Show Though Exonerated Murder Is Charged Mrs l M. M Lynch Talented Utah Musician l Begins Fight 1 9 to Defeat Requisition Papers Issued by Texas Governor in n Strange Case D 0 D 0 DC C with wit first d degree murder ur under circumstances stances said lid to be without with- with CHARGED C J out but parallel at a bar of justice Mrs l M. M Lynch of Ogden talented music musician an orchestra leader former wife of an army officer began in Salt Sal Lake yesterday before acting Governor Harden Bennion a battle to thwart the attempted d coup of a a- county attorney in Texas The strangest feature of the case presented by the womans woman's attorney in m a n plea to deny leny the requisition signed by the Texas governor go is a n telegram from the district attorney advising that if Sirs Mrs Lynch returns voluntarily the indictment against her will rill be bo withdrawn and she will be used simply witness against ng others accused of the crime a brutal double murder as IS a t I I I Aff A to tn the h testimony and Alter II ne I ar arguments In the c unprecedented le leI legal I aspect o of the case acting Governor Bennion announce announced that ho was Unable unable unable un un- able to rule at once but would hand nd down his decision at nl 9 o'clock this in morning 0 ru I ii g Lynchs Lynch's attorney declared that thata a jury at a preliminary hearing hearing- in county count Texas where tho the crime was committed had exonerated the woman entirely from blame soon after the tho tragedy and that now noVo to place her in Jeopardy even nominally w would uld be contrary to all lc legal al ples cs Sf Separates Separate From band The stor story as narrated to the tho acting two years ago governor go began About Lynch accompanied b by her when Mr Mrs army of officer icer husband left lct Ogdon Ogden where they were married for Texas differences arose upon their arrival there which resulted in a i. i separation Then Mrs Irs Lynch went vent to Ranger and Texas lexas where she had relatives as a musician being being be be- soon her qualities shoo sho was engaged as ing recognized orchestra leader of an Mrs Lynch was a a. popular young woman and at nt her home many parties of tho younger s sOt set t wore were held On lh the tho evening of October 18 iS of last year ear eara at ather ather ather people gathered a a. party of ot young oung her home There came caine two uninvited young men and they also were welcomed welcomed wel wel- corned b by the hostess Find In Coat arrival differ differ- Soon a after ter their a a. I Continued on page 2 OGDEN WOMAN FACES fA t e t CHARGE Of MU tI t I Continued from Crom Page C 1 I. I ence of or opinion arose between the late arrivals and some me of or those who had ha hi preceded them The two men Leon Leo Wilson and Alphonso Alphonse Barnes Barnell declined decibel to remain and amid tho time hostess Mrs Irs Lynch Lynch In handing their wraps wraps wraps' to them Dis Discovered l covered a revolver in the pocket of ot th the overcoat belonging to Wilson She to look look k kIt It ou out before beloro handing him the coat co q Wilson so the story goes goe missed th t gun and requested its return At considerable badinage the revolver w whan wis han handed ed him hint t ill Immediately it Is alleged he point pointed the weapon at one of or the three me men e who Were In the tho room and fired killing kU kill killing oth othe in ing Carl Gallagher instantly The two men ran to the tho rescue of or f thel then A friend when another shot was W w. w ire and George Shiner fell tJI to the n floor nr r fatally wounded A third shot wa 1 Deming J receive a fired Ired and 1 F according to Mr r rLyn neck bullet In the Lyn Lynch h m I i th that followed In the excitement thO tin dono done t two men alleged to have o y shooting ns- ns escaped hearing It ft I At the preliminary J the j jur ur t Mrs Irs Lynch contended b by tb lb and ana her exonerated i completely P pair t o others hers who were ere in the ordinal party in t i complicity at itt her hor home from an any 9 J slaying sl not even on Mrs s Lynch was It is id said t 4 to o Later er Mr Mrs Lynch left Ranger wit wither fOgden t f tO O Ogden den whore where she hll has since the been men Yo 1111 her parents ct d n of Meanwhile the killing have be bee e u. u pu p pout cu the ou out under hea heavy bond bo nd for When trial J lIr wnm called recently o 0 officials law the Lynch wa was asked by y and tho Limo Texas city to 0 go o there but she Rile declined Col fo Co f correspondence Considerable stat slat l lowed when it was definitely It that Mrs Irs Lynch would not resin indictment was har P declared that an char charIng cured through h a grand jury jur f Ct d d. d the with murder In Ing her 9 gree grce was m made dc to 4 the b g go 4 Application for tor a Eta of Texas reta the tho h T f for the governor o o of Utah or g theof the CB on of ot Mrs r Lynch to Ranger of mur murder er V h Hague ague IT- IT I put e. e dep Yesterday Joseph V Tew n TeXas rai a ar county Eastland eIth sheriff of or h h rived In III S Salt L Lake kc presented a armed ned to toh i a aIn act requisition which he J In Ing Governor summoned She Mrs Lynch was N N. NGor G ge Motif forI Attorney e represented br blo statement of who presented her s corresPond telegraphic th i and the and t wl with th the attorney general g jj irl ii |