Show AGAINST MEN A OP 0 TRE TEE CANI NOT BE MADE HADE mandamus to compel carlisle to continue I 1 the provision Is 13 infused slay appeal the cazze case washington jan 8 the district court of ct today to day affirmed the decision or of the district prom court refusing to arant the miles 6 usar jani planting Com company piny afi of Lou Loul lElani riana a mandamus co compelling elling secretary carlile carim and ana internal rev nev endue commissioner miller to proc cued under the law awarding cup ir r botin notwithstanding its repeal by the new tariff law the was arr brought lit us as a epst sult suit an to the united states Fu Teme court is yet open to the planters the oae case having pone gone them in all the interior inferior nals tho the court in n at an opinion by judge shepherd hold that the repeal of the sugar bounty provisions provision ct of the icken an ley net by the be new tariff law was tin mediate nd complete anel and contained no exception or protection ol of anny right hold at the time or of the pa passie of the law by virtue of the provi provisions ions of the mcknley alty act consequently there re rc miltin no duty that the carlile Car lilB and riller ll ller might or could lawfully perfo m the court then mide the th fol following lonIng g literal remarks on the hs validity of the auz fulir r bounty provisions of the maxin ley icy daiv the feet fact tb alit it monys have been paid out under a doubtful 0 gumton abas a ble valid validity ty can have no great wel lit under 1 abere the th ciu quenon eston Is so hard to bo be raised in an minner manner but it if there had been a n alco by con conrest Conr cst and generally d in our aninion is so c learly clearly the validity of ahl this he mckenley let act that we could not be con strolled trolled I 1 ly y it in the performance olour of our duty no time no no runs run ngali nt t the people under the protection of our from whet what has haq ban said paid it f hows follows n hit tile th judge jl limet lim nt below the p petition anut be in all thins thin s ani nied and it Is ordered ered |