Show TISH CABINET BlOW BlOWN N jN IN HILLS DF DEfEAT Ii H rach h in Solid Conserva- Conserva ve e Vote of Liverpool Impresses Public Seat Won on by Labor Candidate i March 7 T By A A A. P rhe p. The The aroused in the house of ot mops mOM moos and the political clubs over defeat of or John Waller Waner Hills finan- finan secretary of the treasury in a election bye spread to general public today when the the known through ugh the UL ilde ide from the unprecedented de deRf deot de- de Rf ot of three ministers In s succession it few rew months after the new gox- gox ment ment came Into power r. r the sig- sig anco of ot the breach In the solid soUd 1 lianca e va a ive phalanx of ot Liverpool u Irn- Irn uses u- u ses the public was defeated In the Edge- Edge of ot that city by a plurality about b ut 1000 votes The seat was wasy wasby by y J J. T. T H H. Hayes the labor abor candi- candi who Ja Js said to have been surat sur- sur ed at his victory ith the exception of ot the Scotland of ot Liverpool which v the veter- veter I Thomas P P. O OConnor Connor t represented since every everyone one I li s eleven divisions ms has bas been I resented resented by a conservative for many man firs jIs rs Sir W W. W W. Rutherford the sit sit- of ot Edgehill wh who retired H Q provide a seat for Mr Hills has hasi i returned by large majorities in iny tp r y election for far the past twenty rs 68 58 per cent of ot the electorate This showing is geniI gently gen gerl- Uy attributed to the refusal to supt sup- sup iI- iI t f a nominee of ot the government fose ose policy on the house question some other Issues Is held in prof pro- pro 1 f Jid d d. d disapproval by a faction of at the t other factor In Hills Hills' defeat ac- ac act Qing to some observers was the tho i I Ib linens bens ens en's vote Wills Wills' ills ills' defeat Is regarded as a stag stag- ing blow at the government ec tithe the results of ot the Mitcham and bye elections In which Sir SirI bur ur Boscawen and nt int Colonel G G. F F. Stanley both I bers of ot the government were deI de- de ted ed I 1 lay layes s. s the new member Is a 8 forI for for- I J J ondon policeman |