Show Sensation Sprung By Chorus Girl At Trial of Carroll I S. S c. c Ii j. j JI S K KI KS' KS S' S I v S 0 I s 5 I 35 S 'S Sj j S 5 Y I. I S 5 i S S SS S SEARL S S EARL CARROLL AND HIS WIFE Actress i in 1 Bathtub Party Alleges B Bribe i e Was Offer Offered d to Testify Absence of Champagne Champagne Champagne Cham Cham- Says She Disrobed While Intoxicated Intoxicated In- In v 5 5 Irvin Cobb Declares S P Party Was Proper 1 XE NEW V 1 YORK OI t. t May ra 25 United Press Press Press-NOye Joyce Ha the girl In Inthe Inthe inthe the bathtub of nf the Earl Carr Carroll lt perjury case ilay told her story of Carroll's Carrolls now famous amouR party part MI Miss R Hawley charged that Chris Scafe representative of Earl Carroll Carroll Carroll Car Car- roll offered to give give- ive- ive her if it sh sn would tell telI the federal grand jur toe the bathtub did ot contain cham This she said sh she had refused re refused refused re- re re- re fused to do Joyce arrived In court fifty three minutes late and just in time to O prevent issuance of r a bench war warrant war war- ral rapt rant for for fc t su h sum sum- i. i the dl district as a witness ess againSt t the theatrical producer producer pro pro- ro- ro dU ducer r S S CREATES ST STIR Joyce created reat d a stir a as as she slip dashed shed Int the courtroom wearing a I lavender lay lav vender v- v ender hat gray oat coat edged with fur and a dress to match her hat Court had b bein n In recess reces's recess folioIng follow folio following ing completion of the testimony it If t IrvIn S. S Cobb awaiting Joyces Joyce's ar ar- ar rival S Cobbs Cobb's direct examination was brief He Pie told of cf attending the party which Crr Carroll U gave February 22 23 He lIe had t told ld C Carroll li he vas was v s leaving he said and and C Carroll told him to remain that that a stunt would be done a girl In a bath bath- tu tub Cobb went out for a few minutes and r returned On he gave more details however ho Now you are on one of OC our foremost foremost foremost fore fore- most writers of f New York Herbert Herbert herbert Her Her- bert Smythe Carroll Carrell S Ia lawyer asked In my own opinion I am m answered answered an an- Cobb S SHe He said he i ad spent the the- hour houra at the party cha chatting with friends and watching the dancing It seemed emed to men dby by the accepted standards of ot Broadway perfectly proper he lle said Asked whether he had o of any any refreshments refreshment he said he ho had two glasses of beer beer or or It had the appearance of beer beer and a bottle of ot White Rock GINGER ALE The questioning then to ginger ale Cobb said he he saw aw around the stage stalie s 's sonie me b boxes he thou thought ht were labeled PAul P ull i Rogel r Ginger Cinger Ale He spelle spelled the I name Paul n it Roger i gerbut lt on on b being I reminded said h ht h- hk k guessed es ed It was Ppl Roger He Ito had not tasted lasted any I Of the liquid Did you sea the contents of the Hie tub lub Cobb was a asked ked He Hi said he he had tad and on being asked regarding it suggested perhaps per pr per perhaps haps he had bettor better ett r describe it It ft was as of a pinkish hue said Cobb darker than any straw straw col coI- coI ored or white wine and paler than any red wine vina I have seen It was neither red ed nol not but r rosy s I have never never neverseen seen any anN n like lika It Did reg lt res t champagne han S Smythe asked It did not resemble any champagne cham I have seen sen said the the author authorS On redirect ct examination n Cobb Sl sad sard 11 S he tho thought he V S1 saw the b bathtub re refilled filled d twice D Dj you ou drink he wa was asked DRINKS COCKTAILS I dont don't drink randy l or or whisky except for medicinal purposes he Je answered I 1 dc dont don't nt drink cham cham- I occasionally occasionally- drink a a co COCKtail COCK COCK- k- k tail tall it If I I Iam am sure sure sUl that the Ie alcoholic content will n not nt t be immediately fa h ta- ta tal Miss IIa hawley said that on the night