Show US BEATTY TO DR METZ Editor lrl ul1eThe Importance oe the question In too great l to allow to pnus unnoticed un-noticed the reported assertlons of Dr Mete In the Salt nIce Tribune of today tatting Issue with the statement made by mo In the paper on typhoid fever In which I claim that No tosJs chemical micro scopical or bacteriological can he rolled upon to determine the abucnce of typhoid bacilli from u water supply lie Is I quoted as aayinj that such m opinion war huld In the jiaut uie of modi cine etc but tlmnkn be to science Jt Is I no longer true an chemistry and bacteriology bacte-riology may be relied upon to prove the produce or absence of typhoid bacilli from a water supply I i desire to Bay that It was for the purpose of calling attention to the danger existing In unit mich doctrine itt that advanced by the doctor that the point In my articles wa emphasised I reiterate It and cull upon the doctor over his own signature 1 to substantiate Ills claim 1 am sure he docs not wish to be understood ui holding hut chemlonl moans can detect disease oignnlsms which leaves only bacteriological methods to be dhcusucd No one denies that In a given specimen of Infected water subjected to bacterio logies test by menus or a cultuie tho presence of typhoid bacilli will be disclosed dis-closed But what assurance Is there that a specimen or many bpocimens taken from the millions of gallons dally flowing In tho water mains will contain typhoid bacilli In point of fact It Is only an In ilnltcalmal proportion of the water In such a system even when largely contaminated thut contains bacilli as must h apparent to any one who gives the subject a mo mrntp rcllcctlon If I It were otherwise thoiiHanilH of people lining the water would contract tho disease Instead of the limited number affected If thf entire accumulation ac-cumulation of excreta from a case of tho disease wore thrown at one tlm Into one of the streams supplying Salt L alcc City it would be BO diluted that it would only bo by the merest chance that the bacilli would bo found In an quantity such as that of I ho sample used for a bacteriological bacterio-logical test Water of the quality found in our mountain streams Iu not a good culture medium for tho propagation of disease organisms ami they certainly aro not liable to prorogate and Increase after their Intioductlon Into It Is It possible to better Illustrate the fallacy of depending upon water analysis than by the example just furnished In thin city Were not chemical and bacteriological tests of Parleys Par-leys canyon water made by tho score during the past few weeks and was not the water pronounced pure and free from any evidence of Infection Accepting this statement did not thousands thou-sands of people conclude that It was un ieccsimry to boll or otherwise take precautions pre-cautions with water and thus misled subject themselves to danger In view of the fact that It transpires a case of typhoid t ty-phoid fever had existed on the banks of that stream during all of the time and Is now held responsible In part for the prevalence of the disease In this city It Is no reflection on the ability or cure of the city chemist that IIP failed to find evidence evi-dence of contamination lie Is entirely competent and simply reported on the strength of what he found or failed to tlnd and no other chemist could have done more It Is only another Instance of thousands which might be cited wherein where-in chemical 1 and bacteriological tests failed to discover the presence of the contamination contamina-tion responsible for typhoid ever outbreaks out-breaks und I challenge any one to quote a single authority who claims that any practical chemical mlcioscopical or bacteriological bac-teriological test can be relied upon to dc termlne the absence of typhoid