Show fin ahe dally JR on a Coin plaint I 1 barging or he lit G nn anler eram caso as till B AI U 0 n allx tho oin plaint waa tatton ieli SM one J it mid lle tin p biad the 1 aab anil of 19 liy fl alline line libin u ali tf alli anil a inn dairal fan arnved bhail be dealt stilli uy II 11 who ad il alie caann for aliu city while en esrael rael or ali not dienel 1 complainant though boru kj lie was ik knitted to nian it la court naked alio AB bo linis ed as alie aernt of it afta overruled IWen dant aas arraigned and not keilly alq stated be ana riot ready for iclal ns liall tu lie anil there fuin alt lle diw ho r hi V flay sir to ita aa hie lal to fao eliat it anil 03 the all dir has a braw now niah hie nn 0 o act mr f lie aaa nut A in ogden but atas B cwi iwi ilent ot att ldla boty ty ifo hail to leive lake in elih mornine morn inc but it it nas necessary lift i oroa back it air aurl that until alie 0 lie desi reil by the alven and butil 11 biad been aliat they to libove by theale witnessed was no Well caU the aso for brinl and can tain n mr was sworn an took the lie stated i had leonn Bouie time last Bo nimer MW captain on main street at bis of tue tu e feb served a botie on hica for eonia he lud in his lion j hafl do you mean that I 1 paid yei lift then called me ft dd ald ivins 6 n of a h li I 1 edid it I 1 wua forty years younger I 1 talce eliat youre a liar and alj ou come diplo ade office ill settle it willi you retorted he also paid about swan corn crobia examination only went there 0 o serve the iio tire it a aa purely a matter vaa friendly with him defendant had TOO things he never would fulfill fulfil in this life conot part of it 1 was never so abused in ray life and I 1 hare been in many a mining camp tj mr be stated that when lie said he was friendly with him lie meant that lie bield no malice toward ji S watson of bilingham was floorn tie stated I 1 was pifei nt at the time alie trouble occurred I 1 met air aide out on main and he asked me to go nith ann to bettl a business mat ter MO merit to air handell him the lie arpad it ho then said do you mean that yea sir all I 1 want is ny said mr rideout Kide out aliddie iniss then eaid d olds a of a b b I 1 will pet you if yon come into the office ill bliok hotl all about it he said besides that but I 1 biear what that wag ile was bol croas mr rideout that upon his air smith advised him not to ho abused that ay and eole had arrested air to this testimony aa immaterial alie was au stained captin wanceil to know who air amith mentioned air pointed liim out mr that alie city would rest here n ith the understanding that alm prosecution prote cution be permitted to bring in evidence to prove that anch words aa those by witnesses lor the prosecution were knitli defendant and would be used by him with but little provocation mr was sworn and testified in aa follows I 1 was at the door of my office on slain talking with some atran 1 mr carlyle being the only man knew air came up with air watson and handed me a letter inaki ofa demand on me I 1 objected to that letter and asked him if he he said he did knowing the statements contained therein to be balne I 1 eaid do you mean to bay this lie raid yes I 1 after all I 1 have done for liae you gone in with the swan combination to persecute me lie said lie was not in the swan combination I 1 said you must bean old liar your son in law calls you a fraud ho then said perhaps ou will call me a thieving old scoundrel I 1 paid 1 I dont call you that you have said ft yourself and ft the cap its you you it 1 detata and emphatically that I 1 neier used the terina by mr and I 1 otate it the ednaa 0 uy oath this if a of the vt the hwan auch men as smith croas he the trouble occurred before noon mr carlyle present witness did not know whether ho biad the letter of mr him would nit bacar fedij not hao it till he looked into bia Ier hapa you bould like to fee hafl bonin bon in laws letter at the same time 7 said ahle alie pockets yes sir I 1 mould like to eee that too you have mentioned it replied sir bogere the betler was not aund but the eon in law a letter was there all right As the other wan not produced mr edgers ine na overruled hie letter being read was found to be dated at brovo the contents reflected upon mr character calling liick a fraud of his polygamous poly Amous liina whose had been covered by tha writer I 1 II 11 Snit nona and stated that he donld not feed alm any lonser so lie biad to hll back upon bs old diet carrots and etc cross w as continued elsaid ls aid do yon mean it 7 and he answered ho did I 1 bald that if he firant it he was an oll liar lie said per haia you will call ino a thieving rascal or blidt edoll I 1 aard 1 I dont say that ant if you will come in the ill chow you i a letter from your gon in law in which he calls you a fraud witness daiil not call him a thre vin scoundrel h of a t h or any lucli language ai a i alie inena of from for mr lUde out it vaa tho unlit mas defrauding the i oh I 1 wanted liin mr Si ramona coloring up I 1 am y tho evidencia evid enca icy received iak tor at least so a in any on I 1 leave ken hia iceney froin irme M time that H what I 1 meant by the expression after all ive done for on there waa transact iliin tolk of the junction city also as bitted bim athla waa sa ar aa the defence coad go being abacot iad ie caw wai monday a 9 nm being oil a bond of t 0 mr Kide RO to balti lake marniok to w ft lie lia not been fir beam arti r torn in tune to alit iut alio brittl oil bionday SIon day |