SOUTH CAROLINA LIQUOR Charleston S C May IIn the United States circuit court today W Gibbs Whaley representing the dispensary dis-pensary constables filed a return to the order of Judge Simonton granted on the suit of Joseph Donald requiring them to show cause why they should not be perpetually enjoined against seizing liquors in the state for private consumption consumpton The return denies that the court has jurisdiction denies the various allegations alle-gations of Donald and declares the suit against the state in violation of the amendment to the constitution No arguments were made