Show = I 4 J THE SUPREME COURT 11 fI f I I Appeal By tna City From the Vii l I diet of a Jary For 2000 H 1 I CUM KIIUII ON Till lUIIUOAl W if t SelIbe Ito rho Irolnl Igatott k < I on i I ilclloti boor llramt Iourcenyfbrre II I r Wue iu UiilnUui tenon r At tI fobs diy > UMlon 01 tho Territorial i 1 Terri-torial Supreme oou it no nplnlom were I I 1 banded down The fudge on the I t l bench were Auftclate Juitlcei Miner o llartcb aud Hmllli Cblif Juitoe 7 me Lut f If did not take bent In the proceeding If I T1IM City AlI ° OAb 4 1 In lha CM o of Ueorge Naylor rO i I ponileut vi the Mountiln Won C fall f-all liko City and tbe Salt Lake City 1 I i lUllruad Co defendant and Halt 1h I both I Oily u IIInl the respondent > h I wai repreeenlol by Judge Power nnd I 1 11 Attorney V N Htraup for Ilia appel ali Judge Hoge and Attorney li F I Cold appv4leJ 1 if i I The kctlun lu the Joe molt wa 1 brought 103 Naylor a aluit the defend t I am for Infuilci cWmJ to hn born utlalniHl by Mm on the nljbl of bloc 1 7lli I 18UI by their Deglieuco II and i cateliriiuia lu placing large tll H ut > lnu near the crowing I un HIM vail Uu I of Boil III Temple and 1 iI Fond Houlli sbrcoI hIs lame he dated having been tilt without I prolecllou oran t or-an ilgnal lo Indicate danger 1lln I llll While driving a borie knit carl along the thoroughfare wan thrown i violently over the lone fIle receiving 0li I t II li alleged permanent Inlurle When i j III the act of filling ur bust after ba t loud tilleti tha 1 tell ilruck by a i moving carol the streut company and be wa dragned kulitauce ol ten or I 0 twelve feet The evIdence ou the I trial f thowed thai tome tlmu prior I tu the accident I ac-cident the city let a contract lo tba Mountain Hluno company to do certain P > avlug of It pill t uf g the alieet croii i Inc and 1 did Ibo railroad company rhwn contract were lublello WIlkes I Wlk end 1aliuer who did the actual work j Un Ibo beirlng of the ult In Ibo Third Ultrlct court be ford Judge 7t ne the re > i < ondeat woe uonulloj aa lo the Itallfoad k I Company aol Ihu ltua of fact WftO i If 3 I lubuiillid 10 tbejury between Naylor i and the oilier twudefeniUuti A ncr 1 < 01 f2IHiu wai then returned agaltiit Hall Lake City by whom tlie 1 pieeut appetl li I proeculvd 0 Tllll COW WAR ICILLKU 1 There wai one other cat argued In K E d Hit K A Jelli woe plalnlilt aud Itipondent repieeenlcd by Altorueti Juun M r Canuouand llarloir Fergu p00 kucl Ibe Ula Uraude Wetlvru t llallroad Company Uefendatiti and kp 1 lellanl for wb ui Judge Marihall 3 mu I ireJ Jl11r iJ 0 iloe i action wa Inilltulud by f lain UU lureouverSTo Ihu value Ufa cow 1 klllrtl by a cullnlou wltu k witch i auulue while ruunlug north ufHlxili West treet The oao wai tried beloru Coinmlloner 1ratt who found for j JUUI Ibul 01 fd and SSla cool Au alloch > boil lakiu lu bite Third Ulitriot Court a Jury returned a ver I dint In favor uf pialulll lu lie ul ul i i tw together with Intertel at eight Ir cent and out the litter plioed kl US I Mjllou lor a new trial WM 1 undo and oveirulod aol hence the I I letenl appeal othOtaiNOh OUT lOb AOIIIJIINAL TIIIAL 1 The coo of tbe 1uopu of tbe terri I lury plalnllll u1 I rllOuliool v Nellie llerllu ilefiudaut and appal J lint was tubmltted 00 Iriclt inecaua wu Irld at the May term ItJS ol tbr Fuuiih dlitrlcl I court Judge j Miner on II Jlctmut found by the grand jury chirking I Ibe defendant defen-dant I with grand lircny Tha trial j Jury lubiwquenlly louudher guilty and sloe woe lentumeid lu a year in the nlleutlary A oem trial woe applied for but Ibe court overruled Iba motion J Ukeu and Ironi Ibe JnJ mol kjkppeaU |