Show 33T IXSST NATTONAIiS PAVOB Judge Hiles Decides Case of Thum vs Pingree et al ig a Judge Hiles yesterday hade down dow-n decision In the case of C E Tum receiver VR James Plngree et al The fclilt Involved the legality of a cam t certain warrants of Bin ha and Fremont counties Idaho The warts wa-rts had been deposited with the Chase National bank of New York a debt by Bunt collateral security for a But lag C Bunting Co failed and a receiver was appointed whereupon the First National bank transferred its demand de-mand to the Chase National bank which attached the warrants Judg nvnt was duly obtained and the warrants war-rants sold on ex < cution and bought in by the Chase National bank and by them turned over to tue First National bank Suit was brought by Thum the r ielver to compel the First National t deliver the warrants on his paying the amount for which they had been Seld in pledge by the Chase National bank The court held that the First bank bank rightly ha possession of the warrants which were merely evidences of debt and not the debt itself it-self selfThe question of the value of the war queston rants to the holders thereof must be decided by the courts of Idaho |