Show r MI I VACCINATION TrON FOLLY j d When ono one meets 1 a tnt fact In opposition I to a dominant theor theory wo we mut must the tact Ind and abandon the theory end though being supported by Ireat great nales names It may be generally accepted Claude Bernard BernardIt I It may truly b be said ot of vaccination of theories that It belongs to the tho class that hI has been weighed and was found wanting Now the antiquated drug drui medication Is al all that prevents this practice from taking ls its wih with the relics ot of the dark age ages Ther There is II not n a scientific principle to uphold I It are against the anti and man many ot of the best ties ot of the present time lao have shown the tho evils ot of the filthy practice ot of lon lion Some ot of the peole people are doing their OVo own thinking n and I it Is gratifying tu to hear a member ot of the State health I board state that tIre the elect effect ot of the tho op opI to vaccination Is being felt 11 alt I over oer the State Stute and Is making the work ot of the health to per perform I ton form I Is It any wonder that this Is the case Dr H 11 I U hAll ot of district No 2 Weber Co Itah utah denounces the ot of vaccination In the flowing positive term I herewith de desire Jre to enter my solemn and emphatic protest agAInst any such In filth mth hell being injected Into tire the ot of our lo ones nt at home I 1 deny that ln olon titian Is either n a preventive or a lure ture and I challenge proof to the contray contrary I would advise m my pro friends antI and the pub le lie generally to have none ot of I it I huld myself melt ready to defend my o Of cOUre course I it wi be difficult to tet get health officers to enforce this filthy I practice when they ther Ire are of Dr Wal ad i imano mann mano opinion or hol hoki the opinions ox eX Pressed hy by 0 W harvey M D I In I Monday evenings News No on one would interfere with the work of the health I wih officers when they thoy are doing their I but when they tr try to enforce a whole wholesale I sale aie 1 poisoning ot of healthy bodies it Is the duly UI ot of the citizen to oppose thorn them EFFECT OI OF There has already been more Ins ing caused In Utah b vaccination than try by the tho pox The Th vaccinators go among the tho people and them prIvately to be but wi will not accept a chul lenge to discuss the question through the press and thus lot let tIme the lub sub submit mit to the practice with their eyes ees 11 open on such 1 a poor stans foundation that agitation Is nt not good ot for tor I it I It has already ben been to too much for tor the good ot of It its 05 confess conte M ot of the Hospital du raid aid At I denied tt ti e of the transmission lon ot of syphilis by ac but bul facts repeating thorn them themselves selves Ind and becoming more and more confirmatory I admitted with reser reserve and even een wills repugnance this mode ot of transmission Today I do not hesi hesitate tate to sa I It Is ii a tact fact A manual ot of animal vaccination by bV Dr l E WarI mont page SO 80 But Dut the vaccinator las says that is II not now because we have the pure calf calt lymph pOints Then their own friends declare that the vaccine points swarm wih with disease germs noW the he last shUt shift Is to the dis disinfected infected tubes tube Where wil will the lext shift take them I must again quote from E IL M Z M D B M I 11 C CS Ca S a prote professor or ot of pathology and bac bacteriology In ICings College London Ind and the tho most eminent original investigator ot of the tho vaccInation queston question now living he says There Thore II is no way ot of deter determining determinIng mining by the or an any kind ot of test ot of any character be bc between tween lymph which the Irus ot of syphilis and lymph that does not INNOCENT RIGHTS TO PRO PROTECTION PROTECTION In The Tho Value ot of Vaccination page 42 G cI W Winterburn Ph D 11 M fl D says Millions ot of He re made every year oar and nobodY knows what they are made with The whole pro process procesa cess cesa Is a haphazard game with chance VacCination was accepted on the dictum ot of lerner Jerner I It stamp stam out smallpox Time The medical profession of at today buys its virus Irus ot of those who Is make merchandise ot of It In their dictum that It Is the right thing to use useI It Is a preventive why did dida a I member ot of the tho State health boar board ray In the last that no be FI In It personally because e lie he Ind and his family wera veru entitled to protection does what they claim It the tho practice caIm I for tor It lie ho and his tamlY arc from the tho disease and the tho cannot en endanger anger them the ph ers lot not an equal right to protection against being poisoned VIEWS IN GERMANY GERMANi Many ot of the belt beet English authorities have lum been quoted ns as being belUK opposed to vaccination wo we shall now tur turn our at al attention to 10 German authorities Dr 1 11 tenton says Our German municipal pal records s SIS show thousands ot of cases ot of attack or death tram from smallpox even evenin in newly persons Time fhe mod modem li em drawn tram from the experiments er of A M Pasteur with an anthrax thra or fever teer loe have been proved by time the counter experiments of Dr loch Koch to be miserable Illusions Artificial In inoculation