bacilli from an public water supply It would Indeed be an easy matter to settle the origin of typhoid in all cases of water I Infection if It were fortunately susceptible suscepti-ble of such simple determination It Is useful to I make chemical and bacteriological bac-teriological tests of water for their presumptive pre-sumptive value The detection of large amounts of nitrites and albumenold ammonia am-monia IK 1 presumptive evidence of Impurity Impuri-ty and should be acted upon accordingly Hut their absence Is no evidence of the absence of riiscaso organisms The only practical means at our command for solv hog the question of Infected water supply Is the study of the cases of disease ns related re-lated to it and the exercise of inilnltc pains to ascertain any focus of infection connected with Its source such as a contiguous con-tiguous case of time disease or a distant deposit of Infected excreta excluding all other possible sources Tho statement In a morning pier that the Bullock cnsu was discovered by tracing trac-ing impurities found by tests in the stream Sunday IB Incorrect The case was reported by t the writer the previous Wednesday or Thursday ho having telephoned tele-phoned the Roach family to verify the rumor ru-mor of a case In that place They denied de-nied having had the disease hut stated that a case had occurred In the Bullock family This I reported to the health department de-partment with recommendations to make Immediate Investigation and was referred to In my article written Saturday It Is will to i > e reminded that a large proportion propor-tion of thu casea during the present outbreak out-break have been among people Ufclng well water and those should be condemned and every effort made to fight the danger existing in the soil pollution in the west Bide of town T B BI3ATTY SaIL Lake City Sept Sth r3ACKACHE 1 I tjfjf Baclcaclio Is a forerunner and one of tho most common symptoms symp-toms of Judncy trouble and womb displacement READ MISS BOUMANS EXPERIENCE u Some time ago I was in a very weak condition my work made me nervous and my back ached frightfully all the time and I had terrible head aohos 11 JMy mother got a bottle of IJydifl E Piiilchama Vegetable Compound Com-pound for me and it seamed to strongthen my back and help me at once and I did not get so tired abc a-bc or 1 continued to take it and it bruoght health and strength to ms and 1 want to thuulc you for the pcod it has clone xiicMtsa KATI UOATMA H2ml SI Wales Arc New York City COOO forfeit If orlglurlt abovo letter iiroatny getiulnancsx cannot produced Iydia E Pinkliams Vegetable Compound cures because it is fcho greatest Jciioivu remedy for kidney and womb troubles Every woman who is puzzled about her condition sboultl write to irs Pinklxum at Lynn Muss and toll her aU yr A A DISEASE SCROFULA WE INHERIT Scrofula manifests itself in many ways Swelling of the glands of the nccl amid throat Catarrh weak eyes white swelling offensiveiorcs ammcl ah scesses skill cmptiot11j lossof strength an weakness in muscles and Jomls It is n miserable c1iHase and traceable in almost every instance to some family blood taint c 4 1 bred in the i Scrofula appeared on tho Load of my Scrofula 1 is b ret 111 1e o little frrnndehild when only 18 monthn bone 1 is transmitted J old mid spread rapidly ovor her body C 4 4 1 l 1 t The dinoaao next uttncked tho 1 oyos and from parent to child t cr wo foarod oho would loco hor sipht Eminent the seeds are planted in l i J Em-inent physicians woro connultod but nfancU and unless the ft l r 1 could do nothing to roliovo tho littlo In infancy nooont It was thou that wo decided to blood is purged and purified try S S S That mcdlcino at once rondo pu-rified of j r2 u speedy and complete euro She in now and atom every J a younir lady and has never had