Show BRilliANT ADDRESS Of BORAH ENDED I This Morning Judge Wood Will Charge the Jury r in the Case of William D Haywood Court Room at Boise Again Too Small for the Vast Throng I Seeking Admittance Boise July and ar is at an end and tomorrow L the jury will bo be loft left to do de lide ide what I penalty ir if any WIlliam D 1 aywood shall DaY ay for tor alleged j i In a crimInal consI conspiracy re ill in the tho assassination of former fonner I vernOr Frank with he is charged United States Senator William E Elorah lorah engaged by the state or Idaho s special counsel for the I prosecution the last word tonight Tomor romor l W morning Judge Fremont Wood JI HI charge and instruct the jury is s expected to retire to con ider their verdict about 11 The crowd seeking admission to t the r urt room tonight broke all r records cords 1 a murder trial in Idaho Two hun hundred i dred people remained in the when hen the doors were closed after the die mornIng session and hours before they thay agaIn aU approaches were blocked When finally every s seat at and inch or of space within the court loomas room loom vas as filled several hundred stood on the lawn under the open wIndows that they might catch sentences from the j impassioned pleadings of the young oung I Analysis of Evidence Senator Borah laid the foundation I r his argument last night This he began an analysis or of the theS thel l S but he confined himself to tie murder of and th al aled ged ed conspiracy Ho He linked Orchard Haywood Haywood to SImpkins I to Moyer and Moyer to Pet Peti i one Then selecting only the evi I of witnesses for the defense and andring ring Orchards confession out he we live the lives fives and movements o the j men together Without departing m the record and Incidentally clear 11 I g up B a number of situations lift r clouded he brought these thes tiers and members of the Western F of Miners together Then ll I took Orchard away from Denver 4 lid t d back again to Denver to the head j I ot of the Western Vestern Federation of I I iners This was done car and most monotonously The Quiet be f re the storm Then voice olce iL i nd manner changed He Be sprang Into tion His voice quivering and hand praised fingers outstretched he if Attorney Becomes Dramatic Watch them now Watch Vatch the five fic Is t to die in hirty days and they are moving on t the scene The dramatic utterance and tense III guro of the pleader sent a thrill through the court room For the space 1 cf f ten seconds there was silence Then I r I Borah continued with his logic logie Ho He brought Davis Cople CODle Adams and Easterly aU all officers or members of the Western Federation of 2 Miners lIners into touch with Orchard Without a pause he drew I picture after picture of the men associating together at va various various rious points From oath each place and am fresh 1 om em every crime he brought Or OrI Orchard I chard back home to Denver Denyer and then tIler smiling leaned towards his jury to t task ask Why Why Alwa S back to Den Denver ver Unless it was to find there the thu prot protection tion and the tho pay Day or of hIs employ ers All those things denounced or oi sneered at by counsel for the defens found a bold and brilliant paragraph ot of defense In Senator inter ludes and coun counsel el for the defense were driven into a murmur of I protest now under the lash or of I pointed sarcasm and am again when under a tirade of indignant reproach culture Christianity law and anc order refinement the home and the thu country found a ready The Th state or of Idaho Its people and its chief executive each in turn were giver given I brIlliant eulogy Haywood Show No Emotion Under It all himself was wa perhaps the one man In the room who wh showed the least emotion At his face flushed and more than once under the tao attack as Boran Borah reach ing the climax Jr f the conspiracies pointed an accusing finger at the man who he said was the criminal force behind the Western Federation lif ers era Mrs Irs wIdow or of the dead governor attended the morning ses session session sion but left early almost b by the emotion awakened by vivid oratory mother mothel also left lett the court room in tears but soon returned to take her accustomed place beside the invalid wife Senator peroration was do de livered In Quiet almost pleading tones In strong contrast to the harsher v voice In which he spoke or of Clarence Dar Dat Darrows rows argument or of justification If he said the state has painted out to YOU the tho men who were con concerned concerned in and executed this awful crIme then In the name of th the man hood and the womanhood of Idaho do your duty without fear or of any man or fa favor VOl to an any man manAs manAs As I listened to the eloquent voice ice c Cf counsel pleading for their client I there came to me the memory or of an another another other scene and another time I ye re remembered again that night In dark December in n night that added ten years to the lives or of some hero In this room I felt a again aln the icy fey chill and faced the drifting sleet eject And nd I stood again beside the body of my dead friend whose lifeblood stained the snow Continued on Page 2 BRilLIANT ADDRESS ur GE I S BORAH ENDED NOID tJ from Irom Page 1 11 1 l foiL tl ih the th had ohIO tu U I lw tt it mm man th that t