SMOOT WINS BIG VICTORY SUGAR TO BE PROTECTED FINAL VOTE 1 L IS 13 DE k i Utah Man Breaks the Ranks o othe of r. r the Insurgent Senators anc and Gets the Votes of Two o ol of Them on the Schedules C h. h VOTE ON INCOME TAX IS HELD ov OVER TO JUNE 10 Aldrich Ardrich and Bailey Clash Crash Over ff This but the Republican nj 1 Leader Takes the Texan Into J. J Camp With Good Vote TILLMAN THANKS CREATOR Washington May 27 After After the most spirited contest that has marked discussion of the income tax in the senate Senator Senator Senator Sena Sena- tor Aldrich succeeded late this afternoon in having it thrown over until June 10 for a vote In this fight Bailey and Aldrich Aldrich Aldrich Al Al- clashed on the surface at least and the battle battie narrows narrows narrows nar nar- rows down to a struggle between between between be be- tween the tw two leaders The sugar schedules protecting protecting protecting protect protect- ing Utah sugar were approved ved vedby by the senate vIctor victory was complete completo and Sinai It Is accepted d as meaning defeat at this session of oC Income tax l legisla tion Uon On his motion to postpone action on the tAX lax amendments to thu tho to bill n. n certain date dato lie tie broke broko oroKo i tb a mc 6 and Li but thud Jey f T Jt I Ud id d l-ceu l tty y nn and o tf t ot of tc tn ta r nf can u wo would old 1 t on on ona a a. trial o of strength 1 to to II got gt the Income e tax lax vote ote at the cut cur llo i t d dy y y The vote was 50 O to lo 33 3 The Tho TheIx vix Ix Republicans Republican standing fast to the Income tax were were- D ah rah w Clapp Cummins Dolliver and Lal 01 Jette McEnery Democrat of Louisiana Louisiana Louisi Louisi- ana voted with tho the Republicans The debate te over the tho parliamentary move libya emphasized the differences that exist among amon income tax lax senators over 9 an Income tax plan pan Cummins who J 1 an amendment differing from u 1 Baileys Bailey's stated that those who favored avo red I his plan could not accept the Bailey Dailey J r IrIan although he would vote for the i Bailey amendment in preference to no amendment He lie could not hold hod his followers against tho the Aldrich scheme schema vA v jr of or postponement of ot action i upon the ther r- r amendments until tho the tar tariff bill was f out of oC tho wa way f. Senator Victorious Senator moot noot was victorious on his sugar schedules uleK Ho lie heat down nil alt i. i amendments reducing the duty and andI I changing the classification by decisive e f i majorities The vote on fl abandonment of oC tho the Dutch standard test in measurement measure measure- ment of or strength of or t sugar ugar was 36 for forto or ori i to 17 against The Tha amendment to reduce reo re- re o duce uce tho ho dut duty on refined sugar from ii cents to 1825 18 5 cents per pound was F beaten 5 03 3 to 3 32 Both wore were offered b by F. F a Republican of ot Kans Kansas a voted Eleven Republican insurgents with on the tho amendment In Jog out tho the Dutch standard They were wore FT l' l Bristow Brown Clapp Crawford Cummins Dolliver Jones r LaFollette and Two o insurgents r Burkett and Gamble voted with Mr t. t moot Smoot All the Democrats voted in the tho affirmative with the Republican i i I. I gents g except Foster and McEnery of or V the sugar cano state stalo of or Louisiana LI l The amendment to reduce time the duty dut wa was supported by only SIx eix Ix Republicans Beveridge Bristow Clapp Cra Crawford I and Nelson Tho Tue Democratic ic vole vote was the same as on the previous r amendment Mr Cummins said that tha with free sugar from Hawaii the A. A Philippines and perhaps from Cuba Cuha the ther r r f beet sugar Industry in the tile United States would be wiped out entirely 1 i. i You cannot favor both protection of ot I b cane eamie sugar refiners cud ant beet sugar SUlar i manufacturers In this hill bill he ho declared pi 1 1 You are at the thIC parting of oC the tho ways You must either elthor decide for one or theL the tho I L other for tor the tho human intelligence cannot can can- rt t. t not hot put down this natural conflict t. t Mr Ir Cummins said laid tho tue free Cree admission w. w It of or sugar r from tho the Philippines would the islands but would Injure the d f United States But It may bo be that Toy my idea or of the white whito mans man's burden may mayr r lead leRl me to vote for that tJ provision iii 1 when we reach It said he nut I 1 do o so 80 with my ey eyes eves s Wide open