uth county When hen I went down to Iro Prove on tin end encl of last week saul lie he I it seme seemed that every one me ins to 10 to ins ole an re to ote tar tor the bi bill Thil Is ii IsIt that It a ot of thin the inertIA ot of atlon hut bUI ole otie of oC compulsory V tion J I vaccinatIon Is good god and famIly has been n vaccinated but as am asIt amit 1 CamlY It is II the demand ot of lY my I Iwi IvIll wi vIll vote yolo for tor the hi lull J EXPERIENCE Mr r Evans or of Utah county said I IWi IWas of oC the thim Was or of leht Iehl and Wi board of oC health vite 11 at atIs its worst in our el city Nineteen Is tine were 11 up lt at one time mind the leopie the chols hut but under medical advice the At title time we re Ee open wire kept nn an onier from the tl boN boNot board ot Lf health to 10 close thu to lO oi alt un rO children sa 3 that he be the wu vas never intended to this way Why W we ch h not nol A also loRI close the Sunday I 0 meetings and so forth I shah vote Cor or the ot of the c llan hit lull BOTh HOTH ALUm Mr r or of that In mOl ot of the haul hACI been adults lie a letter from the lie minong 1 of that sayIng In that Ilal email and un Unvaccinated nix had stricken the vaccinated alike that the hl huid had hadnot been continuallY but the they not been able to 10 trac trace one une single case caseto to o the children Wh should WP we close the tho schools antI Iole riot not other Ither gatherings Do children prud the wore than grown lie Ilna b by stating that he II 1 le to vaccination but buthe was not he 11 ll In our locality ha have suffered II ma touch much from I It 01 as smallpox ONIX ONE ONI Mr lr ot of loll saId there Wil was one phase ot of the que question ton that Oi considered and that had been be alli cuhl le before lie house b by Mr lr Evans l I must do lie bidding or of I my he concluded ot of Cache said Mr Ir Ild We a as Q a bo body wi will take make no mIstake when we vote for the ot of tIme Mc bi bill SIAH IN OPPOSITION Mr r tharl or of Carbon Carbon lall ald that pr per constituents were fre against cent ent oC hil his the he passage o ot of the hi bill le lie belIeved that guard agaInst contagion lon alters he children could not TI S Mr Ir of oC I Rinse mer Ild salt I doubt douht whether or lot not tf Is Q a Io good thin blog In our county It I ha hits proved sores than hiatt No NC loan or body of WUI f toen ha have the rl right hl to say MY lint I Ihal hal len make I my and healthy 4 tren n lck Th Three of them had haIJ to lo take taketo takeo to o bd bed as a result ot of vaccInatIon and I Ikno Inow kno now Ill of oC other three cases here it II Is doubtful If IC the wi with yen fr recover roer lbs ot of the Ion on or of tile the Is agaInst vaccInation mud and I nent resent ll the ties that the 0 his State are Bre governed b by fanaticIsm A I round of applause greeted this out burt first which quIckly hushed l by hi speakers akers eael gavel Hy ALNE ALONE Mr lr h ehly of oC Millard remarked that a arest rest wen been said Oi on the subject and that the bl bill would II iOS b by 11 an majority n a young oun nan hp he considered that he hall hail no 80 rIght mal In n lila limited experience to lO judge I ni to tolie tb lie or of le lie believed h 1 the o of evidence wal II mm favor ot of the physicians and that thai al albough bough he hd nut not ln been vaccinated vaccination WI was tue proper to out smallpox But I if we lold lOsel t the hl schools III the there verO ml man meeting pla places which wr tere ion on Just a as bd bad for tor onta conta mun s rIm rIlE DOCTORS Mr Ir Andersen 0 of wb si said that he hew w ass In receipt of at mal many leten letters and peti ions against compulsory vaccInatIon We Ae IU are net h hire to our 01 own lewi 1 So a as th of at the I people pl ye represent Ther There has hal le been Mm some w on the Gus part ot of tM the ph hr who I think hink hT have oe abt about mater natters In 1 a wrong way TheN Thero are a for tor In tb be eta Ia 1 utIS lIes such A as getting rl rid ot of the filth In been vur CWI have hae ignored ThIs vaccination without an and hygienic efforts reminds remind me of Putting scent 01 on dIrty cloth The scent Int I Ii all Al but It would b kIter ler on clean clothes I It we IIII thle thil bi bill Inor more who have ben been against vaccInation wi Will J bt than themi would hav have other othor otherwise wise I The Crelor freedom of an I Is such that he wil