Is on one t tire the epidemic development or of disease quite another and to base the right of the State to enforce vaccination on the test a In Jenner Is to occupy 1 a position that conno cannot be maintained i Address to the Dr G 0 F ot of Munich Member ot of the Statistical commissioner ot of Bavaria and time the au author author thor of several statistical works ot of acknowledged value oue says Fm From I been trained to lok look upon the cowpox n as nn an absolute and I protective I have from my earliest remembrance believed In It I more earlest strongly than In an any clerical tenet or ecclesiastical dogma Time he numerous and acknowledge failures dId not Ot shako shake ny faith I attributed them either to the care lesne or of the tho o operator or the badness ot of the lymph In th the course ot of time vaccine compulsion time the question ot of carrie came before time the when a medical friend supple supplied tue me with a mas In ot of favorable to vaccination his opinion and ble Thin awoke the statistician within bit me On inspection I round found time figures closer were delusive delushe and a tion left lett no shadow or of doubt In my mInd lon that the statistical ar arti array ray ot of prot proof wu was a complete failure gain Again ti In the tho kingdom ot of Bavaria where no ono one for many years ear except the newly born e escaped coped vaccination there were vero In the epidemic ot of 1571 no noles les ther than cases of smallpox of 18 whom had been as Is shown b by 49 the documents In the state department Dr I II Boeing for very er man many years a prominent vaccinator at the Rhine S As I began these on In SI the belief and ald wih with the hope hop to gain a sure guaranty for tor the correctneSs s ot of the present protective thery theory ot of vaccInation nobody can reo re regret gret It more than myself that their ro re proved unfavorable to compulsory and e every ry friend ot of humanity reels feels the constraint of at be lug to resign n a prophylactic 11 oll the Inventor ot of which 1 is called yet ot today todo oM arms ot of the greatest cale benefactors or mankind and the ro real I effet of which hal has to be placed among amon Hermann Hermanas illusions Facts on the Smallpox ad and Vaccination Question Leipzig 1882 T TEAChING CINO OF EXPERIENCE I Ii It impossible that the am army ot of la In r t nJ among the mot most eminent I authorities In the world who aban abandoned the ot of vaccination and were opposed to It after becoming en enlightened lightened Ire are mistaken and our loli little about lights I who know very cr smallpox or vaccination are aro riGht 7 One might wel weil SIY say And It If the blind lead the tho blind both shall fail into the ditch Vaccination Is not the fruit ot of science nor nature and ami It Is only the credulity ot of time the people that give gives It it In general cenera and drug time the reste held at time the present time Ume Ind and both bolh wi viii tal fall together Drugs arc useful where there Is any klin killing to todo i ido do but In disease they are being rap i Idly replaced by mor more rational methods ot re The orthodox methods ot of cure are about n as rational n n the pren proven i iI t I tives ono one the other and both stand In the wa way of at tle the establishment I ot of scientific principles The e statements ot of lending authorities leAd one t to liis isis conclusion In the Element Elements ot of and hygiene by rho I II flux Icy ley LL LI DF D P n it C and W S J You Youmans mans I D page we find the tol fol r lowing Medical tr treatment thus has 11 its hygienic resources which with the I enlargement ot of rational ac are coming Into greater anti and greater prom prominence All who have watched the tho progress of time the healing art In recent I times vill note lint amon among the most I enlightened wi practitioners ther there has ha haI I ben been a stew steadily Ii diminishing confidence i In medIcation and al an Increasing rel roli upon time the sanitary influence of na I Ii i turo ture t IGNORANT FAITH IN MEDICATION I It Is notorious that In proportion to toI I peoples ignorance ot of theIr own I ald amid the true ot of I Is their credulous confidence In pis pillS I potions and absurdities and this continues there will ot of course be plent ur of doctors mho wi wi will lancer pander to I it And not the le st ot of the benefits likely to follow time the bet better et I Iter te ter diffusion ot of physiological and ani i tur lacy information wl will be the tho protection I Iton ton tion ot of the tho community from tIme the numb num numberless berless Impostures ot of charlatanism amid aud a beter better discrimination or of the thc qun quiLl ot of competent Professor John Hughes Bennet Bennett of the tho University ot of says say In Practice ot of Medicine tinge lIngo 33 Al All thoe those wise who have hac In recent times wih with what Is known ot of time the structure and chemical ton tion ot of the tissues the laws ot of ton tion Ind and te the pathological changes which occur In organs during dla disease i must tel feel at at the unfounded assumptions want or of evidence and oven een unreasonableness which charne tense writings on the action ot of etnes The following appeared In the Eco Echo ot of June an 1892 Among the lening leading I medical men In