Show Charley Ross Has Half Century Echo NEW YORK June 7 AP The AP-The The old half mystery of the of ot Charl Charley y Ross was under under un un- un- un der dr a revived fire cross-fire of at claims and denials of ot solution today Mrs Pierre C. C Starr of ot New York presented In a newspaper this morning a claim that she had found the missing Ross In the person of ot ofa ofa a n rugged Southerner who had adopted the tho name of ot Wv W C C. McHale Mrs Starr to be a cousin of ot the late Christian K Ross Hoss of or Germantown l Pa la a. a wealthy father rather of ot the child ped In 1874 Mrs Starr brought the tho man she ahe he claims Is Charley Chancy Ross to New ew York from the mountains of ot North C Carolina Members of the Ross family now living U In Philadelphia Immediately branded her story as ridiculous Walter L L. Ross a a. brother of the ped boy said She Is an Imposter and this Is not the first time tUne she has tried the pame IlAm trick Julius Coleman BelKer Bel Eel McHale or was known In W linger Unger Ker as he lie also wanted Carolina declared he lie North but only hla his Wr bIrthright 1 money no and said he knew he had Men been f adducted ad- ad J ducted dueled as aa ft it child He told of at haY haV haVIng nav the South carried led through Ing been car tinker i In his youth by W y- y yn n a n. wandering and gunsmith Who ho went by various names This Ts man McHale said admitted father lather his 1115 that he was not to him tell teU him d to day some Y and promised fulfilling ful tul who he was but died without filling mUng his promise One of the theories theo the Ross' Ross abduction was rica ries of ot Charley by that he had been carried off peddlers Two su sUch h men on whom centered were caught and suspicion fatally was wounded wound d while white robbing robbing other ther a house hOUe One orie of them s said ld the could solve the Charley Chancy Ross myStery mys mys- but both died Of ot gunshot tery deft deft- definite wounds before anything more nite could be told Christian lIan K IC floSs Rosi spent t r J In in s searching C for tor t the te boy oy before died in 1897 In a book about abou search he said some sorpe zoo chil child had been put forward n as hi his Since his d death ath th the tha solution of at I mystery has been claimed t times but each claim proved u wI M out foundation POSSESSES AFFIDAVITS Mrs Starr said she h had d from many persons who had had n kno th the present claimant since boyt of ot incidents telling telling- which coin with the few tew clues unearthed eQ a at the GREENSBORO N N. N C C. Ju jJ AP The AP-The The man referred to In 3 New v York World story of at the ft t Ing Ingo of Charley Hos probably li Iri I same man who ha hWi been known i some years in Lincoln CoUnt Julius Coleman Bellinger He lie met t Mr lr and Mr Mrs Mra here hel 8 Starr May Convinced t tho Li he was the long Jong lost Charley Chancy Ro n he arranged to go north with n nin th in an nn effort to establish his iden |