Show ROY KAIGHN AND JENNIE H. H COATES STAR WITNESSES WITNESSES' IN I THE HAYNES TRIAL Young S Kaighn Corroborates His Aunts Step Story of Attempted Assault in iii Col Kaighn's Parlor and DeI De- De Describes I scribes Knutsford Shooting t I JURORS WHO WILL DETERMINE DETER t THE FATE OF HAYNESS HAYNES'S SLAYER J Ji t f ti tiThe tit if i- i c. t f The Jurors who will determine the fate of Roy noy Kal hn charged d with f the murder of oC Willard Villard S S. S Haynes In the the order order in which they were ac- ac f copied are arc tI f ROBERT RODERT N. N HOUr HOLT Mill Creek f ff f HOWARD EDWARD WHITE farmer Mill Creek f THOMAS W W. PARTRIDGE real estate Salt Lake f JESSE V GOODFELLOW wool buyer Salt Lake f t CHARLES farmer 1 West Jordan I 4 ALFRED J J. J GRANT farmer Granger er t ALONZO YOUNG employee Z Z C. C C M. M I. I I shoe factory factor Salt Lake A. A E E. CADDY smelter employee Murray f t ff f HEBER B 13 B. B ALDOUS contractor Salt Lake J EDWARD grocer Salt Lake f lIE HENRY RY E. E RAWLINGS barber Salt Lake V f ff f JA JAMES IES KEMP KE farmer Crescent f f t tt t Roy the defendant and his step-aunt step Miss Jennie Coates were the star witnesses In the Haynes lIanes murder trial today Miss lIss Coates was put nut under a n rigid cross Her story ston of the alleged assault was corroborated by young oung Miss Coates Again on Stand Miss MIs Jennie Coates fiancee of the deceased deceased de de- de- de ceased d III n s. s who was WIlS on the witness stand when court adjourned adjourned adjourned ad ad- yesterday was recalled to the stand i l District Attorney Eleanor c continued I 11 his cross f R cross e. e exa s 1 She he said sold that she and Roy I alghn had hod attended a n ball given hen bya business I college She admitted that the d defendant defendant defend defend- I ant had acted as a a. sane sanc man would on that occasion Haynes Sober She Says In answer to Mr Eichnor's questions the witness declared she and Mr Haynes had attended a recital at the Tabernacle on the nl night ht of or November No 2 23 25 1901 She said that Mr Haynes Hanes was perfectly sober ober on the night of the theall all alleged ed as assault aull In repenting repeating her story of the assault she saidI said I was seated near Mr III Haynes In Inthe Inthe inthe the back parlor of or Col Cot home Ha Haynes nes reached out and tried to pull me over on his Ills lap 1 I resisted and he quit We e then sat and talked for a awhile while He Ke said nothing that could be he misconstrued In any wn way We e had talked only a short time however when Mr Haynes IIa nes reached out and grabbed me In the scuffle I fell tell to the floor She Did Not Scream Did he tr try to strangle you 7 asked Mr Eichnor No he did not said the witness You didn't scream for help No sir You did not call an any of the thc members members mem mem- bers of ot the family No sir Mr rr Haynes Baynes was trying to commit an all as assault ault upon you OU and still you ou did dill not call for help No sir Then Thenh h why didn't you ou scream for help I I was ashamed to let the Colonel know that Mr Haynes had done such sucha a thin thing Refers to Previous Statement Miss 1188 Coates Isn't It a fact act that you ou I told a Tribune reporter on the night nigh t of oC the of or November that he would be surprised ed to Ic learn arn how little the trouble between you OU and Mr Ir Haynes Hanes amounted to and also that you ou und and Mr 11 Ha Haynes nes had parted as friends I do not know whether I did dl or not In answer to District Attorney Eichnor's Elch- Elch nors nor's questions the witness told of or her visit to the hospital She said she silo did not willingly I permit Mr Ir Haynes Hanes to hold her hand at any time K Kaighn on the tho Stand Ro Roy Kals-hn Kals the defendant told the court that he was 20 O years old and that I he lie had used cigarettes since he was S years ears old oili When did you ou commence using absinthe absinthe absinthe ab ab- ab- ab sinthe asked Judge King About five Jive years ears a ago o was the re- re re ply ph start to use alcohol When hen did you ou In Its pure 11 state About three years ago ao What hat was a the condition of oC your our health Just prior to the shooting I suffered continually from head head- aches Could you oU sleep at nights No Xo sir Do you U remember cutting your hand handon on a bo bottle lc as was testified to by hy your our father No sir I do not Were ere there times when you ou could not recall what had happened Yes sir Heard Miss Coates Call Do you remember remember when hen you first met Mr Haynes I Yes sir When hen was It In the summer some Kime time In the summer bummer prior to the shooting shooting shoot shoot- ing inc Yes sir Were Vere you and Mr 11 Hn Haynes neg friendly roo Yes Yos sir You know the occasions of ot Mr visits to your fathers father's home