tn mOta th ti fr it t tnt nt th bl W an r Hy had at my state And on that nIght I said to myself can time the IE esin Sn ot thiS hour Lt us rh then n be brave in this su rr mo moment If the defendant Is then let him go free but If not then let him take th the punishment the law You have a higher dut duty to perform than tv ever r was asked of ti 11 jury In Idaho Some of you have the test In the past in protection of your L rc ics and nd your our flag but ou have ner faced a duty that required a aNu Nu r courage than now In very every home in Idaho the thought ft Ct our people are arc with you of the tho things thing that made those hom homes possible and In every throughout thIs broad rand land mi md women tonight look to you as the thet t I n who for the right and the fi g gAt At A the of Senator ad md and the th adjournment of court ite he surrounded and congratulated by T everyone in the court ms l for the defense Both Families Present As Nul early as 7 oclo k the e orrs wre by hundreds seeking to tie limited courtroom Sen Senn Sena n a r Borah beIn popular as an orator In th t his home borne city So great reat was the tho that court ourt officials and others business at the trial had to find their way war Into the building b by devious T II 5 most of th them m clImbing ing a steep im r stairway In the rear The Tho jury brought up these steps Ird the court KS as the next to the last LJ If f the trial trIai began 1 sat r rr b by his fa family mil His Invalid whose condition and f r f han attracted so much attention and ands anda s a mathy sat Mt at his right righta a 1 to her was the IT Ii th who on yesterday could not re tT t n the teats tears which welled to her eyes etS Darrow of Chicago made the plea for Jor the life of her son The laught and sister were ere also b famil family circle the on only 1 absentee lc ng thc little girl Mrs Irs Frank the tho wire wife ot of t 1 governor and her stalwart m son Julian were early In the courtroom and when they had been to seats Inside the attorneys rail themselves seven or eight fet Icet Hawood Hanood Attorneys from many man iu itIS s In the est have come to 10 Boise BoisA for the last arguments and con a large proportion of big When the last t seats were O cu cur r If d disappointed hundreds remained on the courthouse lawn to cat catch h what they or of Senator address as ag the words filtered out of the open windows Borah began by reviewing brief v th the points made in the opening hour hout f his address t the jul jury last night He HesaM saM stu hf he would go briefly over the trail C t f bloOd by Harry Orchard taking lust first the of and harking back OVer some ot of the most Important incidents developed in the tea tes 1 1 hardly neE need to tell you ou sensible men dc Eared the pleader der that de dete te 1 had to do with the as of Frank That 13 inO ne of If the most absurd of the many ab thinks brought Into this case by the h 1 counsel of the defense Borah In laying the foundation f fr r his argument of conspiracy pointed ct Jt that Orchard went to Caldwell from and fr fresh sh from association with the officers of the Western estern Federation C f Miners lIners who regarded a aIH as IH enemy ThEn he touched upon the fact that Marian Moore Ire an officer ot of the theester Westeri ester Federation of Miners In testify for tor the defense admitted that lie he ed with Orchard to deceive Orchards wife when Orchard wished to dEsert her Harr Harry Orchard left Denver with crime in his hEart The Impelling compelling came from Denver Demer George Petti Pettibone Lone bone helped Orchard pack his utensils of murdEr In hf trunk Why is Pettibone not he here re to den deny it His silence Is a con of his guilt gunt absence Is tn an absolute corroboration ot of Orchard Question of Personal Motive Taking up the Question of the personal motive the defense had urged against Orchard Senator Bomb Borah showed to the Juno the hf deed b by which Orchard had part parted ed sJ absolutely and forever with his Inter Interest est cat In the Hercules mine fourteen months General Merriam and his marched Into the Coeur This deed the leU letters rs the telegrams i and all other evIdence nce not subject iO ao I t ing tampered with in this case rate Harr Harry Orchard and fit In precisely the stor story he has told you Governor did not cause Orchard to lose losel l Lis s Interest In the mine so how could coul hp ho have entertained Ii a murderous 1 grudger grudge Borah took up one b by one th the for the defense who he said corroborated Orchard and proved a crim crimInal ma Inal conspiracy because the they hal had covered and nd protected Orchard up to the time he confessed anti and Haywood Among these were Bill the member of the Western estern Fed Federation of Miners who heard Orchards threats and to whom Orchard telephoned from Cald Caid before the murder w V F Davis the president of the he V Yest eat frn Fed mUo 1 of Miners local who heard Orchard make threats a against St and who swore the passing of f the armed and masked mob In pos pea 5 sl or of train dId nut not interest him wll u II ho a It David o tes tile the governor cit t Ct CO and an tiC or the Western Federation ot lUn MinOrs rs whom Orchard discussed the stealing of child Lottie Da Day who was introduced to Haywood Hawood by Orchard and who saw Or