will not nol do a 1 thing unless of oC his hll own tr tree choice VA Mr Weil of af Salt Lake JAke said ll his he war R aroll among tho thetis who had bad to the hue ercal of vaccination against smallpox but II as we p are living und tinder b by consent It wal was nee or sary for us to 10 surender surrender some lome of out our rights lie He was to thu of oC power wh ben beer perpetuated on the Iho people of oC Utah It Il not ben been list previous had to IRWI laws vaccInation It I might Ight have boll been taker taken for that the State boro board oC 01 health had not overstepped Is its rights lUBIC Mr Ir Van or said that I It wall nut not 1 a question of oC the lion hon honet et eat of oC the medIcal men but bUl a matter aier of infringing on rights DP DENOUNCED TIm TIlE HILL Mr r Stuart r f Mn Rl lithe Ike saId ld S e 1 a country lember member nu 01 halt dolt Lake county count countI I would Ik like to lo Ilk Mr Ir ot of Irol county why It Is that he presents a petition from Crom people living II In Olt Jordan and If IC lie he Is acquainted wih with en one of the signers Mr Ir Mo Io Ild said he knew none of oC this the pl but hail presented the because It ha had been glen given him for that purpose e Mr Ir Stuart said that out ot of 30 odd vaccinations lie he hul had head heard ot of no el evil effects 11 lie denounced t the he lc bi bill al as class legislation DINT LIKE CO COMPULSION lUSION Mr Ir McGregor sal said he believed that VaccinatIon made Immune to lo smallpox mal x but dl did not In mik tank tankIng Ing It compulsory QUARANTINE TIlE m REMEDY Mr Maughan of Cache sullin said In answer to Stuarts Stuarts statement about vaccinatIon In Sandy that it II wal Wati nut that had stamped out the dl disease lie In hits his count CALIS IT RIDICULOUS Mr Ir Smith him whether lie ho the opening of oC the schools tu to unvaccinated ehl chIldren ren a a regulation Mr Ir replIed that he did All 1 right I cant talk to you OU Mil said Smith le lie continued I was In hopes that I could keep out ot of this discussion but I It to o me that th the statement by two members on Ihl the floor opening the schools school I is hI a quarantIne measure I Is Isto to ridiculous that I feel teel bound to u ex myself on the subject subJect To open the Ichols schools to u lit Is not nol n a quarantine regula regulation lon and nev neven Ir en can bl be I It hastens spread of Js ease Be Besides you ou people who Ire are no eating this 11 bIll are only cutting or off your own noses I It Is not Rn an lor sony vaccinatIon bil bill Let smallpox b be come epIdemic and both bolh vaccinated and un children will have to stay atay away from rom the schools courts and all places plACe or of publIc In inge will vilI be closed It I Is true that If IC we can seclude ever every man mall In his own houN we may mar break up UI th the but bUl to 10 allow them to go 10 at large and It Is III crimInal The gentleman from I mers talk lalk about rather having smallpox than beinG vaccinated la is rIdiculous lie He naked Mr r If IC IChI its hI haul had ever seen it a ease ot of confluent smallpox harmon replied that list he hall hail seen caste case ot of what physicIans called smallpox BOLD DOID QUESTION Mr broke In with the liMe We got ot any smallpox In Utah Ulah Mr Ir Smith sold he was hut ready to pillS pass on that questIon lie then thell stated that the government had thrown troops who were fluted Into contact natives In Iii South Africa and that while the nn an tives had suffered from Crom the disease not nota n a single case had butt been beon known among the British troops JI lie also aleo brought up the war In favor Cavor or of the lie German troops I repeat repeal he continued lint if IC the object ot of this bill Is to keep the schools open you ou will wll find ml thai you ou will only succeed In III closIng theta DIFFERENCE IN DANGER Do you think that there is II more danger of contagion In th lie than In this Sunday schools BIlked asked Mr Ir Esne Just nt five times Ita as much Smith there are five days dall II a wk week of public school AL RIGHTS N I L Morris of Bolt Ball Lake Jake asked wh why vaccinated children should not nol carry the In Iii their clothes as well a athose tho those o Smith replied that It if the they were wre nit nil vaccinated It could make no difference an way as the they would not contract the disease Mr Morris related to show that Ihu 14 ier cent ot of