a sign the taint removed Scrofula I of the dlaeaso to return Scrof-ula 1 is to d 4 1 at MRS RUTH BEIlttlA 11 a IS sure develop a 100 South 5th Street Saline Knn some period your life No remedy equals S S S as a cure for Scrofula It cleanses and builds up the blood makes it rich and pure and under the tonic effects of this great Blood Remedy the general health improves the digestive organs are strengthened I and there is a gradual but sure ictttrn to health The deposit of tubercular matter in the 3 joints and glands is carried off as soon as the blood b 1 is i restored to a normal condition and the sores eruptions erup-tions and other symptoms of Scrofula disappearS disappear-S S S is guaranteed purely vegetable and harmless an ideal blood purifier and tonic that removes all blood taint and builds up weak constItutions constitu-tions Our physicians will advise without charge all wbo write us about their case Book mailed freeSWBFT WISE SWBfT SPEGEFSG GQoy ATIANTA Gk a = t z x = = r t i = = o I iJ r E1 = Fr otit = > SI I m ft = tJCy J f fs I J = ro p < = cL J A r > r l ft Jp = f < W = J I I v fr vr = Ie = = ur y = Oili < = I FfeSEsr Ss = o = r r K I R t 1rh e Sweet Toned I O I J r 1 r h = c d I Xc1e I ij P 31 i fj jA e k tf C 1 Leads the World 5n jf r r Piano Excalilenco bk l t I Call at oyr store and we vll be l pease to show yon why f lMS L I i the K abe Is the cheapest H J t = 1 cheap-est and the best t f 1 J 1 WE ARE SOLE AGENTS FOB THE 1 l r WONDEBFUL PIANOLA rS 1 I J v I Mc CO 1 i c EEl Day S C b I 1 J 1 74 S Mm Street J j t1 J rfl J Iml 7 i r cl 1 = = J L = tt j n It ltL l = tJ J = Z J I = r llr21t oz r T Gr c rti r r t W L Jt J < I Pj m 1Jod SALT PALACE GRAND AUTUMN CA NIV ALONE AL-ONE SOLID WEEK OF FUN COM 1ENC NG MONDAY SEPT 4 A GRAND AND GLORIOUS SEASON OF GLADNESS in which the masses will mingle in the festivities revelries and amusements amuse-ments ox this BIG FALL FESTIVAL I A MULTITUDE OF ATTRACTIONS SHOWS AND SPECIAL FEATURES for the amusement nnd pastime of all Brilliant Electric Displays Georgcous Decorations I Entrancing Music Startling Sensations The Great Roman Stadium Ten Big Free Attractions Five Splendid Features Fifteen HighClass Moral Shows Ride the Camels the Ferris Wheel the Barrel of Love the Steam Gondolas GEE WHIZ WHOOP HER UP Athletic and Gymnastic Tournaments Special Days and Nights Skilled Trado Contests Sensational Novelties ADMISSION TO THE GROUNDS if 1 IfJ Special low excursion rates on all 11 C I I it I J railroads 1 C J t l PIcIl Qii It J to1J1 I c s r 080 nIDD fIGUIi rJ 9 0 Dont spend a lot of time trying to find a competent t I J compe-tent firm to look after your PLUMBING WORK J U Come direct to us and R L get our estimate youll Trri be immensly pleased at our prices and our workmanship P J MORAN Boardof Trade do 1JAkL1y 1 Building J SALT LAKE CITY UTAH r4 O O < OOO v i DIAMONDS i We have the goods jf they can be had anywhere i When it comes to prices we treat our customers right C Examine our goods and be convinced i LICHTENSTEIN i JEWELER O A S 214 MAIN ST OPPOSITE KENY02 HOTEL wM3 e O OOOH Q A I IY = i I Get the BOY I Ready fr SchooL I r lliirclly possible that afler a Summers siege of hard knocks the boys wardiobo is i in lit i I hhape for school AVr > invite pnvcnU to some extremely good clothing bargains low prices on the kind of suit haft will 1 give groan service rive your boy the benefit of the sort hat is built I to stand wear and lour i 7 50 ViII huy the boy n good looking 40 l1it I of lulahle material thai t will surprise you ou account of its being suck a goed suit for so little money Q CA Will buy a splendid suit made 4 v S tJw and made well in right every 1 say and good enough for anybodys boy 1 CF t 5 AA Will I buy a fine suit of more exp I LJctJJ ex-p llsir material a little more fineness and