Yes Ye sir Where wore were you OU and what had you been doing the day prior to the shooting 7 I I was out r the day clay drinking and stayed at nt home hone In n the evening I 1 Iwas was feeling badly You went to bed did you OU 1 Yes ies sir Were ere you awakened during the night Yes sir What was the noise It was Miss l s Coates's voice What Wha t did you ou do 7 I slipped on my trousers and went downstairs s What hat did you ou see there Miss Coates and Mr Ir were facing each other What did you oti hear either cither of them say I he hem heard rd Miss lIss Coates Contes tell Mr Ir Haynes Hancs to leave the house and never to return I What R hat did dill Haynes do t 1 He lie sat down on the sofa stayed there Ihor therea a short time UlO on and l then tho 1 uto op his hat t und and t-and and l 1 Tl qu c t t Began to Drink Alcohol f What did you OU do after that 7 I stayed up all nl night ht and drank alcohol and smoked cigarettes How did you ou the spend forenoon of ot of the next du day duy If I r recollect I helped put up some Borne screens I What hat did you ou do then 1 I think I took a car and went down town Did you ou have any purpose In view when you OU went down town No sir Who did you see se down town 7 I saw Baw Mr Hancs at the Knutsford hotel hote What did you OU go to see sec him for To get him to apologize Ize to me and V my family for his actions Demanded an Apology What hat happened then 7 I told Mr Haynes v that he must apologize and he told me to keep m my nose out of ot his business He reached for his hip pocket and I drew my revolver re and fired The witness stated In answer to further questions that he did not have nn any distinct recollection of or his Ills actions from that time until he had been lodged In the city cHo Jail In cross examining the witness District District Dis Dlf- Attorney Eichnor asked What was waa the exact lan language used by Mr 11 Haynes Hancs on the da day of or the the- shooting shoot shoot- InS ing logy The witness related the stor story r of the traSe tragedy 1 as ns brou brought ht out by hy Judge Kings King's questions and admitted that he had telephoned telephoned telephoned tel tel- to Mr Ha s Just JURt prior prior to to the shooting and told Haynes Hancs that he would be at the hotel to see him within a short time lIe He stated that he then went vent to a 11 hardware store and purchased purchased pur pur- chased a revolver and went to the hotel hotel ho ho- tel Witness Could Not Explain Attorney Eichnor asked the witness why he did dill not go co direct to the hotel after telephoning to Mr Haynes before purchasing the tho revolver The fhe witness was unable to state The attorney for Cor the State then asked the defendant If Ir he be had ever taken tn- tn ken cocaine opium or morphine I dont don't remember taking any of these drugs the witness replied Miss on the S Stand Miss Jennie Coates Conte a step aunt o 0 nt no Roy Kaighn and fiancee of Youn Young victim was on the witness stand during the entire n afternoon ses session session ses- ses I S- S sion sian of or the court yesterday Miss Coates told of her meeting with Roy Ro about four years ago She Sho said that she and Ho Roy Boy had gone Sone to school to together together together to- to gether and were wera fairly well acquainted before beCore Cot Col had married her sister She declared that after alter her sisters sister's sisters sister's sis sis sis- ter's terA marriage e to Col Cot Kaighn she had hall gone bone to live with them Roy also lived lI there according to the story of oC the witness and she soon came cameto to regard the boy hoy as a n younger brother Miss 1 Coates said ald that Ro Roy drank a n good deal and that she never neVE thought that he was in his right mind Kaighn's Queer Actions In explaining some of or the boys boya queer actions she said One evening evenin Roy and I were sitting In ht the library studying our lessons Roy noy heard the doorbell lI ring He Jumped up from the table and ran Into a a. closet cry crying I UK They are arc after me mo the doorbell It It My 1 sister answered was a man with some souk plants plant I went back to the tho closet and told no Roy that it was nobody looking for him When he came out of the thc closet he threw up his han hands s and fI said paid Thank God I am saved td Threw Ink Bottle at nt Wall Another r time the tb witness continued when Roy Hoy came home I was sitting In Inthe Inthe Inthe the kitchen studying ln my lessons lie He said sahI I Hello Bello Jen Is there an anything to cat about this d d- d dranch ranch I I became frightened and started up- up V Continued on page pace Go 6 CJ Roy oy Kaighn Continued from Page Pago 1 1 1st st stairs I had more mort than I could carr carry so I left an ink bottle lying lyinG on the kitchen table I had been upstairs only a few minutes when I heard a