vaccinated people hId had taken smallpox lie of oC the reo me I ported sufferings rota vaccination and am argued that if IC we dId not nol know III as and some othe others about Cc ac we did know chat were wert our al rights anti w we would not nol notha ha e a those thole rIghts upon It II wall unfair to talk ot of closing our schools when Wt we our theaters anti ball rooms to remain open Ofen When Morris sat lat down Smith pro all amendment to 10 lie bill that In incase case cae of oC an epidemic ot of smallpox It should be In the power por or of boards boaro of health to tn enforce such rules as mIght lie be necessary to preserve the public health This Thill an nn an amendment ot at later b by Axton were weN both bolh down IN MILD ONLY IY Mr Ir ot of Utah county was waB the next speaker lie He akl III that the disease hId had been Irn In so a form that people had not been tn serIously worked l up ul oter It H Re thought that the lIc was wasa a more perlou matter thin Ih the dl dIsease anti and the medical profession had bad fa fato falleti to 10 convince hIm that thai It was a 1 pre of the disease In m my town NIt mid he opt oit ot of 1100 see people 11 11 un an and d n 37 look the t di n I have laa b n 1 mayor ot at tilt t ci I In fl I or of the ot it health 11 Ib In a position toJ t thaw II tit lIt patti welfare I be II levi that the profession hat Mi I a hIll IItti unwise In trying to fores Coree th these e measures r rAI AI Ag TO ION Mr McFarland or of Weber tatted In Iii by asking the Ibe last lut speaker It if he Ut t any school chIld chilli who haul carried In fIction Mr Ir replied refilled In tile II tug atly Aliv and Mr replied that thai the gentleman froni Utah had ex hi his II lie mentioned the case of oC a young a neighbor of 01 who was ws vaccinated lut iset summit and hail not yet recovered froll the iii effects of oC It Ue II also spoke poke of chIldren who list become ill Il through vaccination PEOPLE IT Mr Ir Johnson ot of Utah county saId h he would vote for COl the bill because time the wore were In III favor of oC It II In Spring hIs home live five out ot of six wanted the bill and thy were er reason able atule 1 too When they lund thirty ca lii In the lie town last year schools meeting places place dance halls hall were closed and no objection had been blen made Mr r Axton of Salt Bait Lake then lilted asked the lb clerk to hits amendment to the bill It provIded list In tilt event of an epIdemic the Stats State board of oC health laws power to so 10 In cities of he first and second class clu cluI I as to vaccinated train unC unvaccinated children lie He said lAid must mOlt ot of th timbers members were In favor faor or of the bill 1 hue cause aUM they had received petitions In flUor of It II lie re recalled the petition to Congress In the n I hi H Roberta case anti sake how JIlin many t were ere In favor ot of the action Congress hind had taken MIt m IS Mr Ir WIllIams or of SAlt Lake and chairman ot of the committee on public health said he belIeved that In this Uti county 76 75 item cent nt of this the school chil children dren had already been n vaccinated Thu pu ag passage ut of the bill he said lAlli would not abrogate any authority ot of the he board or of MI CLOSES CLOSI S Mr lIr McMillan the author of oC the bill haul the privilege of closing the debate After alluding to the action ot of a 11 certain of oC Snit Salt Lake In alluding to the bIll all as cities legislation he salti lust It filS hi hit belief that all classes were wre In InCa Ca favor or of the passage of oC the bill ns as Ii ft measure ot of relief There Ther was centre versy among the tho physicians At their recent meetIng with the commIt tIM fr Cr it I ho he Legislature Dr had den dee ell ed that the disease that Wood bur haul hotl been suffering from was not lue to vaccination Dr Richards had lie H lie could not lIa say positively TItle This showed a variance ot of opinion anion among I the physIcians and the lie l said that hp he did not nol know whether he WAS in n favor of oC tion or lIot But Dut his he was certainly not In favor ot of compulsion Mr Ir Mc l nd a 1 long article b by Dr M I It Lever Lerr Leverson son In Physical Culture In which lint authority said that vaccination was wall opposed to tn common sense appealed to 10 time the superstItIous was waft n a revolting te He also allo quoted Gladstone Sir JI George W V Mallory of oC New York |
