Show THE TOOELE CHOIR PROTESTS THINKS I OUGHT T H THE PIIZE Which It I Claimed Was Gven to Another On a Technicaity 1 Lit of the Award BeloW will be found a complete list of winners nrizes at the Eisteddfod lat week The Tooele count Chorus makes the following protest in regard to the award in their class The Cambrians have decided to with hodr rather award thq prIze won by the Tooele count Ghoir to another Of the technical grounds that a rule was broken ly Professor Stdphens stepping in and helping to make the required number of 40 voices The justice of this is questioned on the grounds that Mr Stephens pres micp could not possibly have affected nay of the points from which Dr Par Iarded them the prize according to huis statement read at the ElsteddfOl and here reproduced from his book t djudlcatonNote the points first the tempo or speed second blending of voices third em < tonal feeling fourth pianissImo or soft sWing effects fifth c rcmatc difficult harmonies sixth last movement flow and without exaggeration exag-geration seventh free af fauns the whole being a picture of variety and free from all straining for effects We contend that these were points gained by the work of the choir as a whole that would lave been apparent had it not been forced by th lack of numbers t ask for jid and Jhat they are each and ali points which the aid could not have in the least enhanced Fjepce the injustice of awarding the prize to other choir who were pot qual to them in these esseptaJ points EVAN ARTHUR THE AWARDS AS lAD Military l3apd COltesta Lerley Paraphras Nesvndbf b AwhlIc ening of the LionDe Kontski First prize Oj second prize 10 Gold medal to conductor winning frt prize First prize to r nights of Pythias lIitry band of Salt Lake City Pro Anton Pedersen conductor No second sec-ond prize awarded Ladies QuarteteWinds of Even lag Anderson Prize 16 Won by Misses Ella Derr Heroine Tyler Edna Dwyer and Ferron Pipe Organ ContestOberon Over turearrnged by Warren Prize 10 Awarded to Mss Crissie Lawsol of Salt Lake City Orchestral ContestYilam Tel Overture Prize 50 No competition Chidrens Chorus ContestNot less than 75 nor more than 100 voices a Mach chorus Courage Stephens b We Ever Pray for Thee Stephens Steph-ens Best of five choir First prize 25 to conductor Handsome souvenir to each member of successful choir Second prize I t conductor First and second prizes divided equally between be-tween North Side and South Side choirs Sal Lake City Evan Stephens and Viard Christopheron conductors conduct-ors orsMale Chorus ContestTwo entries Chorus not to number less than 35 nor more than 45 voices a The Cru saderProther b UAl Through the NlghtDavies First prize 100 second prize 25 Baton to conductor winning first prize First prize awarded award-ed to the Sal Lake male chorus Prof Evan Stephens condUctor Soprano Solo Contest a 0 Loving Heart Trust Onottchalk b The Dovefrom Songs of Vales Prize 10 awarded to Miss Lile pye of Salt Lake City Baritone or Bass Solo Contest Thy Sentinel Am jTatsOfl Prize 10 awarded to Viard Christopheron of Salt Lake City Choral Cdmh tton mixed voices not Jess than 40 nor more than 50 voices The TempestDr Parr First prize 150 second prize 50 Gold medal to conductor winning first prize First prize awarded to Lhi chOir Prof E Eeezle conductor second prize to Preston Ida choir Prof L D Edwards Ed-wards conductor Ladies Chorus ntestNot less than 30 por more than 40 voices Kings RosesParson Price First prize 100 second prize 25 Baton to onductor wInning first prize First prize won by Sal Lake Chorus Madame Swenson conductor no second award Tenor Solo ContestEver Yale Shall be ExatedHandels Messiah Prize 10 awarded to lr H 1 Thomas of Salt Lake City Humorous Recitation ContestMan Twains Experience wIth European Guides Prize 10 awarded to Miss Catherine Butler of Sal Lake City Male Quartette ContestLead Kindly Kind-ly Light Prize 16 awarded t Mesrs Ashworth Chrstopheron Patrick and Best of Salt Lake City Contralto Solo ContestCreole Love SongDudle BlCK Prize 10 awarded to Miss Emma Ramsay of Provo Grand Choral Contest mixed voices hors to number not less than 100 nor more than 125 voices a l Men All ThingsMendelssohn b Night Songtephens First prize 500 second prize 100 A handfome gold medal to the conductor winning first prize baton to conductor winning second sec-ond prize First prize awarded to Salt rake chorus under Prof Evan Stephens Steph-ens second prize to Ogden chorus under un-der I of Squir Coop EISTEDDFOD AFTERMATH Anent the discussion as to whom tp honors belong for the training of Miss RamSYs yoke for the Eist dfod contest con-test b Herald ha received commu nicatons both from Miss Ramsey and Mrs De Leery From these i seems that Mrs De Loer and Efe Dean Knappen each gave good instruction but Miss Ramsey chooses to give most creIit to Mrs Knapfen From a digest di-gest of the whole matter The Herald thinks the honor are about equal and chooses to let the ipatter drop To whomsoever belongs time credit Miss Ramsey certainly has a very beautiful voice G Mrs Bessie Dean Allison one Of our foremost contralto singers formerly of tiis city but now of Ogden came dowt to attend the Eisteddfod and the opera She was a guest of Mrs H J Grant and occupied the stage box with heron her-on the first evenings presentation of the Queens Lace Handkerchief She returned borne yesterday morning Mrs Woodvard the dainty little woman who charmed all who heard her sing at the Eisteddfod will rernaia in the city for a few days visiting with friends SIte was yesterday the guest of Miss Mabel Davis Dr Parry was very enthusiastic in praise of the voice of Mrs Lizzie Thomas Edward and urged her to give it a course of training under some first Olass foreign tutor Among the many souvenirs of his visit to Utah which Dr Parry took to his home In Wales none seemed to please him more than the photographs made by the Johnson company and which he stated were the most lifelike apd natural of any ever made of him He was als very much pleased with the large photo made In th tabernacle shcwing the choir Professors Stephens and DaynesMadaine Swenson and himself him-self end also the great organ with Its electric star and the word Utah This photo Is to be framed and have the choiqest space in his studio |