Show Jl C 1 T IN lIlliAN GISH m H sun SUIT ANGELES April 25 AP AP- AP Several LOS years of ot legal effort by Duell motion picture producer producer pro pro- pro pro- Charles from Lillian LIlllan Lil LIl- ducer to exact damages naught A to lian Tian GIsh have come court Here ere re returned jury In superior the film star defendant defendant defendant defend defend- a verdict for after the court had ant yesterday that all the issues issues' of the decided In Inthe inthe settled previously had been previously case court of New York the federal Miss GIsh relief Gish Oh what a a. a she learned that the 5 5 said when suit her onetime onetime had employer against h her ber had been had decided brought again in her favor I r am very The happy trial ended rather suddenly the defense renewed re renewed re- re when defense yesterday 3 of ot previous ad ad- the argument sr attorneys Miss G Gish's attorneys that the tile Issues issue In Duells Duell's argued already had been decided complaint inthe In Inthe were sustained ed cd and they upon the courts court's directed verdict The defense had me made the JUe eThe e- e adjudication plea when the opened last week but the case court at that time ruled that It would hear the testimony Du Duell ell had to offer before d deciding the question ques ques- tion Duells Duell's suit was based on charges that he had raised Miss 1 GIsh to stardom under his employ and that when she was offered a position with the Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Metro studios she broke her contract with him The New York decision held that both Miss GIsh and Duell had broken the contract and refused the latter an Injunction preventing the star from performing for anyone anyone anyone any any- one else |