Show GARLAND TOWN LOSES SUIT i Supreme Court Denies Application for Writ of Mandate on Ques Question Question I tion of Jurisdiction The supreme court of Utah yesterday denied an nn application for or writ of man mandate mandate mandate date asked on behalf of o the town of Garland in Box Elder county against Judge W W Maughan to require him to set aside an order dismissing an ap appeal appeal appeal peal and to reinstate a case and hear hearit it on its merits Costs were ordered against tho tha town The case casc was against Joseph Orgil and John F Owens who were Mere charged In itt the justices court of Box Elder Eider pro pre precinct on July Jub 28 20 9 1808 1908 with a breach of the town ordinances They The were ar arrested arrested arrested rested tried and found guilty A fine with costs t imposed but Jut they ap 1 to the tile Box Elder Ehler district court courton on oil the grounds of or no jurisdiction and anti that the facts did not constitute a tL pub public public lic lie offense Judge sustained the motion for dismissal on ott the first ground and the w writ rit of mandate inundate t was asked The town of Garland is in Sunset pre duet but believing that the justice of that precinct was In collusion with the th offenders the tile complaint was as taken be bp for f fore the tile justice of Box Bo Elder precinct The supreme court ourt holds that such cases must be tried in the th justice court of the precinct in which the town is sit situated situated situated and that Judge JudAe Maughan was right rl ht In ruling that In this case there thet was no jurisdiction juri of the Box Elder justice |