Show I I II STATE ATTEMPTS TO 10 SHOW HYDE I II I INAS WAS NAS SHOT TWICE I Clarence Livingston to Take fl Stand in Own Omi Defense I f Today PROSECUTION ENDS TS CASE CASEI I I II I Witness Testifies She Heard ly i God Dont Don't Then Second Shot I An effort to show how that Arthur Arlhur Hyde nde was fas twice shot b by Clarence rence Livingston once In the back and md once In tho front part of ot the n neck on ot the morning of oC December r 26 6 wa was made IJ by the state state yesterday ro In the preliminary hearing of ot Livingston before Justice of ot the tho Peace Puce Frank B. B Scott Tim state also Introduced d as witnesses wit wit- nesses neighbors who told of ot the clr- clr of ot th tho shooting It concluded concluded concluded con con- its case caso yesterday esterday aft afternoon Livingston ston introduced ono onu witness se and will go BO on the stand tan In hI his own behalf today I 1 think this Otis i Is a good s Job We have been bothered with prowlers too much lat lately ly was tho the statement credited to Livingston b by Desk Sergt William M. M f. f who rol said ho mado Lh the remark at sit tho the police station after th the tho shooting Dr Walter Scott Keyting who waRthe was waR the tho second witness called described 11 three wounds one In the back a short distance below the neck another in the front part of or the neck and a third where the undertaker had made an Incision Ent Enters Enter r Hack Dock He stated that the bullet hullet that entered entered entered en en- tho ho back had passed through the upper part of ot the right lung and shattered shattered shattered shat shat- one rib He said an X ray picture picture pic pie ture had failed to locate the bullet that entered the back He H also said that he lie could not see seelOW how bow lOW the wound In the tho front of ot the neck could have been made otherwise than b by a n bullet David A A. A Johnson a steward steward steward stew stew- ard at tho the emergency hospital later hater told taM of ot removing the bullet from the wound In the nock Jck Policeman I L. L L L. Larsen said the bullet froth from the tho neck ck had been extracted butt en end first that Is Is with tho the nose noso pointing Inward Inar It developed from the testimony that there was wae no bullet mark on tb U front of ot tho collar and no powder marks marls on the front of ot th the th neck or on the collar On rigid examination cross Dr Ke Keyting Keyting Key Key- ting said it was har hardly ly possible that the wound In front of ot the neck had been made by the bullet that penetrated penetrated pene pene- the tho back The Tho fact was as developed and left heft unexplained unexplained unexplained un un- un- un explained that the bullet to enter the front of ot the neck would have had to togo togo togo go through the collar and front of ot the shirt but that it did lid not do so Detective Story tory Joseph E. E Sharp chief of ot detectives who was ivas the first witness called told of ot the summoning of ot the police b by i Livingston the tho arrival of or the bod body the arrest and release of ot Livingston He repeated Livingston's ston's stor story to him of ot othow how ow he ho had bad seen a a. a. a man at the window and had shot Hyde Hyde- Livingston Sharp said Bald told him that he first shot at Hyde when hen ho lie was fifty feet away awny after he h had called upon Hyde to stop and ho he had failed to do doBO doso o oso so BO that he ho thought be he had fired over o his hie head and that he fired a n. 6 second ond shot upon which Hyde Hydo dropped to one knee Policeman George Gcorge Harris told of ot an answering an- an the summons to go co for tor the body and of ot being han handed ed a revolver re b by Livingston with Ith two empty shells In it Neighbors who testified for tor the state concerning what they boy observed cd at the time of or the shooting were Earl D D. Pearson of ot Seventh avenue Charles E. E Norine Korine of ot 6 3 Seventh So avenue Mrs Dais Daisy B. B Norine Joseph Harris of ot J street Mrs Irs Roso floso Miller of ot Seventh avenue onue Mark MarIe Bench of Seventh avenue Mrs Rose Harris of ot J 3 street John R P. R. R Cotter of ot Seventh i avenue venue John Joltn T. T Dick of ot 33 J street Mrs Fred of 3 J street Mrs J. J T. T Dick of ot J street The only witness for the defense defene was n wasi i Fred G. G a street car conductor tor who told of observing a man at the Livingston LI window and of ot notifying Livingston of ot the fact You Tou looked Into the wrong window this time Pearson testified he heard beard Livingston say a He lie also heard Mrs Irs Livingston eay say Dont take tae him himIn In Inthe Several Se of or the tho the house witnesses ald said the they heard both Loth Livingston and anel hia wife say n that Hyde was WM not hUrbut hurt hUr but was only playing drunk My husband is a sheriff and he had hada D. D right ht to shoot hoot Mu I Miller lIller said she heard Mrs Livingston say lIay Mrs Harris heard a voice say Shut up Mrs Irs Dick said that after aCter she sho heard the first shot she eho heard some one ono sa say M My God dont don't and In then heard tho the second shot Khot Tho The words are ringing in m my cars ears yet et she said |