Show I t I SENATE NA TE HA HAS LIVELY UVEl Y i. i WRANGLE ON MAilER MAM MA Of UTAH MATERIALS I I Decides by Vote That Resolution Resolution tion lion Might Be Construed as Slap at Commission t parliamentary tangle and a a. lively ely debate werE pro prologues 1 i In ti tho senate t to the killing of or Senator D D. Hideouts Hideout's concurrent resolution Q o. o recommending tho usa of oC utah mal materialS mate mate- p rials raS so 30 far as n practicable In the construction construction con con- 0 of ot the state capitol The resolution came camo before betor the sellI senate senate sen sell I ate atc as amended by b tho th tim committee on tate state affairs and federal c ral relations which tacked lacked on a n. clause submitting utmost confidence of ot the tho legislature legisla J I th nij In the state capitol commission t ture ture nother amendment I h by Senator I I. I B. B recommended the us use of ot Utah uta r materials so Uso far as practicable Inc in- in c pd d of pC so SO far as possible su killed The proposition was finally hv 1 a vote otc of oC 12 to 4 Senators Benner Bennel b bY and George Georgc J. J Kelly being i X v smith abSent and not voting The adv adverse senators were Booth Ed l Ferry err Lunt Olson Funk punk Hansen Iverson I Thornier hOrnier Wight Ight Williams and Gardner Those who voted for tor forthe forthe the dent lent resolution were Craig Eckersley t Hideout and Cottrell who had moved to take It from the table Senator Cottrell made his molion mo- mo When hen voted favorably lion ilon eleven senators but President Gardner ruled that the I II motion notion was wag lost because eleven cleven was wag I two-thirds two of or the members of the tho not ot nate One senator was absent nt and hast scan- scan not ot voting There was tas a hasty nine of oC the rules b by several solons salons I Senator A. A L. L Booth thereupon produced produced pro pro- pro pro-I Roberts Roberts' rules of oC order from stipulation that a I I which he lie derived ed a majority can take a a. t measure from flom the table jable Roberts' Roberts rules prevail pre in the I 7 Senator Booth had J read ad the the passage In Indicted by Mr Mt 11 Roberts and had nad received encouragement In his stand tand from Senator Cottrel CoLtrell and others j r President Gardner reversed th the j decision decision deci deci- sion zion of oC tho the chair permitting tho the resolution rosa reso lution to bo ho taken from the table and andI v come cume before the senate S Senator Booth I I Ij subsequently voted against the re tion 1 t Senator tor L. L 1 M. M Olson made maae a speech against tho resolution lIe He said he J didn't know members rs of o the capitol commission so was read ready to believe that they were vere all fine men Passage of oC the resolution asserted the senator front from Sanpete would be saying to tho governor and the capitol commissioners commission commission- ers era Wo Wa know lenow you ou are arc fine tine fellows and all that but we dont don't trust you Senator Olson added that the native Boris not ons not tho the Indians but sons of ot th the first white settlers the the relief relle societies societies soci soci- eUe Improvement societies young youn peoples peoples' societies and others have given m enough information to the comI commission com com- I should know mission so o that members I what Is wanted without I lions from the legislature le i Senator I I. I I. I B B. B Wight i ht wised raised the same objection to the resolution that he hc had th the da day previous sa saying that recommendation I m to the commission that Utah materials be used and an added f remark that the legislature had tho the greatest confidence in the tho commission I I. I was nE virtually a slap in the tho face of oC that bod body He quoted th the resolution that w we do cia hereby recommend to the capitol capitol capi- capi tol commission that a thorough investigation es be made to ascertain which of oC th the materials to be lie used in th the construction con con- of said building can be bo procured pro pro- V cured from rom the natural r resources source of ot the state etc odd adding I that tho the legislature legis legis- legislature lature had no right to order such an Investigation gatlon Senator D O. O Rideout author of the resolution and ad Senator Charles Cottrill Cott- Cott rill Jr Jr defended it vl vigorously Th ThI Th- Th They 9 I declared red that the resolution was not mandatory that it was fitting that the th capitol be made of ot Utah materials to so 0 far faT as practicable and that the theL L commission could not take offense at j this expression from the legislators l r Inquiry was made b by President Gardner whether the contract for con con- tf of or the capitol had been let it Several senators vouchsafed the Information Information 3 mation matlon that It had bad be been n let lct and arid that f the papers pl were about to be signed ij whereupon hereupon a vote ote was taken on the f t resolution and It was lost |