Show AS 10 1 A Jrm < lll SlATE Some lImo ago the NEWS mentioned a plan the originator 01 whIch Is au eminent Juritt Dr Herzl for the coin ulzatlon ol Jews In Palestine A conference con-ference of Hebrews bus now been called during tbe summer at Munich Uavarls for Ibo purpue of dlicusilnt the project Ills stated that several prominent Jews both lu Europe and lu this ountry are Interested In Ibo enterprise As might be expected there Is also much opposition The Jewish Mesien gel declare the whole scheme Impracticable Imprac-ticable Tbe paper argues that Judaism Is I not a question ol salt It was made poiBlble only when the temple and I nationality fell ZinnIa the paper say Ii not Judaism II Is I a weird specter ol the pail historically allied with the era DI the Crusade It recalls re-calls the luccetilon 01 false Messiah that almost every century has pro duceJ the long list of prophets tbat ban deluded tbe people and led them to Ibelr destruction Judaism In America will have none of It I The Hebrew Standard dennounces tbe plan became 01 the expenditure It Involves and exclaim Look around you btlp your starving brethren st t your own door1 < The New York IndepsnJent object lstre gathering of Ibo Hebrews the ground that It I weuU bs Impracticable Imprac-ticable for them to rebuild the temple end restore the sacrifices The revived Mosaic state that conservative journal jour-nal thinks would be controlled by She most unenlightened Kusilan and Polish Jews and wouU be an object ol contempt ridicule Only the rift riff would consent to live under such ojntrol Whether tbe plan of Dr Uerzl Is practical or uot or whether the time has come for lIe carrying out ol some such plan we need l not dIscuss at tbls time but II rniy be well to point out that all them argument ngalnst It might with qual fro have been advanced ad-vanced against the return ot the remnant from Babylonia at the limo ol Ezra They probably were urged too at Ibat time and considered sound reasoning by Ibouianda I who re malcoJ when their brethren started start-ed out on the perilous Journey across the wilds that separated them from the lead ol their fathers In set Ibo coudltloDO DOW era 10 many reepecta slrnllsr to those then prevailing prevail-ing Many of the Hebrews lo exile had allied tnemselvea with their cap lace nod made Ibelr 100100cc They bcU positions of trust and were shielded by a spirit of toleration Palestine woe ai It Is I today one vast ruin In tbe bonito of the rlUraQ ° ilowulroJJen and forsaken But these facts did tot prevent Iho faithful remnant by tbe rivers In Bibylonla from lol JowIcK tbe divine decree sod at the appointed lime rebuild the city of David and the temple of the Most Hlgb The very dlicutilon at this time o tbe possibility of establlshluc Jewish stile lu Palestine proves that there Iso Is I an awakening dislre In tbe ranks of the people to see fulfilment of the promises given to the falherv and wbo cm doubt tbat when the people are willing to turn to the ancient paths the Almighty is I ready to make good His everlasting novena SI It Is I In I perfect accord wltb the spirit and tbo letter of tbe Motalo dispensation and l It ii aIm In accord with reaioo lo look for a Urn when the law shall go forth from Zoo and tbe word ol Le I < ord from Jeruialsm |