of the party parry she had had several several several sev sev- eral drinks and that they made malle- me drunk She described Jiow she had answered answered an an- sw red Carrolls Carroll's summons summon's summons of Bab Baby all right by stepping onto the stage In her chemise chemIs ant ani slippers rs doffing them behind the cloak 1 which C Carroll Carroll Car Car- r- r roll held and Mi hm n stepping into tl tI th s bathtub beside her She told the jury that when the theline line jine formed to the right and men in It sought di drinks inks ink's from froin the tub in which she w was d bathing she cried aid Carroll scolded her When were you employed h by Mr Carroll the questioning went oh on on S 'S Abo About t a wC week lc before the party S Where nh re At a fashion pageant at the Hotel Astor Ast r How much did you u receive Twenty T s' s Did you attend the party as a agues gues guest 7 Yes les I did I Continued d on pa page e 7 SENSATION SPRUNG V BY CHORUS GIRL AT CARROLLS CARROLL'S TRIAL Continued from page 1 Did you see a bathtub there Yes 1 I did Did you look in lii 11 the bathtub Yes Yea I saw the liquor in there Did you have any to drink Three or four glasses Did you OU have any other drinks drinks' Yes I did Chris Scaife Carroll's Carrolls Carrolls Carroll's Carrolls Carroll's Car Car- rolls roll's bodyguard or 01 Jimmy Carroll Carroll Carroll Car Car- roll Carrolls Carroll's Irether gave it to me V What effect It U have on you ou It got me drunk STEPS INTO TUB At 4 a. a m. m Miss arias the He testified Carroll came and said Baby all rl ht and I then stepped Into the wings and watched Mr Ir Carroll I had on a chemise and shoes Earl Carroll came up with an opera cloak and I followed him across the stage e took off oft mv my shoes and my chemise and gave them to Mr 1 Carroll I then stepped Into the tub The bathtub she ste said about an nn inch and a half halt of or liquid Did Mr r. r Carroll say anything Yes Yel he said Lets have a drink on this beautiful fl figure ure that's about the worst he said Then The he said sompt about the line forming to the rl right ht anti and I started crying Mr Carroll Carron bawled me out and after atter about five minutes I was wheeled to the tte back of the llie stage There I dressed and when I came back baek I was cr crying Ing Asked If she had been able to s see sac p Earl Darl Carroll during the days davs after utter the bathtub party she said No Not NoI Io I t saw him the net next day y but after that I talked with V Chris ris Scaife Every time I tried to see Carroll he tie sent Chris S Scaife down to see gee me me V V I When you ou got into thOp the bathtub were you drunK sober or V VV V f J i I runk J JHerbert Herbert C. C Smythe Carrolls Carroll's counsel examined cross-examined her sug suggesting sug- sug gesting that perhaps she didn't re remember remember remember re- re member things I do remember things but I wa was feeling very good I had to feel teel good to do a thing like that After Atter out of ot the tub she said sl she dressed Immediately When I came back on the stage I Iwas Iwas Iwas was crying Carroll said Damn It it H. keep your Jour head up lP or keep off the damn floor I went downstairs and then the they started taking pic plc- tures V You had a b bathing suit on and then changed ed to a chemise Yes The other girls did also She left about 5 30 she told Smythe and the next day called calle up Carroll When did you OU see him personally person- person ally she was asked I saw him the day after arter I told him Mm that he had promised me or or 1000 but I never got ot it Then Carroll said to me ine me Why didn't you stay stav I told him I was excited and so left after the party She said h he hd had har asked her to leave town with a friend Juan lie lle who her het to the party I walked out Joyce Joce Jo ce sal said and ana wouldn't have anything to do them She said she has received no money from Carroll yet and has filed tiled a suit against him the papers of ot which have not yet been served she said |