Orchard Orchard chard and Haywood In private consulta consultation tion Engley an Anarchist General Eugene Engley the former at attorney attorney torney general or of Colorado who of all ail allmen men an officer of the law should not have kept these direful threats a secret locked within his breast when ahen the state of Idaho was looking for evidence ah against Orchard the suspect But said Senator Borah Borab General Engley does not believe In law He Is not even a Socialist lie he Is an anarchist You heard the tho speech he made hero here In the wit witness witness ness chair Nobody could stop it With w itil such men as Engley In office I Iam Iam am not surprised that Colorado has had hell within her borders for the past ten years Thu senator next read effectively to the jury the articles denouncing In the Miners magazine There Is much talk here and In the argument of counsel about an Industrial i war waro There Is an industrial war but It ItIs Itis Is for you ou men to determine whether In Industrial industriaL warfare shall be carried out un on the principle of murder The defense tells you that outside of Orchards testimony there is nothing hero here hereto to prove a conspiracy What hat more do you ou want We Va put Orchard an and Simpkins and Moyer and Haywood and Pettibone to together gether In Denver Now Nov watch them as they move to the scene of Frank bergs berss murder Briefly Senator Borah showed the I friendship existing among the quintet I Then he hurled at the jul jury the letter which Orchard said he received from Pet Pettibone Pettibone at Friend was sent to Jack this How exclaimed Senator Borah did Pettibone Know that Orchard under the name of Tom Hogan was Wag at Caldwell Caidwell Why did Haywood send a draft ot of lOO Joo to Jack Simpkins on December 21 Has Pettibone come here to say a word as asto s sto to this Now watch tho coconspirators how quickly the they net act Scarcely had the news of Tom Hogans arrest been flashed to the world than attorneys for the West Vest Vestern era ern no Miners flocked Into Caldwell from three directions S Unexplained Cipher Telegram Jack Simpkins was the man who went to s se Attorney Miller at Spokane Ja Jack k Simpkins was the man who sent the mys ms mysterious and cipher tf telegram legram to Haywood The wording of Simpkins telegram Senator Borah declared that he knew Haywood had full knowl knowledge knowledge edge of the case And Haywood got busy S l Follow ollow Simpkins Orchard Moyer Haywood and Pettibone from Denver to the death leath of at Caldwell re review view yiew the testimony watch their actions and I say to you that an absolute and concerted conspiracy has been proven The They killed to show to the world that the they never forgot an enemy here Is to speak Where here is Jack Simpkins who was at Cald Caldwell well welI with Orchard and could coul tell so much lIe Is in a corner and afraid to come to sa Say a word for his lifelong friends Senator Borah said he was ready to ad admit admit mit that Haywood was shrewd keen anil possessed of brains Of course he has brains he exclaimed He had brains enough to start a defense of the Western Federation of Miners lIners the minute he learned th thit t Orchard the hired assassin had fallen Into a trap Did the Pinkertons send anybody to defend Orchard Did the Mine lUne Owners No It was the Western estern Federation of Miners Bradley Explosion Answering at great length the theory theolo of the defense that attempts on the life or of Fred Bradley at San FrancIsco were and not the design ot of Orchard Senator Borah pointed out that the latter moved mOed directly from Denver to San Fran Francisco Francisco cisco He traced the movements or of Or 01 Orchard chard In San Francisco and ridiculed the theory theon of a gas explosion And cried Senator Borah when Orchard gets read ready to leave San Francisco where does docs he go Back to Denver What hat for To get his money The deed was done the pay paO was due At 12 a recess was ordered until 6 p ui m Final Effort At G 6 Senator Borah commenced the last stage of his argument with the that he would conclude to tonight tonight night lie He d devoted voted himself at first to the prop proposition of the defense that Orchard was wasa a Pinkerton detective Far from having any such connection as that the senator Insisted that Orchard through four ears of crime and conspiracy was loyal to the Western Vestern Federation of Minors lIners and the leaders of the organization If Orchard had had any sinister motive against Moyer loyer Haywood or Pettibone If It had been his purpose to gather evidence against them he had almost unlimited opportunity to do so But on the con contrary contrary It ft had been shown that every piece ot of evidence which came into Orchards hands was destroyed by him even een to the letter received from George A Pettibone In the Caldwell jail Never at an any time did Orchard undertake to build up a case against the defendant Haywood or any of his associates Alleged Crimes oin in Colorado briefly the Colorado tion Senator Borah Borab said auld the crimes and disturbances In Cripple Creek and Tel Telluride Telluride luride were brought Into the case ly h to show the motive the conspiracy the cum com combination and the understanding which finally led to the murder of The jury |