Show I I I I r I V 1 I JUD JUDGE E ORDERS f lI F 4 i 0 Attacks Called So Good od Ci Citizen n Who Bre Breaks ks Law w INSTRUCTS JURORS JURORS' f T Upholds Sta Stancl Under ii r F Federal ed Statute t te teto to k Lo LOUISVILLE Ky y Oct 15 Aiso- Aiso o- o elated Press The October r f t g-t grand n J jury of f the United States district ourt here tod today i ws was ws un under er in instruction instruction in- in from fro Judg e Charles eCharles' Ch rl s I. I I.- I. Dawson to indi indict t if evidence w warranted r ted tl tIe the buyer ye as al s well s seller eller of liquor p I Attacking fg th the soc called so good Ih patronizes zes b bootleggers om Jug Judge Kentucky at attorney at- at torney g Tl d declared th the widespread wide wIde- spread cad Impression that It is js n not t against t th th- th law lawr to purchase h. h 50 liquor or orIs' orIs Is Is' l Referring to a. a decision lon of the the circuit c url t pp of ot the Second district t at at t Philadelphia J d ald th t he bad iad not Iea tIl Courts Court's but ltv as Ills s o opinion that that Jm what t th that t r really lly a decided Was Waa U that t one orie who is is not p purchases s such uch nn in aider ulder or or abettor bett t of of or tho seller r ra a n to aa a seller unde the al la CITES SECTION T To Td- Td that extent Judge Dawson f said ld In his lula charge chars I ji a agree r c with the o opinion but If fr that opinion lon h holds that that- it is not offense an-offense against th the national act for tor ono ones onesto oneto to tor to purchase nse t a 3 per permit per per- m mit t and not o on oil a 3 prescription Uon then t cannot I-cannot agree with with it bec use I Iha bar hav no ni no doubt whatever nh that the act Intended d to to and does docs in in i express terms m make 1 e It illegal for ot individuals to to- purchase liquor for for personal consumption for forbey beverage bev bov- orage crag eo purposes cs i t I He d section 6 of 01 the national nation al at prohibition n act which lie ie said sald among other pr provisions declares No uNo one sell p purchase transport or prescribe any liquor without first a permit erl lt from the thi commissioner I i- iso soto so soto to do except that a a. person 1 ma may without a a- permit p purchase and use se liquor r for medicinal purposes when prescribed by bS' a lal If It t the language ge ju just t rend JJ Judge l c Dawson commented do does s n not t pro ro- ro Continued on page paS 10 19 ER pi OF S BOOZE GUILTY JUDGE STATES STArES S 5 T. T S. S Continued rom from p page ge 1 the purchase of liquor b by In Individuals n tor for personal consumption for tor beverage purposes l. l without a p then I 1 am l incapable capable of understanding un Un- d rs t the meaning V of lan lan- guage PROVIDED FINE D t f Section 29 9 of ot the act provid providing ng a n. fine up Ul to for the first and and imprisonment Im- Im for tor not more than 90 O Oda da tor for the second offense cense applies s sto to to p persons p p purchasing g liquor for tor beverage purposes Judge Dawson told the the Jurors S J ax 1 Ji know ow It is frequently urged Judge Judg Daws Daw n. n concluded clude that If it you m make ke it tb the Jaw law to pur c chase chae fr or if It Yf you enforce the law agaInst t the purchaser you OU will hamstring tho the enforcement ot oZ the l law w b because caul you then cannot get t tc c evidence against against J th the tho BeUer And tho manufacturer t that w worry rry you for tor a minute I. I have been on 1 this benc a little beUer than t tJ J ur years and indi in lii 1 i that l leng length of ot time tImo wo We have handled between arid 1090 quor cases v r and nd not In izi a a s single e one ope of t them h has bas a citizen cUbel buyer buer ever ever appeared as a n witness seller dr a r. r o a. |