crash I rushed downstairs and found that Ro Roy had n throw throw-n the Ink bottle botte against the side of or the wall wal Ink had spattered In all al directions He Heas was as standing there laughing at what he had done He ordered me to gets set down and wash up UJ the ink I r refused fused at first but he looked so queer queer queer- that I was afraid of or him and I cleaned up the mess Ho Called Cale Her Names He stood over o er me all of the time laughing and calling me names nunes In re relating relating re- re lating another similar experience Miss Coates told th JUr that on another occasion he had tome come home drunk and cut his hands severely erel e on a bottle which he had broken She said ld that she bound his hands up for him and arid put him in bed The next morning accordinG according according ac ac- ac- ac cording cordinG to her stor story Ro Roy came to he her herand herand and asked her wh why his hands were tied ted up in clothes 11 IIi I said Mid that he remembered remembered nothing that that had happened the night before Tho The Witness Wines Weeps In reply to questions propounded b by Attorney Hoffman Hofman Miss CoMes Coates told between between be he- tween sobs gob of her relations with Haynes Hanes She said sid that she had met Haynes Haynee about two tto years' years before the shooting and he would c call l upon her near nearly every night he was in town She said that the they would seldom spend their evenings e at home but that he would take her out riding or driving or orthe orthey orthey the they would go for a n wal walk or to the theaters theaters theaters the the- aters or some some other place of amuse amuse- men ment t. t The latter later part of July 1901 she said sid Haynes had asked her to become his wife I did not give him an answer at nt that time she said eald I 1 told him to wait lt until I could talk the matter mOter over with wih m my sister Haynes Wanted an Answer I next saw Mr Haynes Hanes In August Col 01 Kaighn m my sister Mr Haynes and myself went to together Mr lr Haynes Harnes remained in Salt Bait Lake several days das on that trip and I saw aw him al almost almost almost al- al most ever every night He lie asked me to give him a reply to his proposal but I told him to wait walt until the next time he came to the c city I Mr I. I Hayness Haynes's HOness next visit to Salt Sal Lake was S in November On November Mr lr Haynes HInes called up by telephone I Iwas Iwas Iwas was dressing dresing and my sister Mrs rs Kaighn answered the phone Mr Ir Haynes lynes asked my sister If I she Col Cot and myself would be his guests at a recital recial at t th Tabernacle the thc following following fol fol- fol- fol lowing Monday night She Consented to GoMy GoMy Go My I sister told him that she and the Colonel had an engagement for tO Monday Monday Monday Mon Mon- day night b but t for tor him to call me up later He e did so gO and I consented to go with him I met him on Monday night between Main and State street on Second Sec Sac ond South street street I was not feeling el well neil and I suggested that we take the car car and go so home He lie said ald that he ho wanted to go so o we went to the Taber- Taber nacle but stayed only o a short time On our way stay a home we stopped topped at th the Che Chesapeake ap ike restaurant and Got got some Gome oysters on t r Story stor of tho the Assault Assault When we reached home I held oui out m my hand hantl to bid him good night but ho said aid hanc that hi his car ha had Just passed be another rinI nd as there would not Ic along long for thirty minutes he would go 30 goIn In We e went vent Into the back parlor He lIe le leat sat at on the sofa fora and I on a chair near him We Ye were talking of ot our future lives l cs He H pulled my m chair toward him and od grabbed meA meAs meAs me As A I 1 went vent to pull a away from himm him pul and I m my chair slipped from under me fell elt to the floor He lie foil over me We e e Ie struggled and in the struggle ruggle I bit him himon himon himon on the left lett arm He lie let me up after ater 1 I had bitten him and as 39 I got up he said said- ld have had that Jennie I would not ha c hal happen happel for tor 30 I replied Well Mr Haynes jayneS laynes I would I el not have have had hat that happen for 00 She Refused Refused His HandI Hand I ordered him out of ot the house When he reached the Olt door he offered ino ti-ic his hand but I refuted refused ed to bid him good good- good n I gut Mr Ir examined cross the witness witness wit wit- It ness for the State She admitted that C. C Ranee Ilance a she hc had married Samuel was only lb It photographer when she he h with him years cars ears old and that she lived led Ies Coates W was tas only a n short time Miss Mies court ad adjourned ad- ad still on the stand aland when the a- a JIl e |