Show USES HIS OFFICE TO 10 COMBAT FOES I City Attorney Dininny Does This Says Chief of Police Barlow Ban ow FIGHT OVER SALOONS HEATED SESSION OF 01 LICENSE COMMITTEE OP OF COUNCIL That City Attorney H J 1 Dininny IB is I using Ills his office to combat old foes and to pay a political debt of ot the last cam campaign campaign campaign was charged by Chief of ot Police PoUce Sam M tL Barlow yesterday afternoon at nt atthe atthe the special meeting of tho the license com corn committee In the tho city council chamber Livid with rage because of ot the poUt political politimi ical imi talk of the city attorney and shak shaking shakIng shakIng ing with suppressed emotion Chief Bar Barlow Barlow low declared that shortly after alter the elec election ion tion last fall Dininny had come Into his office and assorted he ho would use his of or office orrice office fice rice to get oven oen with prominent mem mern members members bers bern of oC tho the Knights of ot the Royal Arch who had knifed him In the campaign Ill use my office for the next two years to get even with them Is what Dinino said in talking about tho the Royal Arch to o the tho chief in tho the private office of ot Barlow So bitter did the feeling become that thata a clash was only averted by Chief Barlow Barlo when whon Charlie Murphy one ono of or ortho the tho saloon men started after City At Attorney Attorney torney torne Dininny During the tho midst of ot the excitement Councilman M L E K Mul Mulvey Mulvoy vey voy ve who stands accused by tho the city attorney of or violating the tho law la as all a sa nfl saloon gl loon man asked to be excused and left lert the meeting with Murphy Tho The result of the meeting was W S that all of the 14 licenses wore approved and will be sent ent to the city elty council Monday night with the tho letter of ot the tho city Attorney The Tim breach between members of ot the tho American party which has been con constantly constantly constantly widening went far apart when the open charge was made and not de do denied denied nied by tho the city attorney that the tho fight was wan being made by him against prom prominent promInent prominent members of ot the tho lie Knights of or tho the Royal Roal Arch an organization of ot saloon men and that other violators of ot the thela law la were not being brought Into the controversy y by tho the city attorney The city attorney did say I Y however that he hewan was wan fighting in tho the interest of ot the American party part Charge Chance Law Violation In the Dininny letter to the license committee ho charged law violations against Frumkin Goulet South Main street M lL iL E Mulvey 12 2 East Bast Sec See Second Second ond South street A Fred Wey We proprietor proprietor proprietor etor of ot the Wilson hotel C N Murphy of ot the tho Wellington hotel and G S So Holmes of the Knutsford hotel All have applications before the city council for renewals renewal of their licenses with 10 oth others others ers The whole batch wont went before the council at Its last session sos lon but wore were sent sont back balk to the license committee so o that tho the city attorney could protest against the five fIe named claiming they thoy had been guilty of oC selling liquor after midnight and anti before 6 or that booths were wore maintained In connection with the sa an saloons saloons loons bonn For Good of ot the Party That he ae believed the law should be upheld was the statement of tho the city attorney when the tho matter came before a full fun meeting of the committee All AU of or orthe the saloon Baloon men named by Dininny were also on hand as well as some attorneys representing them City Attorney Din Dininny DinI inny may declared that last Monday night I he had paid for and received drinks from the Mulvey bar and from Murphys I Ibar bar In the Wellington hotel Also AlBo he declared some saloon I loon men even after the tho passage of ot the present license ordinance ordinance nance nanco had so arranged the partitions in their saloons that it was impossible Impo to see the inside of oC the saloon at any anytime anytime anytime time He lie said Bald his protest was in the interest of or the American party part partA A Fred Wey Woy Ye declared Dininny was not a true friend because of ot his actions In thus bringing the matter before the council Instead of ot going to the tho men per pcr personally personally and telling them they were not strictly conforming to the statutes I 1 am surprised to hear that It tt Is for r the good god of ot the tho American party that this matter mater is being aired said Mid Mr Ir Woy Wey 1 I thought the city el attorney was moved by some other othor cause cuse and It pains me deeply to hear what ho says I thought he lie would do It I for the tho good of the whole people or because these thee things were wore against the tho law la And I ask you Mr Dininny why you did not come to me rue melike melke like a man and tell ten me mo that certain things were not right You Tou fall fail faUto to come como to me for support in the last campaign We Wo all an have lae families and wo we wedo do not care to have these those matters made public I am willing to live Jve up to the tho law as a well wen as W anyone but I do o not like this way w of bringing the tho matter out out It I hurts hur me deeply Barlow aro Domb DombI It I was then that the bomb was fired tIred It I came from Chief Clet of Police Sam M lL Barlow and reflected the breaking po political situation which has been wrought up through the to campaign of or the tho city at attorneys attorneys office of nee I want to say a few fow words in regard to all an this business said the chief I 1 notice that the men named here hero by tho the thool city ol attorney are aro high hl h up In the Royal Arch And since Judge Dininny has ha Arc brought In the matter mater of ot politics I 1 will Ul Ulo go o Into the matter mater also Just before the tile election Assistant City Attorney Daly came camo Into my office and showed me one of ot the tho printed cards which the Knights of the Royal Arch had print printed ed for support in which was omitted the name of Judge Dininny He Ho told me that wo we should get out and use ue our In Influence fluence to save sae tho the city attorney And AndI I 1 did everything possible to support Judge Dininny and have have others support him Then hen Just after the tho election after we had hal pulled him through Judge Din Dininny Inny came Into my office and we were vere discussing the card of ot the Royal Roal Arch He Ho told me Ill Til Il use my office for the next two years to get got even with wih thorn them thor And from that I believe the fight Just now Is against these thee prominent men of ot tho the Royal Arch to gratify that tt political fooling feeling It I is against those thee men and these those alone alone City Attorney Dininny looked looke at the chief without batting an eye and then started to ask It a few Cew questions The chief declared he ho had hd no personal persona knowledge that saloons kept open after ace midnight but said sid he would not be b sur cur surprised surI I priced to learn lern that nearly all al of or them did He Re I also Iso admitted amite that he be did not know that slot Ilot machines are gambling devices Then the city attorney start started rt ed eu asking king about the campaign against the stockade when he was WI interrupted Did Id you sy say IY what the chief says eys you yoa told him asked aked Councilman Mulvey y yIn In effect yes ye said Mid the city attorney attorney ney noy but I did not say 81 I 1 would use ue my m office I said aid I would woul us u use my m lonu Influence ence once to got get even on with you U fellows Then Than hen I suppose tho the men are here who you referred to toYes tor Yes they thoy are aro You Tou and an Murphy and andO Charlie Charle Murphy by that tt time had started toward the te city olt attorney but bt Chief Barlow was between tb them m and arid stopped him him himo Too roe o Hot for Mulvey Mulvey declared lie he could stand It no n longer and an asked to be excused from tho the meeting Ho lIo and an Murphy left lert Then tho the remaining four councilmen on the committee John ohn B Moreton Mark Reedal W C C Lyne Lyric and l Itt Bd O G ODonnell ODonnel approved the 12 licenses licensee and passed tho the matter mattor up to the council The Tho license of W J 1 1 which had been Included Include In the bun bunh h but bt had never neer gone to the tho council counci was Wa taken out at the tire suggestion of ot the city attorney attore and a new flOW application must be made and filed fe with wih the city recorder and then with the tho council counci Mark Rooan declared decare that from his own observation he was wa certain that tt at least 95 96 per cent cont of or the saloons of ot Salt Lake were guilty of keeping their places open opan until after midnight but bt did not see ace why those five should be bo singled out by b the city attorney |