London Is one who Is isa i 1 a fellow ot of time the ColeCe College ot of and ot of the tho Royal Society M D I and I physician to one ot of Ute time largest lanest hospi hospitais I tais In London In the very popular I bok book on medicine ot of which he Is eItor edItor i imo he ha has laid down at the bottom ot of the tho thory very ry first VI page e that al all s systems ot of medicine are ot of necessity tale false and ar are equal equally ly Iy unreasonable not wrong solutions ot of n ft scientific problem but Ignorant answers answer to an absurd queston question chat time the great French pathologist in his Generl General Anatomy Vol I page 17 I says Ins Medicine Is an Incoherent as assemblage assemblage ot of incoherent Idel ideas Ind and Is all the eel perhaps ot of 11 physiological I that which bet best shows the caprice ot of the tho human mind What did I say I It Is not n a science for tor a methodical I mind I It Is a a shapeless assemblage ot of otIn In inaccurate ideas of ob observations oten often puerile Ind and ot of formulae IS as fantastical fantastically ly h conceived as tey they or are tediously h nr ar arranged ranged Dr P R ft C S London says I It cannot be denied that time the pre present nt system ot of medicine Is a a burn In lag reproach to the In Indeed indeed deed a series ot of vague Ind and uncertain incongruities deserves to be caled called by that nome name How rarely do oUr medI cines do gol now how oren often do they make our patients relly really worse I fearlesslY assert that In mt most cases the tue would be safer without n a physician than wih with one I have 8 seen n enough ot of the malpractice ot of my profession to warrant the strong language I em employ employ ploy John Mison Mason God Good M 1 D B F R B S says sas The he elects effects ot of medIcine on time the system ae are In time the highest do dc gree uncertaIn except Indeed that they re hae save destroyed more lives than war pestilence and famine combIned Dr Olver Oliver Wendel Wendell Holmes the tho wel well known author and a professor o of anatomy In harvard In his Border Lines ot of knowledge ss says The disgrace ot of hB has been that t colossal system of at In obedience to which thich mines have hae been oen emptied ot of their cankering minerals empte the entrails of animals taken for theIr impurities and poison polson bags of reptiles draine drained of their venom arid and all thE the In Inconceivable conceivable absurdities thu obtained thrust down the throats ot of human be beings ings Ing suffering some want ot of or nourishment or vital al Fim Again I If al all drugs were cast Into the sea It would be 8 so much the beter better for tor tn man rind so 10 much te the wore worse for tor the Raises Enough statements along this an Une to 10 01 fill a bolt book might b be collected and the people who have hae s so much confIdence In drug medication cnn can plainly e see what a weak atar staff they at are leaning upon Ullon I quote one more statement Ly by the cele celebrated physician and physiologist Majendie t to his class od and published iii the pres press It at the time He says Let Letus Letus us no longer wonder at the lamentable want ot of which marks our practice tice when there Is scarcely n a sound principle amor u us I hesitate not to delare declare 10 no matter low sorely I should wound our vanity anly that so gr gross s Is our Ignorance of the ral real s nature ot of the physiological disorder called disease that It would perhaps cale be better beUer to do nothing and reign resign the complaint Into the hands ot of nature tha than to act 15 as wo we ar are frequently corn com polled to do without knowing the why and whereto wherefore I ot of our conduct at the obvious risk ot of hastening the end ot of the patient Gentlemen men medicine Is a great humbug I 1 know I it Is called science Science Indeed I I It Is nothing like science ad once ence Dolors Doctors are merly merely empirics empiric when they lre are not nol charlatans We are areas as ignorant ns as men can be Wise Who knows anything In the tue world abut about medicine you ou hac done me time the honor to come here to attend I may lectures and I must tel tell you OU frankly now In the beginning thAt I kno know noth nothIng lag Ing In the world about medicine and I dont know anybody who does know anything about It Rather n a frank confession for tor such an eminent man to make but ther there are many who have more confidence In dr drug medication Ihl than physicians themselves then ther there Is another clas class that have little confidence In drug drugs ad and when the physician prescribes the they do donot donot not take uke the drugs and nature does the tho work but II is cheated out ot of the credit Surgery and rational medication de do Jand the respect of the community but dru drug medication with its s serums and Uon tion inoculations Is n a disgrace tu to TUE TRUE S SMALLPOX PR In conclusion I desire to quote from eminent authorities In regard to te true ot of smallpox Mi and other diseases In time the Sanitary Home for tor Do De DeI comber 1899 1898 page US David 1 11 Reer Reeder I M I D B Ph Ih D gives Ive the following ble advice General u I Oeler unsanitary lan tal con conditions sewer fewer gas 1 poorly ventilated and sunless unwholesome to |