a little more elegance thrown in thats all EYEKY SUIT IS A GOOD ONE I Money back if you want it Bring the boy here t for his School Suit I m 1 Rowe Kelly Co 1 The eicth1 errs 1 n32 Main St r i r1r T t II Jtl I For pure Starch IPC have nothing to compare Ivitft i i KNSFORDS OSWEGO I j i CORN STARCH and it may be used in some dish daily Ivitliont monotony It is capable of infinite bariely in preparation and is both inexpensive and easy to tlstlir Helen l1rmstrollf u 12I i I I 1 J l1 r 7fr tJ Ir T ri Our jjj1j 1kii at Department Is filled with the newest shapes for this season The styles of the most famous Hatters in the country are here including the wellknown JOHN B STETSON I COS 400 and 500 Hats and YOUNGS 300 HATS the acknowledged leaders of New York styles AYe give you the t choice of the best styles in the country at a price as small as you would pay elsewhere for ordinary Hats In both stiff and soft Hats you will find a variety that will enable you to select A Becoming Style Without Trouble Stilt Hats will be shaped to your head without extra charge Our new IALL AND WINTER CLOTHING has arrived l ar-rived and is brimming full with good things Call and see theJna pleasure to show you NICOL CRABBE CO jLa V2ty Vtxda < fSrPytL > v ay 220 MAIN ST I SOLE AGENTS FOR STEINBLOOH CLOTHING = = J t D ic DOGTORS WHO CURE ItATARRH Note und Throat Tror qs I bko NtitTonn Dlioucn 3j t ii Itlilnor ned LiTer Ulaoasos nindrtcr Trou i f 4f4 bloc HoirtDlacore IMociccsof UcHtomaob 5 ff i unil Bowel Pllcu Klutula and Itcotul Ul t W c13 ccfiscs iccmlo Complftlnls Clironla 11 rJ BOVJCB ot Women anti Children Ulcoii 1 i i Bplual Troubc3 Sklu Ulscaicx DciUnusa I 4 J Autumn Bronclilnl sail Lung Trouble 4 b Rheumatism HilT Paver Neuralgia Iljn i ci i r lena Uo anil Ear nicovioi Goltro Cor bx I c aNt Vnttcocolu Lost Jlruhocd oc II p Bloon JJIocasei Irlvrvto Uliouco Borofiilo v i jf and all fonna of Kurrous and Chroclo 11 i f1 J ieit3 that nro oiratilc t I l i 32t c 4 OUR MOTTO A lorr foo quick 1 Itt it fD I I euro mild and pi > ln1 < m trrntiiiot pb > f 41 W ouuaJtntloH In person or > > y latter i IJUJHimomirfl froo to all Call or irrltc iitWSt101T3 I HOME OURES BY MAIL no not dopnlr lIccauo ou 110 rt II cHAtllllCa t elt Jrs horci UJJT lVIICtn or JIO I I lltLr nO II ct137 to iCt oxpuri advice immiti irenhmneni born Timnir cow 01010 btai coYcYi over ymptom of dkaa mylmicli onnbl theme to dingnoe your cssu nimil loll you wJt I trobln I wimat otto bo done or you anti wit hum comm of a euro I1I be II Wirr OU atfltC call for tl1llr now ymiitm ibid mind tko 111rnnloo or Ibo h1UF EzA3iiNtLiON V CLttC you tuLo truittuicui or not Ibo udrlco costs you uOL1JD1 j Weak Men Pay When Cured d If yonouOor from any of Ito wuutncjiea or Wo euro TOU Ural nun then ac fc ft rEASOJ dltoasot cnntod by Jirnorajico orcrsi or con A L13 vrB triton OU mo curfil You c11 I J 4 tslon YOU ARK THK VCIIV IKIISON WE jxjnd uuoa our noel tboujatula of l jjivr 9 WANT TO TALK TO IVITO UidoiMd us NOW W i WANl TOWlf Wo luna proon our uklllin our lug CHRONIC YOU with tho dlntliirt nntloron3liiff 1 diseases by pullllilnj tIm mnnr voluntary will not demand n Tlvi unUl cc cuo1 tevUinonlals trom home people ulTlni namoc Tlilo upjilloi Jo Ion Mnuliooil Sisuiliial > W i ploliurs anil nddrcvici JI 53 diormuiorrhocu Vnrlcocelo via c W1S OANT PUBLISH OUR CUBKS limo Proatnio Cl lonll CnruturJl JoScS uv I IN 1KIVATE DISJEASS3 nrhocB Gloct srrlcturt etc CoutaIOI1S mood Ilecauan U would botmr contldonco Hanca C ° 0 g I1ullt r ofn Poliou and all WIZAICSUSSKS of man e KO have to prnra 1 oar 6UIH Iu till clftnx of tree I blui lit uuotlior wax 1hl II i oar plan tultatlOD and ndvtco free Onico Uoiira V 111 nr to < p nii EJontnJl1l1 to 6 Bundars ace Uolhln l ys 10 aoi iou It DBS I SHORES SHORtS Expert Specialists Mtff I < n ut I v v II |