Show STATE FAIR SILK CASE Committee Com Decides Against Mr Lyle lile Because Protest Was Not Filed In Time V V Mrs Margaret Marga et A Caine Calne won but in inthe Inthe the he t silk contest between her and anti John Lyle on oo what in football f U would be le called c a II fluke The TIle executive con com S of the State Fair association i met Wt t yesterday and decided that Mr Lyle had not protest pr against aust the he t awards In proper peeper time thu e e and that iM i for f ft or that reason re the executive M tee t ee could nake no urn no change in the i awards made by b the judges and this leaves l eaven the a 46 36 In ill prizes with Mrs Cain Caine At the same fame time they ex cx expressed j pressed sed themselves to the effect that 1 had Mr Lyles protest been filed in time ime t the case ease might have gone dif f The committee composed ed of ef President Nelson Nel on A Empey John Jehn H V White Moses W Taylor J C Cutler and J G 0 McDonald McDona has hag been wrestling g with this problem i ever evel since the fair tair I closed A month ago a hearing was j given the contesting parties and their 1 witnesses u and then the case wag taken i IV under advisement Yesterday the oem com committee V j r met in Ia the office of Secretary S I W Sears and decided the case cue as ai above stated V By this decision Mrs Caine Calne gets the 15 prize for the best beat exhibit of silk sUk including i cocoons reeled silk and manufactured silk although Mr l r Lyle still stilT maintains that he made the piece of silk that drew the prize and sold it I t to Mrs JerrI Caine after drawing a prize on it himself at the state fair of at 1950 Mrs Caine Calne also retains the 20 O prize given by the Z C M I for the bast best fifty yards of silk lk manufactured in Utah from Utah produced silk al although although a though Mr Lyle maintains that th t there were not fifty yards in the lot It is perhaps the most awkward and complicated question that ever came before the executive committee of the organization organisation The decision is especially ally J unsatisfactory to Mr Lyle be because because because cause of the fact that he was assured by Secretary Sears at the time his protest was filed that it was in proper form and in proper time 4 r |