| Show judgment against devine in the case of J J dark clark a member of the fire department against agal nt james devine chief ot of the department com iniss loner sommer yesterday rendered in favor 0 the plaintiff nark bark sued to recover alo 10 the amount lf f a fine assessed against him by the chief for failure to have in his posses pion flon the department rules and alleged that after his suspension from and restoration to the department the book of rules had not been returned t to min the judgment was rendered against chief devine upon the ground taken by the court that the fire and police board had no authority to direct the chief to assess hues flues for breaches brea chea of discipline the chief gave eaic notice of an appeal |